Headlines, North America | Analysis

POLITICS-US: Return of Fortress America?

Analysis - Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Oct 18 1999 (IPS) - President Bill Clinton waded into the Republican dominated US Senate this week for refusing to ratify the Comprehensive Test Bank Treaty (CTBT) that he called the latest in a series of signs of a “new isolationism.”

Clinton and his fellow-Democrats were not alone in believing Republicans were returning to their “Fortress America” stance which dominated the party in the 1930’s – even when Washington’s closest European allies were being attacked by Nazi Germany.

“I am concerned by what I see as a growing isolationism in the Republican Party,” Republican presidential candidate, Sen. John McCain, told the influential ‘National Journal’ recently.

An analysis in the New York Times compared the Republicans’ rejection of the CTBT to their predecessors’ refusal to ratify the Treaty of Versailles after World War I.

That historic vote in 1920 – which ended President Woodrow Wilson’s liberal internationalism and effectively torpedoed the League of Nations – marked the last time before Wednesday’s defeat of the CTBT that the Senate rejected a major international treaty.

Republicans by and large kept to their isolationist policies for 20 years until Japanese warplanes attacked on Pearl Harbor in 1941. Indeed, only when the Cold War was fully underway by the early 1950’s did the Republican Party, under President Dwight Eisenhower, adopt a more internationalist outlook.

But, with the end of the Cold War some 40 years later, the rationale for those internationalist policies – that Washington needed to maintain its alliances and global engagement in order to defeat the overriding Soviet threat – ceased to be relevant.

As a result, Republicans have been engaged for almost a decade now in a kind of foreign-policy identity crisis.

That became clear already in 1991, when then-President George Bush – a consummate Republican internationalist – came under fire from a number of right-wing Republicans for sacrificing US blood and resources to save Gulf sheikhdoms and protect Europe’s access to Arab oil.

Bush’s defeat by Clinton marked a major turning point in the Republican drift from internationalism which became much more pronounced after the 1994 Congressional elections swept the Republicans to power on Capitol Hill and brought a whole new generation of right-wing Republicans to Washington.

Unlike many of the older generation, the new lawmakers had little or no memory of World War II and virtually no interest in affairs beyond US borders. Many of them do not even possess a passport.

“I’ve been to Europe once,” bragged House Majority Leader Dick Armey last year. “I don’t need to go again.”

While that attitude has proven embarrassing to internationalists such as McCain, it helps explains a series of moves by Republicans in recent years that many analysts see as a clear trend toward isolationism. These include:

– their refusal to approve some 1.7 billion dollars in arrears the United States owes the United Nations.

– persistent Republican efforts to slash US foreign aid and other international programmes.

– their resistance to US troops acting as peacekeepers in global troublespots such as Rwanda, Bosnia, Kosovo and East Timor.

– their opposition to the Kyoto Protocol to combat global warming.

– lavish funding for the deployment of a hugely costly system to shield US territory from foreign missiles; and now their defeat of the CTBT.

“Certainly there is nothing new about partisan tensions between the White House and Congress over the extent of America’s international entanglements,” wrote the National Journal’s James Kitfield.

“But if 20th-century history is any guide, the intensity and frequency of recent disputes signal that the worldview of the Republican Party is changing in important ways.”

Clinton characterised that worldview harshly in his press conference the day after the CTBT was defeated. “The idea that the best way for us to go forward – since right now at this particular moment in history we enjoy (our) greatest wealth and power – is to build this big old wall and tell our friends and neighbours to go take a hike …will (make for) a bleak, poor, less secure world.”

The attitude conveyed by Republican isolationists to US friends and foes alike, he said, was “…as far as we’re concerned, any (one) might be an enemy, and anything you want to do with your money is fine with us because we have more money than you do, so whatever you do, we’ll do more…”

In fairness, that summary does not by any means describe the view of the entire party, or even necessarily a majority.

Seventeen of 55 Republican senators joined Democrats and the administration in making a last-minute appeal to their leadership to put off the CTBT vote rather than to defeat the treaty. And many senior Republicans stressed afterwards that Washington should continue to observe a seven-year moratorium on US nuclear testing in hopes that the treaty can be resurrected.

But ultimately even these more internationalist-minded Republicans put their partisan loyalties ahead of their personal convictions, thus dooming the treaty, betraying 40 years of bipartisan US arms-control and disarmament initiatives, and humiliating the president.

Recent polls suggest that this new isolationism has very limited public support. One taken in June found that 82 percent of citizens support the CTBT.

Large majorities in the past 10 years have declared their belief that Washington should pay its UN dues unconditionally and in full; contribute US troops to UN peacekeeping missions; increase aid to poor countries; do more to combat global environmental problems and forgo unilateral actions without the support of other countries.

That is one reason why Clinton and other Democrats believe they can make Republican isolationism and the CTBT a winning campaign theme in next year’s presidential elections.

“The self-destructiveness of the Republicans is awesome,” wrote foreign-policy analyst James Chace in the New York Times Friday, but others are not so sure.

“While Americans are still interested in foreign affairs and think foreign policy is important in choosing a President, there are numerous studies indicating that the way they vote is far more influenced by domestic issues,” according to Steven Kull, director of the Programme on International Policy Attitudes at the University of Maryland.

That seems to have become particularly true since the end of the Cold War and the absence of any credible threat to US security.

In many ways, Clinton, despite his own internationalist and multilateralist views, has contributed to the public’s disinterest in foreign affairs and thus strengthened isolationist Republicans.

In his 1992 campaign slogan, “It’s the economy, stupid,” Clinton tried hard to contrast Bush’s interest in foreign affairs with his own focus on domestic affairs.

His attention to foreign-policy issues has been sporadic and reactive at best. His virtually total failure to mount a serious public campaign to secure the CTBT’s ratification – like UN arrears and foreign aid – already has drawn withering criticism, even from loyal Democrats.

“With Clinton, the rhetoric and instincts have always been right, but the follow-through is never there,” according to one Congressional veteran.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags