Saturday, November 21, 2026
Sergei Blagov
- Russia has long prided itself on its freedom of press and expression, which remarked a dramatic departure from the totalitarian past in the wake of the Soviet collapse in 1991.
Yet, these days, a bold vision of an open society has become a matter of increasing concern, in Russia and throughout other post- Soviet states.
To highlight these anxieties, On Jan 29, in an unprecedented move, Russian President Vladimir Putin, met in the Kremlin with 11 leading journalists of the NTV national channel who complained about pressure from the law enforcement agencies.
The Russian leader tried to calm the reporters, telling them he did not mind keeping NTV as a private channel free to criticise the Kremlin.
Nonetheless, the talks were tense and NTV journalists reportedly often interrupted the president.
Putin reportedly said that he would like NTV to remain an independent company, NTV general director, Yevgeny Kiselyov, said after the three-hour meeting with Putin. Yet there was a high barrier of mutual misunderstanding and mistrust, Kiselyov added.
Putin also gave journalists a copy of the letter he sent to CNN’s founder Ted Turner on Jan 23, in which he thanked the American for his interest and said he would welcome his would-be investment, but without any political guarantees.
Turner had sought assurances that if he bought a stake in NTV, the Kremlin would not interfere in the station’s operation or coverage.
U.S. financier and philanthropist, George Soros, as well as the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, have hinted that they would team up with Turner to buy a 25 percent stake in NTV to protect its independence.
In recent months, NTV has been targeted by repeated legal action, described by NTV as pressure from the Kremlin to change their critical coverage. After nearly a year of investigation, on Jan 26 the prosecutors began to question NTV journalists.
NTV has accused the law enforcement agencies of pursuing a political vendetta. Russia’s Prosecutor General, Vladimir Ustinov, retorted the investigation of NTV finances is purely economic and criminal.
Investigators do not question journalism, but seek to establish the legality and grounds of providing the loans, Ustinov told ORT television.
NTV has repeatedly alleged that Ustinov had received an apartment worth 500,000 U.S. dollars from former the Kremlin chief manager Pavel Borodin in undue manner, while Ustinov dismissed the allegations as libel.
Borodin has been in detention in the US following his arrest in New York earlier in January on a Swiss warrant charging him with money laundering.
Borodin, 54, the man credited by Putin with introducing him to the presidential administration, Borodin was at the center of a series of allegations of bribe-taking that darkened Yeltsin’s final years in office.
Moreover, the NTV case, though high-profile, is not the only point of press freedom concerns in Russia. For instance, earlier in January, some deputies of Russia’s State Duma, lower house of parliament, drafted amendments to the law on mass media that could outlaw any reports that could be perceived as instigating riots.
Under the proposed draft, a section of the current law that prohibits open calls for riots is changed to sound more like the instigation of riots.
The unclear wording used in the draft could be interpreted to apply to anything from open calls for riots to criticism of the authorities.
An article in the current law that grants the status of a journalist would be deleted. That section of the law allows journalists to protect their sources and gain access to areas otherwise closed to civilians. In another proposed amendment, journalists would be held liable for reports that could be seen harmful to a person’s business or political image.
Though the question of whether these amendments could be approved is far from certain, the proposals were seen as a test to alert the parliament and the general public to attempts to limit freedom of speech.
Yet, if in Russia the president and opposition journalists still talk to each other, in other post-Soviet states disagreements over press freedom took dramatic forms.
Notably in Ukraine, the outspoken opposition journalist, Georgy Gongadze, disappeared last September. It was widely believed that he had been kidnapped by forces close to the presidential administration, who were angered by his critical reporting.
In mid-November, a body was discovered in the woods, decapitated and doused with acid, in an attempt to disguise its identity, but DNA tests have since shown it to be Gongadze’s.
As a result now a political crisis flares in earnest in Ukraine. The case revolves around a series of recordings, allegedly made in President Leonid Kuchma’s office, on which several voices (supposedly those of the president and his cronies) allegedly discuss a plot to eliminate Gongadze. Kuchma’s political opponents now wage a campaign to impeach the president.
In the relatively quiet Kazakhstan, the amendments to the law on mass media, approved earlier this week, are expected to cause bankruptcy of 15 independent TV companies. Kazakh president already enjoys unrivalled access to the media, and the main state television channel is run by his daughter.
In neighboring Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan, editors of state- owned media outlets imposed direct censorship, in particular to enforce the taboo on any criticism of the presidents or their policies.
It might be argued that the Internet could be an answer to all post-Soviet challenges to freedom of press. Yet during its spring session, the Russian State Duma is moving towards considering a dozen bills to regulate the Internet.
Most of these bills address legitimate concerns, such as protecting intellectual property, preventing copyright infringement, and securing online payments.
However, one bill that is likely to draw fire from defendants of free speech. It stipulates that all Internet publications need to be registered with Russian Communications Ministry if they want to be considered media outlets.
The Byzantine registration process is widely seen as an administrative tool to exclude critical media outlets, in Russia and other former Soviet states.