Saturday, November 21, 2026
Tabibul Islam
- A High Court directive to the government, that children detained in Bangladesh’s overcrowded and run-down jails must be transferred to correction centres, has been met with both relief and concern.
The Apr. 9 order, passed by a division bench of the court, followed three months of hearings on a petition filed by lawyer and human rights activist Shahdeen Malik and advocate Idrisur Rahman. While the order is seen as progressive, those working for children’s and women’s rights point out that it raises a number of concerns about the treatment of children in Bangladesh.
Rokeya Kabir, president of the Bangladesh Nari Progoti Sangha (Bangladesh Women’s Development Association), a non-governmental organisation, has welcomed the order, but does not want to see child prisoners sent to correction centres. "There is no such centre, in the true sense of the term, in which child prisoners can be properly rehabilitated," she said.
It is a view that found support from an editorial comment on Apr. 12 in the Dhaka-based English newspaper, ‘The Daily Star’. "The government should put more emphasis on rehabilitation of child prisoners, instead of just washing their hands off (the problem) by putting them in correction centres," said the newspaper.
There are estimated to be more than 1,200 children in Bangladesh’s 65 jails, and the country has been criticised by national and international rights groups and advocates for violating its own laws by incarcerating juvenile offenders together with convicted adult criminals.
Kabir has suggested the formation of a group – comprising representatives of the government, NGOs, civil society and lawyers – to draft a rehabilitation programme for children in detention, one that will include education and skills training in a benign environment.
But any such group will also need to address the factors that lead to children becoming offenders, and these are several and equally daunting. Where legislation on the matter exists, for example, as in the Children’s Act of 1974, it is flouted by the police, as lawyers almost unanimously point out.
The act forbids the sending of children under 16 years old to jail, states that children accused of committing offences should be held either at a correction centre or in a remand home, and that they be tried as juveniles and not adults. "In practice, the police often do not document the age of children to sidestep their responsibility," said advocate Abu Ahmed of the Dhaka Bar.
Furthermore, as Shahdeen Malik has stated in a paper on the condition of Bangladesh’s judicial system, these problems are "compounded by the prevailing poverty and increasing corruption". He warned: "The delay and perception of corruption, at least in the lower tiers of the judicial system, are increasingly making the system marginal."
Poverty, overpopulation and lopsided development combine to make the world of the street child in urban Bangladesh a grim and dangerous place. There are estimated to be 500,000 street children in the six major cities, of which half are in Dhaka. Yet instead of addressing the problems, some of Bangladesh’s fractious political parties exploit the children’s vulnerability.
Street children are routinely used for picketing during strikes, are incited to hurl stones at police, to disrupt meetings and rallies of political rivals by setting off crackers. They are also recruited by criminals and drug traffickers, and are targeted by the sex industry.
Mukhlesur Rahman, a well-known labour leader, squarely blamed political parties and policy planners for failing to respond to the problem. "Political parties often use child labour and street children to realise their political goals, and the police shirk their responsibility in exchange for financial benefits," he said.
It does not help at all, said Salma Ali, executive director of the Bangladesh National Women Lawyers’ Association, that the police tend to arrest children on mere suspicion. "This is a common practice," she said, "but there are no guidelines for such arrests." And this, as Rahman noted, despite Bangladesh being among the first signatories to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child.
Lawyers have also complained that while the right to legal assistance is guaranteed under the constitution, it is not provided to children. Their observation is that during trials, an adult may be let off on bail, but for the same offence a child may be held as an under-trial simply because of the absence of legal representation.
The legal imbalance has to some extent been recognised by the recent court order. The High Court has directed the government to withdraw all criminal charges filed against children under 12, and should that not be possible then that they be freed on bail.
In practice, however, the wheels of justice grind excruciatingly slowly in Bangladesh. As Malik has said, close to a million cases are pending in the courts system. Even the mandatory appeal process against sentences of death pronounced by trial courts drag on for three years before being taken up by the High Court.
This has led to the jails in Bangladesh being chronically overcrowded – they are estimated to hold more than 80,000 prisoners as against their capacity of 25,000 – with their resources unable to cope with the numbers.
Overcrowding, poor food and inadequate medical facilities are the lot of a prisoner. Into this dark world, where there is little space for the adult, are thrust juvenile offenders, who quickly become victims of sexual abuse and mental harassment.
Is there a way out of this system for children? Justice K.M. Hasan of the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court has stated that the success rate reported by the government-run juvenile correction centres is very low. He has suggested the setting up of special courts or designated courts with judges and personnel trained in the provision of the Convention on the Rights of the Child.