Sunday, November 22, 2026
Abid Aslam
- Some 1.2 billion poor people in developing countries pay on average 12 times more for water than do their better-off compatriots, say world water experts.
And, cut off from municipal systems, the poor are forced to buy water off the back of a truck and often get a diseased swill responsible for some four million deaths per year, according to the multi-donor World Commission on Water for the Twenty-first Century.
That is a gross injustice – but also a business opportunity, says the group, which will meet in Stockholm Aug 9-10 to discuss ways of raising 31-35 billion dollars that it says will be needed annually to provide universal access to water by the year 2010.
“The poorest developing countries are unlikely to have the funds, even through international aid, to finance such development” and therefore must tap transnational corporations and domestic investors, according to a Commission statement.
Otherwise, the number without safe water will rise to 2.3 billion by 2025, warns Commission Chairman Ismail Serageldin. Needs will be especially acute in cities, which face 160 percent population growth by 2030, compared with 10 percent in the countryside.
The Commission’s thrust toward commercialisation of water supplies could well test the adage that “water has sank more grievances than wine,” observers opined.
Public workers in Paraguay have threatened a general strike over privatisation plans, which they see as a union-busting effort. The World Bank, reportedly dissatisfied with stalled water deregulation, has suspended a 46-million-dollar loan to the country, according to news reports.
French water companies have met resentment in Argentina, where they have raised prices beyond agreed levels and threatened to cut off people who can’t pay.
South African workers and community groups have been fighting water privatisation plans amid evidence that other public services – including waste disposal – have suffered after being sold.
“Clearly, unit costs of providing water must be reduced,” says Serageldin, who also is a vice president at the World Bank.
The poor nevertheless manage to find money for water and this can be parleyed into profits for reputable suppliers, Commission officials argue.
“Although conventional wisdom holds that poor people cannot afford to pay for the household water they need, a survey shows that both rural and urban poor are willing to pay higher fees in order to have a reliable and safe water supply,” says William Cosgrove, director of the World Water Vision Unit.
This organisation is drafting public policy guidelines and a list of private investment opportunities to be adopted next March.
As it is, poor people pay five times the municipal rate for water in Abidjan, Cote d’Ivoire; 25 times more in Dhaka, Bangladesh; and 40 times more in Cairo, Egypt, according to the World Commission on Water.
“They are paying so much that they can only afford to buy cups of water to drink, not 40 litres per day,” the minimum necessary to meet basic human needs, says Commission consultant Arienne Naber.
Private firms have waded into developing countries’ water markets over the past decade with decidedly mixed results, Naber acknowledges.
Many firms have sought out higher-end customers, leaving government to meet the needs of the poor but “if governments provide the right regulatory framework, they can ensure that services do reach the poor,” she says.
Setting the right framework will mean striking a balance between governments’ duty to protect the public interest and private investors’ demands for tax breaks and guarantees that water prices will not be controlled but allowed to float with the market.
Proponents of privatisation say it is necessary because governments no longer have the money to spend on water infrastructure and delivery.
National co-financing of World Bank water projects fell from an average of 34 percent in the late 1980s to around 10 percent in the early 1990s, notes Naber, and the difference has had to be made up with increased private investment.
Critics, however, say that the need to privatise is a consequence of misguided government priorities, exacerbated by the Third World debt crisis.
Governments have had to spend more on debt servicing and less on public programmes, says Brendan Martin, author of the 1993 book ‘In the Public Interest? Privatisation and Public Sector Reform.’
“While recession, structural adjustment programmes and other problems have undermined the ability of local authorities the world over to provide their communities with well-resourced integrated public services, a group of transnational companies has grown up on the strength of running those that can be paid for privately,” according to Martin.
Some firms have made inroads into the developing world thanks to contracts won under international loans, in return for ‘tied aid’ from their governments, and under agreements sealed during the transition from colonial rule.
Cote d’Ivoire’s urban water, for example, has been supplied by the local subsidiary of a French company ever since the West African country won independence in 1960.
“We will probably never know” whether direct public provision would have worked better, says Martin, but the company relied heavily on public subsidies when the economy soared – and scaled back rather than forgo profits when falling world commodity prices hit the country’s export earnings.
“During the 1970s the state was prepared to subsidise water connections to house owners in poorer areas of the city but the programme fell off in the early 1980s because of a shortage of public funds,” according to Canadian researcher Richard Stren.
As a result, “the rate of added connections fell from 8,000 per year in 1977 to 2,300 in 1982.”
This happened just as farmers, faced with weak agricultural prices, flocked to Abidjan in search of jobs. Shanty towns mushroomed along the city’s fringe and a swarm of vendors began trucking in water and gouging prices.
If experience in Britain – where water prices and the number of people disconnected for non-payment both zoomed upwards after deregulation in the early 1990s – is any indication, “privatisation of water offers no solution,” Martin adds.