Saturday, November 21, 2026
Danielle Knight
- US environmentalists and lumber mill workers do not usually find themselves on the same side of many issues. But now both groups are working together to urge the government to renegotiate a lumber trade agreement with Canada that they say is hurting US jobs and harming ancient forests.
They argue that Canada heavily subsidises its timber industry and has less strict environmental laws.
Denny Scott, a spokesman with the Western Council of Industrial Workers, a labour organisation based in Portland, Oregon, says this combination is leading to the flow of cheap wood into the United States which is undercutting the US timber industry, leading to mill closures and layoffs.
At the same time, the subsidies are also causing the over- harvesting of old growth trees in Canada and the destruction of habitat for endangered species, says Joe Scott, conservation director for the Northwest Ecosystem Alliance, an environmental group based in Washington state.
“Subsidies are killing US mills and killing North American forests, and we have an interest in both,” says Joe Scott, who is no relation to Denny Scott.
Environmental groups and the US timber industry are urging the Bush administration to launch lumber import negotiations with Canada. Lumber trade between the two countries currently falls under the Softwood Lumber Agreement, a five-year accord signed in 1996 that expires on Mar. 31.
The pact sets quotas on how much each of Canada’s timber producing provinces can export to the United States, with shipments above that amount subject to duties. It does not address Canadian subsidies.
While Canadian producers complain that the quotas and duties on shipments to the United States are unfair, mill workers and environmentalists want Canada to eliminate its subsidies.
Many US lawmakers agree that Canada should remove its timber subsidies. Two weeks ago more than 50 Republican and Democratic Senators sent a letter to President George W. Bush, urging him to begin negotiations with Canada.
The central problem, says the letter, is that federal and provincial Canadian governments own 95 percent of timber resources and set the price of timber at a level that “ensures high employment levels”. In the United States, companies generally log from private and public land and the price of lumber is set at auction.
Canada’s “set prices are generally one-half to one-quarter of the actual market value of the timber, thus constituting a significant government subsidy”, says the letter.
Senator Max Baucus, a Democrat from the western state of Montana, says that about 100 lumber mills have closed in the past six months across the country, including in his state, because they cannot compete with Canadian lumber imports.
“Canada continues to pursue a short-sighted forestry policy to the detriment of US mills and their workers, the North American environment, and ultimately, Canadian taxpayers,” says Baucus.
According to Denny Scott with the Western Council of Industrial Workers, in the logging states of Oregon and Washington, 52 mills with a total of 5,000 workers have closed since the lumber trade agreement was signed. The Department of Labour says that the Canadian subsidies have been a determining factor in the mill closings.
He says the Canadian subsidies have added to other problems plaguing the US lumber industry, including a 33 percent drop in lumber prices.
“The subsidies have been a disaster,” he added.
The Canadian government also subsidises its industry by not having the same environmental laws as the United States, such as the Endangered Species Act, says Denny Scott. Without these kinds of laws, the timber companies in Canada are allowed to over-harvest and clear-cut where they would not be allowed to in the United States, he notes.
The extensive clear-cutting in western Canada, says Joe Scott with the Northwest Ecosystem Alliance, is having significant adverse effects on US efforts to protect endangered and threatened species that are shared by both nations, such as bull trouts, grizzly bears, woodland caribou and salmon.
Four of the six US grizzly bear recovery zones, for example, span the Canadian border.
“Grizzlies are extremely vulnerable to logging related habitat disturbance,” says Joe Scott.
The habitat for some of the healthiest bull trout populations remaining in the United States also straddles the border with Canada, he says.
While the fish is extremely sensitive to logging related habitat disturbance and road building, nearly all of the bull trout watersheds, mostly on the Montana border, are slated to be logged within this decade, he says.
Logging companies in Canada are also allowed to drag logs across salmon streams and cut to the banks of some of these water ways, argue conservationists, despite the decreasing population of salmon across the West Coast.
“Such practices destroy salmon nests and make habitat inhospitable for fish by destroying the food web, increasing sedimentation, which clogs the gills of fish and smothers salmon eggs, and raising water temperature which kills immature salmon,” says a statement released by the Northwest Ecosystem Alliance.