Saturday, November 21, 2026
Sergei Blagov
- As Russia continues to lose billions of dollars in fleeing capital, both government officials and economists agree drastic measures have to be taken to stop the flow.
A variety of methods have been suggested, including a tax amnesty, but a viable solution has yet to materialise.
Economists say mostly people are taking out their money to avoid taxes, dodge domestic debts, hide stolen assets or because they lack confidence in the local banking system.
The illegal outpour of money is having a devastating effect on the country’s economy.
In macroeconomic terms Russia is reported to have fared favourably well last year recording an unprecedented foreign trade surplus.
Russia’s exports reportedly reached 72.9 billion US Dollars in 1999, while imports stood at 40.3 billion US Dollars. However, this healthy surplus has done little to heal the country’s economic woes as most of the money earned is being poured out.
Peter Westin, head of the Russia-European Centre For Economic Policy, a Moscow-based think tank, blames the situation on Russia’s failure to establish a functioning market environment.
He says macroeconomic instability, as well as the lack of confidence in the domestic banks and disincentives to re-invest profits, have encouraged companies and individuals to move their money off-shore.
In 1998 Russia’s Central Bank introduced the obligatory sale of 50 percent of export revenues. This was increased to 75 percent last year and there are now plans to raise it up to 100 percent.
Furthermore, in Aug 1999, the Central Bank issued a decree that resulted in weeks of chaos at airports and borders when foreigners were suddenly told they could not leave Russia with hard currency in cash without providing proof as to how those funds entered the country.
Officials said the new rules were aimed at Chinese and Vietnamese shuttle traders who were selling goods on Russian soil, converting earnings into dollars, and taking three million US Dollars to five million US Dollars, out of Russia every day.
However Western analysts slammed the move saying funds leaving the country in this way were a mere drop in the ocean compared to the amounts lost to unauthorised bank transfers and false export and import contracts.
According to Westin, efforts to impose regulatory curbs on the illegal transfer of money has had limited success. “As the new restrictions are introduced, economic actors usually find ways to circumvent them,” he says.
However, even some nations who are benefitting from Russian money, are getting nervous. On Thursday (Feb 10), the South Pacific island nation of Nauru, a zero-tax haven, promised to review its banking system following charges that Russian criminals were using its’ offshore finance centre to launder money.
A 1998-1999 report by the US State Department’s Bureau of International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs, the Russian organised crime syndicate was fully utilising Nauru’s banking facilities.
Russian officials estimate that tens of billions of US Dollars has been transferred illegally from Russia to banks in Nauru, Vanuatu, Western Samoa and the Cook Islands.
Other offshore destinations like Cyprus, Panama and the Virgin Islands are reported to provide more opportunities to those who are looking to circumvent Russia’s regulatory restrictions.
According to the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) Report for 1999, private capital flows pose more problems than solutions for the international financial system.
The report said Russia was one of the countries where liberalising trade as part of an export-led growth strategy had not paid off, implying that trade liberalisation was often premature.
Andrei Illarionov, director of the Institute of Economic Analysis, says the legal conversion of Russian roubles into foreign currency inside the country also amounts to capital flight.
He says the phenomenon can be described as “flight from roubles” and it reflects the people’s lack of confidence in the national currency.
“According to our calculations money lost to capital flight … did not exceed 100 billion US Dollars during the 1990s. Estimates like 300 to 400 billion US Dollars are simply baseless,” he says.
Desperate Government officials have hinted at amnesty as a viable option for the return of money illegally taken out of Russia.
Vyacheslav Soltaganov, director of Russia’s Federal Tax Police Service, says the money should be ‘legalised and amnestied so as to ensure its return home’.