Europe, Headlines

POLITICS – SLOVAKIA: Relations with Hungary Look Set to Improve

Ed Holt

BRATISLAVA, Apr 24 2002 (IPS) - Strained relations between European Union, EU, candidate states Hungary and Slovakia appear set to improve dramatically after a change of government in Budapest.

Stalled top-level political cooperation on EU and North Atlantic Treaty Organisation, NATO, entry is expected to be restarted and aggressive nationalist rhetoric over controversial legislation abandoned as the Socialist Party and centre-left Liberal Alliance of Free Democrats begin negotiations on forming a new government.

“A European, rather than nationalist, direction has prevailed in Hungary’s elections,” said Slovak Prime Minister Mikulas Dzurinda on April 22, a day after the final round of voting in the elections.

Bitter disputes over two controversial laws and a pre-election campaign by incumbent Hungarian Prime Minister Victor Orban’s Fidesz party, that many observers saw as laced with nationalism, had brought cooperation between Slovakia – which has a 500,000 strong Hungarian minority – and Hungary to a near standstill at top political levels.

The work of the Visegrad Four group, an important political grouping of Hungary, Slovakia, Poland and the Czech Republic, had virtually stopped after calls from Orban that the Benes Decress – legislation that saw millions of Germans and Hungarians stripped of property in the then Czechoslovakia just after the second world war – ran contrary to EU ideology and legislation and should be revoked.

Relations were also soured in January by the Slovak government’s essential rejection of the Hungarian Status Law, giving rights to Hungarian minorities in a number of states, although Budapest had approved the law six months earlier.

Socialist Party leader Peter Medgyessy has already set about mending those relations, though immediately after the election results became clear he told Hungarian media that the new government was backing neighbour states’ integration efforts.

“I see good relations with Slovakia as key. We will give unlimited support to [their] integration efforts,” he was reported as saying.

The change in tone from Budapest has been publicly welcomed by Slovak MPs keen to dismiss the tension of the last four months and privately by European Commissioners who had been angered by the nationalist stance taken by Fidesz.

“The Benes Decrees and the Hungarian Status Law were both election themes. The election is now over and the situation always has a natural tendency to return to its normal agenda,” said Frantisek Sebej, independent MP and head of the parliamentary Commission for Integration.

Visegrad Four leaders are due to meet in Bratislava at the end of May and the presence of the new Hungarian PM, likely Medgyessy, will be seen as a precursor to renewing full cooperation between the four states on integration issues by autumn.

“It is very possible that once the Czech and Slovak elections in June and September respectively are out of the way, Visegrad Four cooperation at the highest level can be put back on track,” said Pavol Lukac of the Slovak Foreign Policy Association.

The European Commission will also be keen to see relations between the group improve. Its only comments on the result of the election have been to say that it expects the new Hungarian government will continue the EU accession efforts made by its predecessor.

However, privately commissioners will be relieved that cooperation between a group, it has always supported as crucial to the all four nations’ hopes of EU membership, can start again at the highest levels, and Slovak politicians close to EU negotiations have acknowledged the importance of the election results.

“The continuation of Orban’s policy of revaluating both postwar arrangements and unifying Hungary across state borders could have led to regional destabilisation, complications in EU enlargement and the strengthening of Slovak nationalism,” said Peter Weiss, Chair of the Parliamentary Foreign Affairs Committee.

The change will also, political observers argue, allow for a defusing of tensions between nationalist parties in Slovakia and the Slovak Hungarian Coalition Party (SMK) which had grown in the run up to the elections.

“A more moderate position will be reached by some members of the SMK on some issues and the nationalist rhetoric in Hungary will weaken after the elections. The same rhetoric of Slovak nationalist parties will also die away. They won’t use the ‘Hungarian card’ as much,” said Grigorij Meseznikov of the Institute for Public Affairs.

The nationalist rhetoric in the Fidesz campaign had included references to strong future support from Budapest for ethnic Hungarians, the Benes Decrees, pre-World War I Hungarian borders, and vetos on Slovak NATO entry by current alliance member Hungary.

This had allowed the two strongest Slovak nationalist parties, the SNS and PSNS, to attack the SMK and build support prior to Slovak elections.

SMK members collectively stayed neutral to the disputes in the run-up to the Hungarian elections but individual MPs had been seen to support the Fidesz campaign.

Statements SMK deputy leader Miklos Duray had made at a Fidesz rally referring to ‘Felvidek’ – the historical Hungarian name for upper Hungary, much of what is today Slovakia, under the Austro-Hungarian empire – led to legal action from the SNS to have the SMK banned as a political party for attempting to “destroy Slovak statehood”.

The SMK, a member of the same pan-European political group as Fidesz, The European Democratic Union, has dismissed the accusations from the PSNS and welcomed the new government with an immediate call to support Slovak NATO ambitions.

But in what may be a sign of a more tolerant approach to Hungarian politics the SNS has also reacted positively to the prospect of cooperation with the new Hungarian government.

“I am convinced that the new government will be fundamentally more constructive in establishing relations with neighbouring countries,” said SNS deputy leader Jaroslav Paska.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags