Thursday, November 19, 2026
IPS Correspondents
- Two among the most sensitive issues in Malaysia – race issues and press freedom – have combined to ignite Monday’s police raid on an independent Internet newspaper and turn it into a full-blown political controversy.
In the last few days, activists, citizens, all the opposition parties and regional and international press groups have spoken out against the raid on the offices of malayskini.com and the seizure of its computers.
”A crude attempt” to muzzle independent media, said the Bangkok-based South-east Asian Press Alliance. ”Uncivilised,” said the Islamic party PAS, yet another sign of Malaysia’s ”authoritarian syndrome", argued the Chinese-based Democratic Action Party. After the police raid following a complaint lodged by the youth wing of a political party in Malaysia’s ruling coalition, it remained unclear what, if any, charges would be brought against the three-year-old, web-based publication.
On Jan. 17, the youth wing of the United Malays National Organisation (UMNO) complained to police about a ”seditious” letter that Malaysiakini published on Jan. 9 that criticised the racial affirmative policy towards Malays, who make up majority of 24 million people in this majority Muslim country.
Police demanded that Malaysiakini editors, whom they have questioned, identify the letter writer. The editors declined to do so, citing professional ethics that require protection of sources.
The letter, signed by ‘Petrof’, said the special benefits given to Malays for more than three decades are ”pernicious politics of privilege" that worked against the other ethnic groups, the Chinese and Indian Malaysians.
Meantime, debate has continued around the two issues brought to the fore by the row.
For instance, critics are asking why UMNO Youth, if it felt aggrieved, chose not to write to Malaysiakini, or file charges against it in court.
”Why don’t they sue for defamation instead of abusing state power to clamp down on the organisation?” asked Hamdan Adnan, a member of Malaysia’s Human Rights Commission, known by its local acronym Suhakam.
”Certain things like critical views should be out in the open. With new technology, we cannot expect to keep these away,” he added.
Thus far, Malaysiakini has been able to publish independent news different from the country’s mainstream, government-dominated media because the Internet is not covered by the press control laws and it does not need a publishing licence.
Though it has been unhappy with Malaysiakini, the government has also been careful not to clamp down on it, not least because it has been trying to promote the country as an information technology hub.
But officials’ statements in recent days may be revealing. Deputy Home Minister Zainal Abidin Zin on Tuesday said that the government would not censor Internet content ”if they (media) are good”.
”If they are not good, we just cannot lay down our head,” he was quoted as saying. If parties commit acts ”unjust” to society, ”the government must act responsibly to defend the rights of the people”, he maintained.
Those words are not very far from the arguments of UMNO Youth, whose information chief Azimi Daim said: "If they (news websites and media) fail to censor offensive materials unfit for publication, the authorities should then investigate and act on them.”
Malaysiakini editor Steven Gan said the letter was not racially inflammatory but the person’s comparative study of the situation in Malaysia. "I find this an attempt to close us down,” he said.
Echoed Malaysiakini chief executive officer Premesh Chandran: ”We know that this is an election year and that UMNO and the government feels that Malaysiakini is a threat,” referring to general elections expected this year.
In October too, Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad will be stepping down to give way to his deputy.
In his letter, ‘Petrof’ also compared the unjust treatment by Americans of native Americans to Malaysia’s treatment of its own native people or ‘Orang Asli’, among the most marginalised groups in the country.
It also said that just as the Ku Klux Klan sought the perpetuation of white supremacy, ”UMNO Youth’s raison d’etre is to perpetuate Malay hegemony and privileges”.
Public discussions of race, including in mainstream media, tread on safe ground, because it is a subject the Malaysian government is very wary about. It says that inflammatory remarks about race have no space in a multi-cultural country, where it may create dissension.
Cautious attitudes were shaped also after the racial riots of 1969, which were a factor in shaping the New Economic Policy designed to give a boost to Malays.
In another police report against Malaysiakini in March 2001, Selangor state police lodged a report against the website for quoting the opposition’s remarks that the death toll from racial clashes outside the capital could be higher than the official count.
Azimi Daim says special rights for Malays were provided for under Article 153 of the Federal Constitution and should not be questioned.
"The letter falsely accused the government of ignoring the benefits of ‘Orang Asli’ and said allowances and medical care are only given to those who become Muslims,” he argued.
"It also implied that Malays are the cause of poverty among Indians as Malay businessmen were said to have bought plantations (where many of them work) for project development,” he added.
But an expert on indigenous issues said: "I was told by many members of the group that they somehow feel that without conversion to Islam, they would not get government’s support in development.”
”One man told me that it was commonly known that by converting to Islam they would to get a hundred ringgit (26 U.S. dollars) a month," he added.
While this is not an open or official policy, he says that somehow, some indigenous people have been made to believe that was the way to get government support.
"The fact that poverty rate among Orang Asli has never dropped from around 80 percent, despite what the government says, indicates that they are still not benefited from the kind of help being provided," he said.