Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

BANGLADESH: River Ferries Disasters Waiting to Happen

Tabibul Islam

DHAKA, May 9 2002 (IPS) - The country’s worst river launch accident yet happened just a week ago, but people are already predicting that the disaster will not be the last of its kind in Bangladesh.

Indeed, many note that commuter ferry mishaps have become so common in Bangladesh simply because the same mistakes are committed again and again – as they were in the May 3 mishap.

They also say that either authorities have tired of enforcing the rules or were never really interested in making people follow them at all.

One shipping ministry official himself points out that despite the flagrant flouting of the laws meant to keep the country’s waterways safe, there are still only about 10 to 12 supervisors and inspectors assigned to enforce these rules.

“Is it humanly possible,” asks the official who declined to be named, “for only a dozen people to look after over 8,000 motor launches plying the different waterways of the country?”

This is largely why, he says, he is pessimistic that there would be significant changes following this month’s disaster that claimed more than 300 lives.

He adds, “There is always a hue and cry after a major accident — which subsides after a short time. After that, nobody takes any initiative to resolve the problems of the waterways, ensure the safety of the passengers and enforce strict discipline in the movement of launches.”

To be sure, one of the reasons why the MV Salahuddin, bound for Patukhali district that is about 240 km from here, capsized was that it was overloaded. It left Dhaka with more than 500 passengers when it had a carrying capacity of only 336 people.

Overloading is acknowledged to be the single biggest culprit of all river accidents in Bangladesh. Yet many say it is rare to ride a launch that is not packed to the rafters.

One porter at the Dhaka launch terminal also says that assorted merchandise was also on the ill-fated MV Salahuddin, in blatant violation of a rule prohibiting passenger launches from carrying cargo.

To make matters worse, the Salahuddin’s master apparently did not heed a storm warning that was even broadcast on commercial radio.

One survivor of the mishap has also been quoted as saying that the master defied the appeal of passengers to take the launch near the shore while the storm was still starting and the wind was not yet that strong.

MV Salahuddin encountered a severe storm while on the Meghna river, and failed to make it past the Chandpur district.

Businessman Hamid Ali, who often uses launches that are a popular means of transport in this riverine country, comments that ferry masters never care for weather forecast.

“(And) there seems to be no authority in Bangladesh to compel them to abide by the weather forecast and punish them for operating launches in the midst of severe storms,” he says.

According to data from the Department of Shipping, negligence of the ferry master accounts for 21.43 percent of river accidents in Bangladesh. Some observers say the carelessness of these masters can be traced not only to sheer foolhardiness and hubris, but also to a lack of training.

Masters and launch crews must have training and experience certificates before they are allowed to work on ferries, but many say there have been cases where certificates were simply issued by authorities in exchange for money.

Corruption is apparently at play as well in the issuance of many marine fitness certificates for the motor launches.

To get these certificates, which are required before a ferry can ply Bangladesh’s more than 8,000 kms of navigable waterways, a passenger launch must be equipped with life jackets, fire extinguishers, search lights, hydraulic wheels and a radio set.

Yet passengers themselves attest to not spotting most of these in the launches that they take.

Then there are the launches that do not bother to get a certificate at all, but ferry passengers anyway. According to some media reports, 70 percent of the country’s river ferries do not have this document.

That Bangladesh’s lone marine court is ill-equipped can only mean that violations of river transport laws will continue to go largely unchecked. As it is, more than 4,000 cases are pending in the court, which has just one magistrate.

Launch owners and masters also never learn any lesson from river accidents because there is often a lack of witnesses that would help put the guilty behind bars.

Because the trials on these cases tend to drag on for ages, witnesses tend to lose interest in giving their accounts. Most of them are also poor and unwilling to travel to far-away towns just to give evidence in these trials.

In the last three decades, more than 5,000 lives have been lost in some 450 boat and launch tragedies in the country. In 1987, a World Bank-funded project aimed at improving safety in the river transport system was launched. But it was later shelved, without the government ever giving a reason why.

Some 70,000 people use motor launches and country boats every day. Bangladesh has about one million country boats, which also transport passengers and cargo.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags