Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

CARIBBEAN: Trinidad Weighs Charging Paper for ‘Terrorist’ Report

Peter Richards

PORT OF SPAIN, Jan 31 2003 (IPS) - The Trinidad and Tobago government says it is considering legal action against a national newspaper that reported on a laboratory allegedly being used by an unnamed group of local Muslim radicals to produce chemical and biological weapons.

Prime Minister Patrick Manning said this week that the attorney general had been asked to determine whether criminal charges could be brought against the journalist who wrote the story and any others involved.

”Legal advice is being sought by the attorney general to see whether anybody is culpable, with the assurance that if anybody is, then appropriate charges will be laid, whether they come from the media or not, Manning told reporters.

Last weekend, the Trinidad Express published a story titled ”Terror Threat”, in which journalist Darryl Heeralal said he and a photographer had been taken blindfolded to a location where they were shown chemicals that members of the group said would be used to manufacture weapons.

According to the article, the group said the weapons would be used against British and U.S. interests in this country should the United States attack Iraq.

Local Muslim groups here, including the radical Jamaat-al-Muslimeen, which staged an unsuccessful coup in 1990, have distanced themselves from the article.

The head of the Inter-Religious Organisation (IRO) Nobel Khan, said that his organisation, which groups the country’s various religious bodies, was denouncing the alleged threat.

”Islam is a religion of peace. Acts of violence and terrorism are not parts of the Islamic faith. People who have problems and hate in their hearts must solve them through prayer, not through violence,” he said, flanked by other IRO members.

”The Islamic community is fearful that there will be a backlash,” added Khan. ”Unfortunately, many unseemly things that have nothing to do with Islam are labelled as Islamic.”

Added Presbyterian Reverend Cyril Paul, ”if this story turns out to have no credence, then the media house that carried the story would come into disrepute, the reporter who wrote the story would come into disrepute, and the vocation of journalism would be sullied”.

Many people have already condemned the report. In a nation-wide address, National Security Minister Howard Chin Lee said the journalist had written similar articles in the past without any of them being correct.

”Ladies and gentlemen, your government has no problem with a vigorous, enterprising media,” he said. ”This government has never, and will never, confuse the message with the messenger, or rail against reporters doing their job.”

But, added Chin Lee, the report contains a ”tremendous amount of misinformation, and our fear is that there may even be a deliberate attempt at disinformation”.

The Media Association of Trinidad and Tobago (MATT) has kept quiet on the issue, saying only that it will be discussed at a meeting scheduled for next week.

The Express has defended the article.

In a front page editorial headlined ”Shooting the Messenger”, the paper said that it had always understood its primary role was to convey information that it judges to be either in the public interest or interesting to the public.

The newspaper insisted that the article was published according to journalistic principles and that ”the decision to go public with the results of our investigations, therefore, was based not so much on whether we were satisfied that the men had either the will or the means to carry out their threat, but on what we believe was our responsibility to alert the public both to their existence and indeed their insidious intentions, albeit self-proclaimed”.

On Tuesday, the paper said that the police had interviewed the journalists who covered the story and that police had told lawyers that ”the interview was set up to get information and that both men were not being treated as suspects”.

In a column, the paper’s editor at large, Keith Smith, said he found it ”sadly revealing” that the Express was being considered as part of a conspiracy to destabilise Trinidad and Tobago.

But another Express columnist, Dennis Solomon, wrote that he found the weekend article so ”ludicrous” that ”my first reaction on reading the story was to check if I hadn’t fallen asleep and woken up on April Fool’s Day”.

"So ludicrous was the cloak and dagger account of the trip to the ‘secret location’ and the verbal and pictorial descriptions of the ‘lab’, that one almost forgot to wonder how the contact with the ‘terrorists’ was made and why arrangements were not made for a police tail, either physical or electronic," he added.

Heeralal has defended his story, saying his job is to serve the public interest with public information.

The Express reported Thursday that police special branch officers were searching south Trinidad seeking to unearth the laboratory where the chemicals are allegedly being made.

Coming on the heels of a British Government travel advisory for Trinidad and Tobago, the Express report was doing untold damage to the country, Manning said.

He also said that the state is ready to deal with security threats. ”We are in a constant state of readiness to protect the citizens of Trinidad and Tobago.”

”We have no fear whatsoever about our capability to treat matters of this nature. We are also determined that all such matters will be appropriately dealt with, especially if these matters find themselves in the realm of fiction or as part of improper plots against the state.”

 
Republish | | Print |