Saturday, November 21, 2026
Nadeem Iqbal
- Muhammad Hanif was in government service until four years ago when he opted for early retirement and received a 40,000 U.S. dollar package which he invested in a savings scheme.
Employed by the Atomic Energy Commission of Pakistan, he was earning then the equivalent of 200 U.S. dollars a month. But he felt his salary was not sufficient to feed his six-member family.
So Hanif, like tens of thousands of other state employees, availed himself of the government’s retrenchment or “Golden Handshake Scheme” which offered a generous package of cash and other benefits.
Now he just paints car registration plates on a market footpath in the capital for which he earns only a fraction of his previous salary. Meanwhile, his savings are being eroded by the high inflation rate.
On May 28, the federal government once again offered a similar ‘voluntarily early retirement scheme’ to 40,000 of its employees or nearly 12 per cent of its 3.5 million-strong federal bureaucracy, which is considered too large for a developing country.
The decision was made by military ruler Gen Pervez Musharraf, who also approved the restructuring of federal departments, reducing their number to 21 from 35. As part of its efforts to cut spending, the government is planning to privatise many of its corporations.
By letting go of 40,000 employees, the government hopes to reduce its salary and pension bill for civil servants by around 500 million U.S. dollars a year, officials say.
Planning Commission Chief Economist Pervez Tahir said employees would be offered a package equivalent to 36 months of their last salary in addition to other benefits.
The decision is believed to have been taken under pressure from international financial institutions which want the government to cut its expenditure on salaries and instead spend more for social sector development.
But although the downsizing is aimed at promoting efficiency in the bureaucracy, critics say it will worsen unemployment in the country, where 2.4 million people are without jobs.
The plan is also getting a lot of criticism because it is targeting only low-income employees, or those with monthly income of between 50 and 150 dollars.
But while the government has spelled out its retrenchment plans, it still doesn’t have the resources to implement it, observers say.
According to official estimates the present retrenchment plan is going to cost the government around 4.0 billion dollars which, official sources say, the government will borrow from international donor agencies.
So although the plan was unveiled late last month, there is no certainty as to when it will be implemented and how. Its previous ‘Golden Handshake Scheme’ was discontinued because of opposition.
But for sure, the scheme has prompted similar moves in other sectors. Four provincial governments and semi-government corporations, taking a cue from the federal government, announced plans to cut staff positions.
Among them are Pakistan International Airlines, and Pakistan Telecommunications Corp.
A 1998 World Bank document described the previous retrenchment programme. “Civil service reform is a complex and difficult task. While in Pakistan the government rapidly initiated a downsizing exercise involving a review of the rationale for the existence and staffing of government agencies, the resulting recommendations were not implemented due to concerns about the large numbers of public sector employees that would be rendered redundant.”
“Instead an untargeted voluntary ‘Golden Hand Shake Scheme’ was promulgated in August 1997, under which employees could retire early with enhanced benefits,” it said.
“More than 80,000 persons responded to this offer, but due to its high up-front cost and parliamentary and labour opposition, the scheme was shelved temporarily.”
Like Hanif, Muneer Ahmed accepted a “golden handshake” from the Agriculture Development Bank in 1997. Back then, he said, commercial banks were offering rates of return of around 18 percent a month so he invested 20,000 dollars from his retrenchment package.
Now the rate of return has been cut by almost half so investments like these are no longer attractive. Coupled with a 13 percent inflation, Muneer said it would not be wise for government employees to opt for early retirement.
Last year, the government reduced the monthly interest rate on government saving schemes hoping that the people would switch their investments in new businesses, ultimately reviving the current stagnant economy.
The government estimates that as many as 4,000 industrial firms are financially weak.
Advising the government not to go ahead with its downsizing plans, The News, a leading English daily said that at a time when jobs are not easily available, the government has to shoulder the responsibility of being the largest employer.
“As the total projected savings is much too small, less than half percent of government’s total annual expenditure of 600 billion rupees (12 billion dollars), the decision of declaring thousands of employees as surplus could have been avoided.”
“The people should have been allowed to go at their usual retirement age (60 years) allowing the government to grow thinner slowly and gradually,” it said in an editorial.