Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour, Latin America & the Caribbean

TRINIDAD & TOBAGO: Labour Movement Heading into a Minefield, Say Observers

Peter Richards

PORT OF SPAIN, Jun 28 2000 (IPS) - Disappointed with how it has been treated by successive governments, Trinidad’s labour movement appears now to be testing the waters as a prelude to launching itself into the political fray.

But, observers here say, that road is a minefield for the unwary.

“The roads to this country must rumble with people power. We have to take back the power from the politicians. Before the end of the year, labour must be felt. We are going to rock the corridors of Trinidad and Tobago,” declared President of the Public Service Association (PSA) Jennifer Baptiste.

“I am sowing the seeds again in the minds of workers, to look around in the Caribbean and the region. Anytime we want meaningful change labour has to take the reins of power. It is time for a Labour Party in Trinidad and Tobago,” she told cheering workers at the Jun. 19 Labour Day celebrations.

At last year’s observations, President of the National Trade Union Centre (NATUC) Errol McLeod said “no traditional politician, no political party, whether in government or in opposition, has given the working people anything.

“Yet today there are some who may be of the mistaken view that the best way to serve the workers is to make deals with politicians in the vain hope that the politicians will return the favour and run something for the workers,” he added.

These kinds of statements have been staple fare at the annual Labour Day celebrations over the last three years as labour leaders have become increasingly disillusioned with politicians who they say pander to workers and their causes in election campaigns only to ignore them after attaining high office.

The idea of a labour party with a workers agenda is not new. At least on two occasions in post-colonial Trinidad and Tobago, the trade union movement has been intimately involved in the formation of political parties geared towards pushing the agenda of workers.

Indeed the current Prime Minister Basdeo Panday was part of the Workers and Farmers Party (WFP) which contested and lost the 1966 general elections. Panday also lost his deposit.

Ten years later, he was leading the United Labour Front, (ULF) a coalition of trade unions representing workers in the sugar and oil industries. The party formed the official opposition in 1976, but failed to capture the government five years later.

The ULF became part of the amalgam of opposition political groupings that in 1985 formed the National Alliance for Reconstruction (NAR) and successfully challenged the Peoples National Movement (PNM) winning by a 33-3 majority.

But the NAR failed to live up to the expectations of the electorate. In-fighting and open public verbal sparring resulted in its demise in the next general election in 1991, but not before Panday and some of his ULF colleagues were expelled.

Panday had the last laugh, however. Between 1988 and 1995, his new grouping “Club 88”, which later evolved into the United National Congress (UNC), became the official opposition party in the country. By 1995, the UNC was to form the government after the two NAR members gave their support. The general election of that year had provided the country with its first ever tie in the race for the 36-member Parliament.

And in 1989, David Abdullah headed MOTION, a grouping of trade unionists which unsuccessfully contested the polls of 1991.

Despite Panday’s labour credentials, however, labour leaders say he has turned out to be a sore disappointment.

“Many take the view that the Prime Minister has repudiated his origins as a lifelong advocate of social democratic policies and eminent trade union leader.

Some say he is unrepentant about playing with the parasitic oligarchy (a term Panday himself coined to describe the capitalist private sector),” says political analyst Lloyd Best.

Panday’s government is even now embroiled in a protracted dispute with the country’s nurses over higher wages and improved working conditions. The government has even gone as far as to deduct money from nurses’ paycheques charging that they are engaging in an unlawful strike. Classified as essential workers, nurses are forbidden to take such industrial action.

Some nurses have taken the administration to court over the issue, producing proof that they have indeed been on the premises at the time they were alleged to be off the job. The nurses are in fact punching their time- clocks as usual, but failing to actually carry out their duties, claiming that they do not have the necessary equipment to do what they were hired to do.

Panday has been very vocal in his disagreement with the healthcare workers, and his administration’s move to dock their salaries have not won him increased support.

But, says Best, the view that Panday has abandoned his roots is “dangerously facile”.

Lecturer in Politics at the University of the West Indies (UWI), Dr. Hamid Ghany says he does not believe that Panday has abandoned his trade union colleagues and workers. “What he is faced with is having to deal equitably with a multi-sectoral society and he can’t give the impression he is favouring one over the other,” Ghany said.

In observation of Labour Day and to demonstrate his government’s commitment to workers, the UNC this month ran newspaper advertisements celebrating its achievements in improving the lot of workers in the country. It pointed to areas such as providing a mandatory minimum wage schedule, increased pensions, and old age benefits.

“It’s easy to say you support working men and women, but talk is cheap. The proof is in the record and the United National Congress’ labour record proves that results and not rhetoric count for Trinidad and Tobago’s working men and women,” said the advertisement.

Labour leaders, however, believe they can do better. Not so, say observers.

Ghany believes that the labour movement “which has had limited success in that area” over the years, is unlikely to succeed now. The first obstacle is the fact that the two major political parties here, the UNC and the PNM have “large working class bases.”

“(Workers’) principal loyalties are to their respective parties. I don’t think the consciousness of the labour movement has been able to transcend these divided loyalties,” he added.

Further Ghany argues that the impact of race on the voting behaviour in Trinidad and Tobago would seriously undermine the success of any labour party. The UNC’s base is found within the Indo-Trinidadian population while Afro-Trinidadians flock to the PNM.

Ghany also notes that the labour movement is divided along racial lines. “That is seen in the complete absence of the All Trinidad Sugar Union (a predominantly Indian group which Panday once headed) from the Labour Day activities.

“This is a pattern which has developed, and I think therein lies what is perhaps the deeper challenge that faces the labour movement and that is the ability to get a working class consciousness that transcends racial lines.”

“To some extent that is what a Labour Party will have to address if it is to have any electoral success at all,” he added.

Best believes the trade unions would be better off addressing “the original mandate of labour” and investigating “what mistakes were made when we handed over the initiative from the unions to the political parties” rather than attempting to fight political parties on their own turf.

“You need to pursue a different political method in which politics would take over from the ascendancy of government,” he added.

But the labour movement may take heart from the editorial of one of the three daily newspapers here.

The Trinidad Guardian newspaper noted here recently that “at the end of the day, it will be up to the electorate to decide whether or not a party of labour makes it for the first time to the so-called corridor of power.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags