Headlines

RIGHTS-CANADA: Supreme Court Scales Back Indigenous Rights

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Nov 27 1999 (IPS) - The Supreme Court of Canada, in a “clarification” of a previous verdict on native fishing rights, has denied that its ruling granted indigenous communities aboriginals access to forestry, mineral and oil resources on government-owned lands.

The high court underscores the point that native fishermen on the east coast of Canada are subject to federal regulations – which could include a closed fishery – in exercising their 1760 treaty right to hunt, fish and gather resources for a “moderate livelihood.”

The court made the declarations in a “clarification” of Sept. 17 ruling on a treaty signed in 1760 between the Mi’kmaq tribe and the British government.

The court claims that its September decision had been misinterpreted both by indigenous groups and non-natives who believed it gave the Mi’kmaq free access to all fish and game in eastern Canada and made them immune from government regulations.

Not only do natives not have an unrestricted right to fish, the Ottawa government even can impose regulations to limit their treaty rights to ensure there is “fairness” and recognition of the “historical reliance upon, and participation in, the fishery by non-aboriginal groups.”

The 30-page clarification concerned the case of Donald Marshall, a Cape Breton Mi’kmaq acquitted of fishing for eel without a license and out of season.

Marshall became a leader of the Mi’kmaq community after serving 17 years for a murder that he did not commit. An independent commission found that his original conviction had been on racism by police and court officials.

The Marshall judgment prompted hundreds of native Canadians to hunt for lobster in the off-season and led to violent protests by commercial fishermen who fear their fishery will be put in jeopardy.

During the protests, cars and buildings were burned in aboriginal communities, people were beaten, and thousands of native-owned lobster traps destroyed.

On the other hand, natives from across Canada and the United States traveled to eastern Canada to kill moose out of season, cut logs on government land, and fish.

Native leaders in Nova Scotia and New Brunswick, who thought the original decision opened access to all natural resources, say they feel betrayed by the new court ruling.

“The Supreme Court has given in to mob rule and vigilantism to let them get their way,” says Lawrence Paul, co-chairman of the Atlantic Policy Congress of First Nations. “The Supreme Court has hurt its credibility today by backtracking. I am not happy.”

Paul, who is also chairman of the Assembly of Nova Scotia Mi’kmaq Chiefs, calls the decision a victory for the non- aboriginal fishermen who destroyed Mi’kmaq lobster traps.

“I think they backed off a little bit and they gave in to mob and vigilante rule,” he says. “They set a bad precedent as far as I’m concerned, because if they make some other decision that makes a large group of people angry, they’ll resort to the same tactics.”

Robert Levi, Mi’kmaq chief of Big Cove, New Brunswick’s largest reserve, says the decision will erode his people’s faith in the justice system.

“I’m not surprised. Every time that we get our rights, you get the federal government and the provincial government combining and trying to get our rights watered down to nothing, and that’s exactly what they’re doing again,” he says.

The West Nova Fishermen’s Coalition, a non-indigenous group that sought the court clarification, cheered the decision, saying it achieved everything it wanted.

Don Cunningham, the coalition president, said he hopes the clarification will calm fishermen’s fears that their livelihood was threatened. “There’s no doubt that this has taken away a lot of the things that the natives thought they had.”

In its 6-0 decision, the Supreme Court dealt a reprimand to Canadian Indian Affairs minister Bob Nault, who supported the view of the Native Council of Nova Scotia that the Marshall ruling extended native rights to natural resources on Crown lands.

“No evidence was drawn to our attention…that trade in logging or minerals, or the exploitation of offshore natural gas deposits, was in the contemplation of either or both parties to the 1760 treaty,” the court ruled.

“Certain unjustified assumptions are made in this regard by the Native Council of Nova Scotia on this motion about ‘the effect of the economic treaty right on forestry, minerals and natural gas deposits offshore.

“It will be open to an accused in future cases to try to show that the treaty right was intended in 1760 by both sides to include access to resources other than fish, wildlife and traditionally gathered things such as fruit and berries.”

The court decision also appears to rule out extending native rights to logging, mining and oil extraction by explaining that the Sept. 17 judgment dealt with “the types of the resources traditionally ‘gathered’ in an aboriginal economy.”

The Supreme Court is the highest judicial body in Canada. Only the country’s Parliament can over-ride its decisions.

Despite the ruling, Nault says he believes future court judgments could favor expanding native rights to natural resources, which is why he is determined to negotiate new arrangements with aboriginals and the provinces.

“Instead of the courts defining our relationship as a country with First Nations, we as politicians and as leaders should do it and stop letting the courts have to make the tough decisions that politicians should make,” he says.

The Supreme Court says the Marshall decision granted the Mi’kmaq year-round fishing rights for eels because Ottawa did not provide a justification for closing that fishery. Eels are not an endangered species and there is no significant non-native commercial fishery, it notes.

The courts add, however, that the government could justify restrictions for natives fishermen, such as a closed season, to conserve other species such as lobster, scallops, cod and crabs.

“Conservation always has been recognized to be a justification of paramount importance to limit the exercise of a treaty and aboriginal rights,” the court says. “It is up to the Crown to initiate enforcement action in the lobster and other fisheries if and when it chooses to do so.”

Herb Dhaliwal, the Fisheries Minister, ruled out using the courts again to define the rights of natives to fish for lobster out of seasons, saying he prefers to follow the recommendation of the Supreme Court to negotiate a “modern agreement” on treaty rights with aboriginals.

“We have a choice. We can negotiate or we can keep going back to the courts over and over again to define all those things. My preference is to negotiate those rather than going back to courts,” Dhaliwal says.

He has appointed federal negotiators to find an interim arrangement to accommodate native fishermen’s rights and conservation concerns.

The court now states explicitly that closed seasons can be imposed on an aboriginal fishery, where justified “for conservation or other purposes.” It says the treaty right is enjoyed only by members of “an aboriginal community in Canada,” and specifies that the treaty right is a communal right that can be exercised only in “the area traditionally used by the local community.”

Will Moreira, a Halifax lawyer who represents commercial fishermen, said there will now be “a lot more equality” between native and non-native fishermen.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Environment, Headlines, Human Rights, North America

RIGHTS-CANADA: Supreme Court Scales Back Indigenous Rights

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Nov 22 1999 (IPS) - The Supreme Court of Canada, in a “clarification” of a previous verdict on native fishing rights, has denied that its ruling granted indigenous communities aboriginals access to forestry, mineral and oil resources on government-owned lands.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags