Africa, Headlines

POLITICS-BOTSWANA: From Chief To King

Caitlin Davies

Jul 17 2000 (IPS) - Botswana’s House of Chiefs has unanimously decided its members should be referred to as Kings from now on.

This, say the Chiefs, will right a colonial wrong inherited from the days as a British protectorate. Others say it is the last wishes of a dying institution at a time when chieftaincy, far from uniting the nation, appears to be causing increasing tribal tension.

The kingship motion was tabled by Kgosi Tawana II, the nation’s youngest paramount chief and leader of the 15-strong House.

Tawana was crowned chief in 1995 and, in an interview to celebrate his first year in power, ironically asserted: “We chiefs are not kings but servants.”

Today, however, he wants government to replace the term Paramount Chief with King and ‘tribe’ with ‘people’. Presumably the House’s one woman chief would then become queen.

Tawana believes the word chief lowers the honorable members’ status and that the word ‘tribe’ is derogatory. The other chiefs in the house heartily agree, with one accusing the British of injustice and adding; ‘please give us back our status’.

However government’s response is to point out that Botswana is a republic not a monarchy. The House has been advised to wait for the outcome of a recently appointed presidential commission of inquiry.

The commission will look into possible amendments to sections 77-79 of the Botswana constitution which are charged as being tribalistic. It will also solicit views on the very future of chieftainship.

Some observers, such as columnist Busisiwe Mosiieman, have dismissed the kingship motion as ‘preposterous’, adding that ‘no one gets called by some title or other only because they rather fancy it’.

As far as Mosiieman is concerned, Swaziland and Lesotho have real kings because they are sole rulers of independent sovereign states. He advises the would-be kings of Botswana to stay with the indigenous title ‘Kgosi’ if they don’t like the English word ‘chief’.

Meanwhile the motion has brought the issue of chieftainship to the fore once again in a nation struggling to decide on the modern role of its traditional leaders.

As the editorial in Mmegi, the country’s largest independent newspaper, begins: “(chieftainship) at this point in the history of our nation is becoming a bitterly contentious subject “.

There have been several serious chieftainship tussles in the past few years mainly centering on whom is the rightful heir to various tribal thrones. Amid such struggles, there is an increasingly belief that the whole institution is outdated.

Those who would like to see the House of Chiefs abolished argue that chiefs have outlived their purpose. Their judicial role has largely been taken over by magistrates, their administrative role by district officers. The House rarely, if ever, influences government policy.

“Chiefs are not even a unifying force, in fact they are divisive because the so called minority tribes don’t have equal representation,” says one proponent of abolition.

“Don’t forget that paramount chiefs were created by the British anyway, they upped the status of the chiefs that didn’t cause them any trouble. I think the whole house should be done away with.”

Some observers feel Tawana, paramount chief of the Batawana in the north, wants his status upgraded because of an upcoming legal battle with the Wayeyi tribe.

The Wayeyi form almost half of the 100,000 people in the North West district, but have traditionally been classified as a minority and fallen under Batawana rule. As a minority they do not have representation in the House of Chiefs.

Currently eight historically advantaged tribes – all Tswana speaking – enjoy automatic representation in the House. But last year the Wayeyi installed their own paramount chief Calvin Diile Kamanakao, the first time a minority tribe has made such a move.

A year later and Kamanakao has not been recognized by either Tawana or government and the Wayeyi are now taking both to court in a case which will effect the whole future of the House.

If Kamanakao is recognised and the Wayeyi therefore allowed representation in the House (and presumably group rights to land) other ‘minority’ tribes are sure to follow.

“Tawana is feeling threatened and wants to maintain the inequality (between the tribes) by elevating the status for the current paramount chiefs,” says Lydia Nyati-Ramahobo referring to the kingship motion. “To me it is a clear signal that some people are not ready for equality with marginalised groups.”

Nyati-Ramahobo, coordinator of a Wayeyi cultural organization, also sees the commission of inquiry as a delaying tactic, coming five years after parliament already agreed to amend the constitution to make it tribally neutral.

While the kingship motion continues to be discussed, an anonymous and highly inflammatory letter attacking another tribe – the Kalanga – started making the rounds. One newspaper leader says this serves as “a reminder that if the ugly monster ethnicity is making inroads into our society it needs to be fought resolutely”.

From present events it is clear that former president Ketumile Masire knew what he was talking about when he retired in 1998. Asked what he most feared about the future of Botswana, his answer was tribalism.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags