Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

(CONFLICT-EGYPT/ISRAEL): Setback for Foes of Normal Relations

Hossam Hassan

CAIRO, Jan 31 2000 (IPS) - Foes of normal relations between Egypt and Israel suffered a major setback when the left-wing Al-Tagammu Party decided to withdraw from The Anti-Normalisation Front, the group spearheading the drive to break ties between Cairo and Tel Aviv.

The party recently declared that it would also boycott the political and social activities of the group’s central committee, which includes representatives from opposition parties as well as from professional associations and trade unions.

Al-Tagammu was considered the most influential party in the group, given the fact that it was the first to establish a movement opposing formal and popular normalisation with Israel in 1979.

The movement was created as a reaction to the signing of the Camp David Accords by Egypt and Israel in November 1978.

Internal differences broke out in the anti-normalisation ranks about a month ago, when some members of the central committee lashed out at the leadership of Al-Tagammu accusing them of harbouring Zionist views.

Indeed, there were even some accusations of direct contacts between Al-Tagammu and Mossad, the Israeli secret service.

Appalled by the enormity of this accusation, Al-Tagammu officially requested that their detractors’ membership of the committee be revoked. However, the Nasserite Party another key member of the group–strongly opposed this request.

Political analysts consider Al-Tagammu’s withdrawal from the committee a serious blow to its activities considering that this particular party was by far its most prominent member.

Additionally, it wielded a great deal of authority within the committee, thanks to its strong influence among trade unionists, who represent one of the movement’s core constituencies.

Al-Tagammu’s assistant secretary general, Hussein Abdel Raziq, says that the party’s withdrawal does not necessarily mean that it would give up or even modify its anti-normalisation agenda.

“We have no plans to change our anti-normalisation and anti- Zionist principles; rather our withdrawal from the central committee was in protest against the slurs made upon our name.”

Abdel Raziq emphasised that the decision to withdraw is final and that the party’s political leadership will not reconsider unless the central committee agrees to revoke the membership of the party’s critics.

In contrast, the Nasserite Party described Al-Tagmmu’s decision as an over-reaction to a minor dispute. Assistant secretary-general Sameh Ashour said that the problem is too trivial to warrant withdrawal from the committee.

Disputes within the ranks of the Anti-normalisation Group should not necessarily mean a softening of the stance of any individual member against Cairo-Tel Aviv ties, but could produce a positive development in Egyptian-Israeli relations if Tel Aviv manages to reach a satisfactory agreement with Syrians and Palestinians, political analyst Mohamed Abdul-Maqsoud said.

The Anti-Normalisation Front suffered serious setbacks during the second half of the last year, with many members questioning the merit of its continued existence in its current form.

Meanwhile, anti-normalisation activists suffered another setback Saturday when a plan to introduce legislation against normal ties fizzled in open disagreement among some parliamentarians who had earlier pledged to back the move.

Ahmed Taha and Mahmoud Zeinhom, both independent members of the Egyptian People’s Assembly (parliament), were planning to give vent to their opposition to the 1979 Egyptian-Israeli peace treaty by submitting a bill to parliament calling for it to be repealed.

Taha and Zeinhom promoted the idea among other independent and opposition representatives, 10 of whom signed a “bill” urging the revocation of the treaty.

The initial plan was for the bill to be submitted to the People’s Assembly which consists of 445 members, on Saturday. Its signatories would then hold a news conference at the headquarters of the Wafd opposition party to make the announcement.

However, the deputies failed to show up in the parliament session and the news conference turned out to be a disappointment for all except the Wafdists, who appeared to have had a last-minute change of heart.

At the press conference, some deputies said they were surprised to hear that the Wafd Party wanted to amend, not abolish, the treaty and that the Wafd believed that the approval of all opposition parties was a prerequisite for submitting the bill to the Assembly.

“What abolition? Abolition is out of the question. We only want to amend some of the provisions of the treaty,” Fouad Badrawi, a Wafdist deputy said.

The assistant secretary-general of the Nasserite Party MP Sameh Ashour disagreed, calling for a united front ôto revoke the treaty.”

Ashour and most of the other deputies who signed the so-called bill are members of the Committee for Boycotting American and Israeli Goods, founded nearly three years ago.

The committee issues a monthly publication called The Arab Parliament. There are 18 opposition MPs and another 45 independents in the Egyptian parliament.

The proposed bill, which is not likely to make further legislative progress, described the 1979 peace treaty between Egypt and Israel as ôa violation of international law; (and) Egypt’s sovereignty over Sinaiö adding that ôthe treaty sanctioned Israel’s military, political and economic superiority.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags