Saturday, November 21, 2026
Jim Lobe
- The International Monetary Fund (IMF) should scrap its long-term lending programmes to poor countries because it lacks competence on issues such as reducing poverty, according to a new report signed by a number of US development policy heavyweights.
Released here Wednesday by the Washington-based Overseas Development Council (ODC), the report calls for the IMF to defer instead to the World Bank, on all long-term programmes – such as structural adjustment and debt reduction for the poorest nations – which have a major development impact.
In particular, the Fund’s main programme for development financing – the Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility (PRGF) – should be transferred to the World Bank, according to the report, which also calls for the IMF to restrict its lending activity to short-term stand-by agreements for countries with macro-economic problems only.
“The IMF is uniquely qualified in macroeconomic analysis, but it does not have expertise on poverty reduction, which is the major focus of long-term development finance,” the report says. It notes that the IMF’s efforts to impose conditionality on medium- and long-term loans generally have been ineffective.
“The IMF’s advice should still play a significant role in determining World Bank lending, but it should not have a veto, as that would essentially maintain the current state of affairs,” it stresses.
The report also calls for a re-allocation of voting power on the IMF’s board to give developing countries a greater voice.
Fourteen experts signed the report including a former vice president of the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB), Nancy Birdsall, and the controversial chief economist at the World Bank, Joseph Stiglitz, who resigned under pressure late last year. Stiglitz’s outspoken criticism of the IMF’s handling of the 1997- 99 Asian financial crisis angered top IMF and US Treasury officials.
Also participating in the ODC task force were representatives of prominent non-governmental organisations, including Oxfam International and Friends of the Earth, as well as influential US academics.
The report’s release comes just days before the annual spring meetings here of the boards of the Bank and the International Monetary Fund (IMF).
This year’s meetings are attracting unusual media attention both because of plans by thousands of environmental, labour, church, and human rights activists to use civil disobedience to disrupt the proceedings and because the Fund is under sustained attack in the US Congress and elsewhere for its performance during the Asian crisis.
A recent independent report commissioned by Congress also argued that the IMF should provide only short-term loans for crisis situations, although it added more conditions which the new study appears to reject. In addition, US Treasury Secretary Lawrence Summers has urged the IMF to curb long-term lending programmes.
The IMF has defended its role, but its new managing director, Horst Koehler, who will formally take over next month, has been close-mouthed about his intentions.
The new report’s authors are calling for Koehler to confine the IMF’s operations to three major roles: providing short-term liquidity lending to all countries hit by economic crises; advising all countries through dialogue on macro-economic policy; and collecting information on countries’ macro-economic policy and financial markets.
Established along with the World Bank at Bretton Woods, New Hampshire, in 1944, the IMF has evolved from its original mandate of maintaining stable exchange rates among the major industrialised countries to short-term lender for developing countries hit by macro-economic crises, such as balance of payments problems.
After the 1982 Latin American debt crisis, however, the Fund, convinced that the crisis reflected much deeper structural problems, broadened its policy agenda to include longer-term lending through a new “Structural Adjustment Facility which was soon replaced by the “Enhanced Structural Adjustment Facility” (ESAF).
Loans granted under these facilities normally required governments to slash public spending, a “conditionality” that usually resulted in sharp cuts to social services, such as health and education.
As NGOs and others protested the impact of these IMF edicts, the Fund began attaching more specific conditions to their loans, such as cutting military spending and attacking corruption.
“Consequently, the Fund became even more involved in government processes,” according to the report, which noted that this expansion of its role culminated in two recent policy developments that involve the IMF even more closely in policies, such as reducing poverty, for which it has no expertise.
The first of these was the requirement that the poorest countries successfully complete as many as two three-year ESAF programmes in order to qualify for major debt relief under the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) initiative. “Thus a facility of the IMF, an institution originally never meant to deal directly with poverty, has become the instrument by which a major poverty reduction initiative is triggered.”
The second development was the replacement last year of ESAF with the PRGF, a facility that for the first time makes reducing poverty one of the IMF’s explicitly stated goals.
But this makes little sense given the IMF’s continued expertise on macro-economic policy, as opposed to the World Bank’s much broader focus on development issues, including poverty reduction, says the report. That is why it favours moving the PRGF to the Bank.
“In addition, moving the PRGF would mean that a Bank programme would be the trigger for debt relief through the enhanced HIPC Initiative (which) is appropriate, since the relief is to be used for poverty reduction,” the report says.
This would mark a major shift in the relationship and power between the two institutions which, given their respective competencies and interests, have always found co-operation difficult. In effect, the IMF would lose its ability to deny countries access to World Bank loans if they failed to meet the Fund’s conditions.
The IMF should instead focus exclusively on short-term loans to help countries out of crises, according to the report which stresses, however, that any conditions placed on those loans should also be confined exclusively to short-term macro-economic policies that will enable borrowers to repay the loans quickly.
The report argues that conditions which go beyond macro- economic policy, such as those imposed on Asian countries during the financial crisis that required changes in labour laws or the rights of foreign investors to acquire local businesses, have proven ineffective at best and counter-productive at worst.
“This far-reaching conditionality can have two strongly negative effects. The first is that it discourages countries from coming to the IMF until they have no choice, so that the situation may be far more serious and difficult than if the IMF had been called in earlier.
“The second effect is that foreign investors may assume that the problems are not short term in nature, but rather deeply structural, delaying the return of investment,” the report says.
It added that the recent rebound in most of the crisis-hit Asian economies, while remarkable, “has had little to do with the implementation of structural reforms since the crisis.”
Moreover, by withdrawing from long-term lending, the IMF could better offer independent surveillance and policy advice to countries, according to the report. De-linking policy advice from long-term lending would make actual policy reforms adopted by countries more credible to foreign investors, the report argues.
On governance issues, the report calls for the Fund’s board, which is currently dominated by the western industrial powers, to be re-aligned to reflect current economic realities and give more representation to poor countries.
In contrast to its early years, the IMF’s main clients have little influence over the institution. “This lack of representation is harmful to the IMF’s effectiveness,” the report states, “as client countries see the Fund as dominated by rich countries and do not regard it as impartial.” As a result, many developing countries “feel a sense of alienation from the Fund. ”
In particular, the United States which is the IMF’s biggest contributor and controls 17.5 percent of the vote, should no longer enjoy a veto over major policy decisions, the report urges.
It notes that representation is also undermined by the fact that board members are often overwhelmed with information on the large numbers of country programmes, which makes it difficult for them to focus on any one country.
One approach to addressing this problem, according to the report, is to create “sub-boards” consisting of representatives of regional neighbours that could focus better on specific countries and offer “peer reviews” of country programmes and policies as part of the IMF’s surveillance role.
In addition to the task force members, several outside experts, former Ghanaian finance minister Kwesi Botchwey, who also participated in a recent external review of IMF operations, as well as Gerald Helleiner, a prominent Canadian economist, Eduardo Lizano of Costa Rica, and Willi Wapenhans, a former top World Bank official, endorsed the report, although “not necessarily all statements or emphases.”
Jim Lobe
- The International Monetary Fund (IMF) should scrap its long-term lending programmes to poor countries because it lacks competence on issues such as reducing poverty, according to a new report signed by a number of US development policy heavyweights.
(more…)