Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

RIGHTS-BANGLADESH: Women at Risk in Safe Custody

Tabibul Islam

DHAKA, Aug 28 2001 (IPS) - An unofficial measure supposed to protect female victims of various offences has become yet another addition to their pile of misfortunes. But while the sorry situation has been known even to Bangladeshi authorities for quite a while now, little has been done to correct it.

Each year, at least 300 women and girls are lodged in so-called “safe custody” facilities, which are really nothing more than several square metres of space inside ordinary jails, along with other prisoners, both convicted and those still awaiting trial.

Because of limited space, these jails often house both male and female prisoners as well.

Among the women and girls placed in safe custody are those who have been raped, rescued from the sex trade, oppressed or deserted by their husbands, and those whose marriages are in dispute.

For no fault of theirs, these women and girls are forced to suffer the same conditions endured by convicted criminals. Even if they have not been accused of any crime, some are handcuffed, a practice that has yet to be explained by jail authorities.

More often than not, women and girls in safe custody are also harassed and abused by male co-prisoners and jail personnel.

Once inside, there is no telling as well how long they will be kept under lock and key. The shortest stay has been three months, but many of those from impoverished families have been known to have languished in safe custody for as much as a decade.

Jamila (not her real name), 22, spent two and a half years in safe custody despite being from a well-off family. Then again, it had been her father who had filed a case with the police, alleging that Jamila had been kidnapped by a young man who then forced her to marry him.

In fact, Jamila, who has gone to university, had married her boyfriend without the consent of her parents. In court, she pleaded that she was mature enough to make her own decisions and had married her boyfriend legally, in front of a ‘kazi’ (marriage registrar).

She also pleaded not to be sent to safe custody since she had the capacity to live independently.

But the court failed to listen to her. When she was finally released recently on the orders of the High Court, Jamila could only describe her stay in safe custody as a physical and mental ordeal.

As a result of all these, some legal observers and experts have argued that placing women and girls in safe custody against their will is nothing less than a violation of human rights.

Lawyer Tania Amir says the problem is that “the concept prevails that a woman is never self-independent, nor is completely free. She is always under the custody of someone.”

“That is,” says Amir, “when she is a child, (she is) under the custody of father, when she is married, under the custody of her husband, when she is old, under the custody of her sons”.

“Such a ‘mental baggage’ we conventionally and traditionally maintain, and obviously the practice of safe custody is one of the results of such mental baggage,” says the lawyer.

Critics also point out that there is no provision for such a thing as safe custody in the country’s jail code. Yet, they say, magistrates with their undefined discretionary power continue to place female victims of crimes in such set-ups.

Prompted by a writ petition on the matter filed by the Bangladeshi National Women Lawyers Association (BNWLA), the High Court has asked the Home Ministry as well as other concerned government agencies to show cause why those under safe custody should not be kept separate from convicted prisoners at the very least.

But all a Home Ministry official would say on the subject is that “we have taken cognizance of it”. He was silent on whether or not steps have been taken to keep women and girls in safe custody away from other prisoners.

Still, some advocates like Ila Chanda argue that safe custody is “necessary” even if it does not have legal basis.

She does say, though, that it should be done outside of jails. Instead, says Chanda, safe custody facilities should be in shelters where rehabilitation or various training aimed at developing self- sufficiency and independence can be done.

BNWLA executive director Salma Ali echoes the need to have those being placed in safe custody in “homes” instead of jails. She also says that such women should be given not only vocational training but legal and medical assistance as well.

In addition, Ali suggests that members of different women’s organisations be included in committees that would supervise the running of these “safe custody homes”.

But some observers say that women’s organisations are partly to blame for the situation. They say these groups have failed to adequately and properly air the grievances of the women and girls in safe custody and react only when stories about these “inmates” are published in the media.

One local journalist who declines to be named also notes that although the chiefs of the two biggest political parties in Bangladesh are women, neither has paid heed to the numerous problems of those in safe custody.

“Had the two distinguished ladies (Sheikh Hasina Wajed of the Awami League and Begum Khaleda Zia of the Bangladesh National Party) been sincere (about their concern for these women)…several dozens of modern shelter homes could now be across the country by this time,” says the journalist.

“Such shelter homes outside jails,” she adds, “would have given the female inmates freedom from perpetual harassment and abuses of various kinds.”

Begum Khaleda Zia is a former premier of Bangladesh. Sheikh Hasina has been prime minister since 1996.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags