Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, North America | Analysis

POLITICS-US: Eyes Wide Shut in Colombia

Analysis - Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Jul 29 1999 (IPS) - The United States appeared Thursday to be stumbling ever deeper into the multi-faceted conflict of drugs, insurgency, and banditry that has made Colombia the most violent country in Latin America.

The presence in Bogota of Washington’s drug czar, retired General Barry McCaffrey, and the recovery Wednesday of the remains of four of five US soldiers whose reconnaissance plane crashed into a mountainside near the Ecuador border last week, highlighted the growing US role in Colombia.

Colombia, the biggest source of cocaine and a growing source of heroin for the US market, already is the third biggest recipient of US military assistance, after Israel and Egypt. About 200 US military personnel are stationed in Colombia for training, reconnaissance, intelligence, and crop-eradication operations.

The administration of President Bill Clinton currently is considering requests that would more than double the amount of military aid to Colombia and deepen Washington’s involvement in the country’s 30-year-old civil conflict.

But the administration remains deeply split about what it should do in the Andean nation.

It has supported the year-long effort by President Andres Pastrana to initiate a peace process with the guerrillas of the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC). As recently as last week, Clinton reiterated his support for Pastrana, noting that “until the civil discord in Colombia is brought to an end, it is going to be much, harder for us to restrain the activities of the narcotraffickers there.”

Political analysts, however, now believe this policy has been badly – perhaps fatally – weakened by recent events and that officials like McCaffrey and others at the Pentagon, who favour increased military aid and training for Colombia’s army, are winning the internal battle almost by default.

“What’s happening is that people with views like his are filling the policy vacuum,” says Michael Shifter, a Colombia expert at the Inter-American Dialogue (IAD) think tank.

“The people who want more military aid are in the driver’s seat now.”

They still face opposition from some elements in the National Security Council and the State Department who worry that increasing military aid will almost certainly escalate the violence in Colombia, while destroying the flickering hopes for peace talks without substantially reducing the drug trade.

“A big military aid package will add fuel to the fire,” according to Winifred Tate, an analyst at the Washington Office on Latin America, a non-governmental human-rights group.

Despite a steady rise in counter-narcotics aid over the past decade, drug production in Colombia actually has increased, she says.

“Even some people in the US military admit that defeating FARC (which Washington accuses of drug-trafficking) will not impact on the drug trade.”

For supporters of the peace process, the last few weeks have brought one disappointment after another.

A major offensive by FARC rebels, which brought fighting to within 40 kms of Bogota, underlined both the weakness of the army and the continuing aggressiveness of the insurgents – despite their year-old commitment to engage in negotiations.

The indefinite postponement of those negotiations, just hours before they were set to begin, also highlighted the weakness of the peace process itself, according to analysts.

At the same time, the visit here of Colombia’s defence minister Luis Ramirez and armed forces chief-of-staff Gen. Fernando Tapias, provided a platform for the Colombians to press for some 500 million dollars in new US military aid.

Republican lawmakers, who enjoy a majority in Congress, quickly endorsed their request

Not to be outdone, McCaffrey submitted his own request for one billion dollars in additional emergency aid to fight drug- trafficking in the Americas next year, 600 million dollars of which would be earmarked for Colombia.

Bogota already is receiving almost 300 million dollars in anti- drug aid from the United States this year – three times what it received in 1998.

Most of the money goes to the national police but about 40 million dollars is earmarked for the Colombian military, subject to assurances that none of it goes to army units accused of serious human rights abuses or to right-wing paramilitaries, who are responsible for the worst violence in Colombia today.

The fundamental problem is that Washington cannot decide what its top priority is in Colombia and how aid to the army, whose main goal is to defeat the insurgency, relates to accomplishing that objective.

“Is it, in fact, the purpose of US policy in Colombia to defeat the guerrillas?” the IAD’s Shifter asked in column printed in the Los Angeles Times. “Is it to reduce drug production or, taking a page from the US role in El Salvador in the 1980s, is it to ‘level the playing field’ – which would enhance the Colombian government’s leverage to negotiate peace with the insurgents?”

The answer has been “all of the above,” Shifter says, because McCaffrey, the Pentagon and influential Republican lawmakers see the insurgents – who tax drug production in areas under their control – as the enemy in the drug war.

That assessment, however, blurs the distinctions between the anti-drug fight and a counter-insurgency war despite the fact that, while inter-related, the two are quite distinct.

“The argument is that, by increasing support to the military, the US can accomplish a range of objectives, when, in fact, those objectives may be mutually exclusive,” Tate says.

The commitment of as much money as is being requested, as well as the commitment of more US troops, such as those who died in last week’s plane crash, requires a major debate about the wisdom and coherence of the present course, according to both Tate and Shifter.

“After so much attention was paid to avoiding US casualties in Kosovo, here we have five deaths, and barely a ripple,” Tate adds.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags