Active Citizens, Civil Society, Europe, Headlines, Human Rights

HUMAN RIGHTS: EU Urged to Sue Russia over Abuses in Chechnya

Brian Kenety

BRUSSELS, Oct 28 2000 (IPS) - Leading human rights groups are urging the European Union (EU) to pressure Russia at their bilateral summit on Sunday to launch a credible inquiry into reports that its soldiers have tortured and killed civilians in breakaway Chechnya.

Human Rights Watch (HRW) is advising European states to open an inquiry at the European Court of Human Rights over alleged abuses, while Amnesty International (AI) is calling on the EU to demand the establishment of an independent office to investigate the alleged persecution of Chechens.

HRW charges in a 99-page report issued this week entitled ‘Welcome to Hell’ that Russian troops have arbitrarily detained thousands of Chechens on suspicion of collaboration with rebel fighters and subjected many to systematic beatings, rape and other forms of torture. The report documents more than 130 summary executions by Russian security forces.

‘Welcome to hell’ is how Russian guards at the Chernokozovo detention facility would greet detainees before forcing them to undergo a hail of blows by baton-wielding guards. Most detainees were released only after their families managed to pay large bribes to Russian officials, said the report.

HRW researchers have gathered testimony from former detainees at Chernokozovo and other facilities, including the Mozdok and Khankala military bases, about rape and sexual assault of both men and women.

A number of former detainees gave detailed accounts of the injuries they sustained to their ribs, kidneys, testicles, and feet from prolonged beatings. To gain their release, most detainees said their families had to pay bribes ranging from 75 to 5,000 US dollars to their Russian captors or “predatory intermediaries” said the report.

In February, delegations of the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture visited detention centres in Chechenya. Following the visits, the Committee explicitly requested Russian authorities to investigate allegations of abuse and Chernokozovo and other facilities.

The EU subsequently sharply criticised Russia’s actions in Chechnya and sponsored a resolution at the United Nations Commission on Human Rights urging Russia to launch a national commission of inquiry that would establish accountability for abuse, notes HRW.

However, six months after the resolution’s adoption, Moscow has failed to launch a credible investigation into human rights abuses in Chechnya, including torture at the detention centres, said the HRW report, noting that to date the EU has taken no steps to press Russia to form the commission.

“These are not just abuses of the past,” said Rachel Denber, acting director of the pressure group’s Europe and Central Asia Division in a statement that stressed that European states should not forget Chechnya.

“Even today, any Chechen civilian is at risk of arbitrary detention and severe physical abuse at the hands of Russian troops,” she said.

Under international law, Russia has a duty to investigate allegations of torture, rape, summary execution and other serious violations of human rights and international humanitarian law standards. The Convention against Torture obliges state parties to initiate a prompt and impartial investigation of torture complaints wherever circumstances give “reasonable ground to believe that an act of torture” has been committed.

“The EU has given Russia more than enough time to launch a credible investigation into abuses in Chechnya. If the EU wants to retain its credibility on human rights issues, it should act now,” said Denber.

The United Nations has also not called for the creation of an international inquiry, but has called on the Russian government to conduct an investigation, while urging Moscow to allow UN working groups to visit the region. Moscow has thus far not granted its permission to do so.

HRW is calling on the EU and the United States to emphasise in bilateral and multilateral communications with the Russian government that abuses committed by Russian government forces in Chechnya amount to war crimes and serious violations of international law.

The New York-based pressure group wants Brussels and Washington to oppose payment of any pending loan instruments to the Russian Federation until Moscow “takes meaningful steps to limit the civilian toll imposed by its military operation in Chechnya and hold those responsible for abuses accountable”.

In a statement Friday, Amnesty International (AI) noted that throughout the 1990s “an accumulating combination of anti-Chechen antagonism and racism in Russian society, and official Russian pronouncements, actions and policies gradually reduced Chechens in the Russian Federation to their present status of an ethnic group beneath the law, prey to abuses, persecution, extortion, and arbitrary treatment, including restrictions on their freedom of movement”.

The London-based pressure group is calling on the EU to incorporate into its actions and its dialogue with the Russian authorities over the Chechnya conflict, concern and engagement with the wider crisis of the corrosion and breakdown of Chechens’ human rights protection throughout the Russian Federation.

“The costs of a relaxation of international pressure upon the Russian authorities to meet their human rights obligations over Chechnya are high. The bill is being paid every day in Chechnya by those falling victim to new, grave human rights violations,” said AI.

“The European Union has a responsibility to ensure that pressure is sustained. Expressions such as ‘gentle diplomacy’ may only too easily be understood by the Russian authorities to mean ‘business as usual’ and European Union acquiescence in the status quo,” said the group.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags