Development & Aid, Environment, Headlines, North America

AGRICULTURE: Risks in Bolstering Livestock Farming

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Oct 29 1999 (IPS) - The anticipated growth in demand for meat and dairy products in developing countries will require increased large-scale production of livestock in those countries, says a report from international agricultural research institutes released here Friday.

Environmental and small-farm advocacy groups in the United States are on record, however, with a warning that promoting increased livestock production and the accompanying large-scale factory farming in developing countries does not increase food security and could threaten small farmers.

Growth in large-scale livestock production will lead instead to increased deforestation, pollution of water supplies, similar to what has occurred in the United States, the groups say.

Currently, the 23 percent of the world’s population living in industrialised nations consume three to four times the meat and fish and five ties the milk per capita as those in developing countries.

But from 1970 to 1990 the combined per capita consumption of meat, eggs, and milk in developing countries grew by about 50 percent, says the new report by the UN Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO), the Washington-based International Food Policy Research Institute and the Kenya-based International Livestock Research Institute.

During that same time period, the consumption of meat in developing countries grew by 70 million metric tons, whereas in developed countries grew by only 26 million metric tons, says the report titled ‘Livestock to 2020, The Next Food Revolution.’

“As incomes rise and cities grow, people in developing countries are eating more meats, eggs, and dairy products,” it says.

“By 2020 the developing countries are expected to produce 95 million metric tons more meat by year and the developed countries 20 million metric tons more compared to production levels observed in the early 1990s,” says the 72-page report.

To deal with the increase in demand and, what it called an inevitable increase in production, the report suggests governments of developing countries develop strong institutions that would regulate pollution control technologies of large-scale livestock producers.

Without such policies, “the result may be a livestock industry dominated by a few large producers, with few opportunities for poor farmers and little control of environmental or health risks.”

‘Livestock to 2020’ said developing nations should foster institutions that allow small scale farmers to be integrated with large-scale livestock processors and input suppliers in a way that is just and equitable.

But Farm Animal Reform Movement (FARM), a Maryland-based advocacy organisation, argues that any promotion of large-scale agribusiness would hurt small farmers in developing countries.

“Imposition of exploitative factory farming contracts by international agribusiness firms on indigenous farmers is a form of agricultural colonialism that should not be tolerated by developing countries,” says a statement by the organisation.

While ‘Livestock to 2020’ discussed the environmental and social risks usually caused by that large-scale livestock production, FARM says focusing on animal products will not help feed growing populations.

“Livestock in factory farms will be fed grains and legumes that could feed more people directly, thus creating food shortages,” the group says in its statement.

Animal products provide but a small fraction of the calories and protein provided by plant foods per hectare of arable land, according to FARM. The organisation also warns that increasing the production of livestock will raise the price of grains and therefore lead to widespread famines in developing countries.

FARM recommends the promotion of policies that will reduce meat and milk consumption in industrialised countries thus freeing up grains and legumes to feed developing nations.

Environmentalists also point to the pollution problems caused by large-scale livestock production in the United States.

“Promoting this style of farming would be a huge mistake given our own track record on this,” says Ed Hopkins of the Sierra Club. Spills and leakages from manure lagoons or cesspools on factory farms can cause fish kills, toxic red algae tides, and threaten waterways used for recreation and drinking.

The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) recently estimated that out of 35,000 river miles have been polluted by livestock waste. And in 17 states ground water pollution has resulted from large-scale agro-industry.

According to a report by the Washington-based Clean Water Network, in the June through September period of 1995, nearly 30 million gallons of manure and urine killed at least 200,000 fish in 13 separate cesspool spills in the states of North Carolina, Iowa, Minnesota, and Missouri.

The environmentalists accuse government officials of being slow to regulate the pollution coming from the lucrative factory farms.

Pollution from huge pig farms in North Carolina – where the hog population has grown faster than any state in the nation – is widespread, especially since recent storms and subsequent flooding distributed the pig waste, further contaminating water supplies.

According to a project called ‘Hog-Watch’ by the Environmental Defense Fund, North Carolina’s hogs produce a mind-boggling 19 million tons of feces and urine a year, or more than 50,000 tons of waste every day.

That is more waste in one year than the entire human population of the nearby city of Charlotte, North Carolina produces in 58 years, according to the environmental group.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags