Africa, Headlines, Human Rights

RIGHTS-RWANDA: Nine Years On, Genocide Suspects Still Languish in Custody

Swaumu Stella Vuzo

ARUSHA, Tanzania, May 30 2003 (IPS) - Each morning the residents of this northern Tanzanian resort town of Arusha wake up to the sound of sirens and police vehicles escorting genocide suspects to court.

Hassan Ngeze, former publisher and editor-in-chief of Kangura newspaper, is one of the suspects currently on trial. He has been accused, along with Ferdinand Nahimana and Jean-Bosco Barayagwiza, of using the media to incite genocide in Rwanda in 1994.

Up to one million Tutsis and moderate Hutus were slaughtered by Hutu fanatics – known as interahamwe, or those who fight together in Kinyarwanda – in 1994. It was the worst genocide since the Nazis killed six million Jews in World War II.

All court sessions start at 9:00 a.m. until six o’clock and last for ten weeks. The trials go on for a long period depending on the availability of witnesses.

Rights groups have criticised the tribunal for being slow in delivering judgement. This is mainly because witnesses come from all corners of the world, thus delaying court proceedings.

"Judges cannot sit if there are no witnesses to a trial," says South African Judge Navanethem Pillay, the Tribunal president. This means that for a case to proceed, witnesses must come forward to testify.

Some witnesses, especially refugees, have no proper travel documents. Some are threatened and traumatised and require counselling before testifying. Each case needs, at least, 25 witnesses. To complicate matter, the witnesses mainly speak Kinyarwanda – Rwanda’s official language – which has to be translated into English and then into French and vice versa. The process of acquiring witnesses, their testimonies and the translations is long and time consuming.

This raises concern about whether the tribunal will meet its deadline to wind up by 2008. "This does not mean that the suspects will go free," says deputy prosecutor, Bongani Majola of South Africa. "If the cases are not completed they will be transferred to national courts."

The tribunal, set up by the United Nations in 1994, has more than 800 staff representing over 80 nationalities. In 1996, the tribunal made its first arrests. Since then more than 50 suspects have been arrested and brought to the United Nations Defence Facility in Arusha. More than 20 others are on the run.

Arusha, with a population of around 1.2 million, was chosen to host the tribunal, says U.N.’s Bocar Sy, as recognition for the role played by the city in the search for peace in Rwanda.

The late Rwandan President Juvenal Habyarimana held his last peace talks in the city, before the plane in which he was travelling was shot down near Kigali international airport on Apr. 6, 1994. Hutu extremists opposed to the power-sharing arrangements with Tutsi rebels are suspected to be behind the shooting. Habyarimana’s assassination, along with that of his Burundian counterpart, was to unleash a 100-day orgy of bloodletting across Rwanda.

"The tribunal’s existence is a lesson to other African leaders that impunity will no longer be tolerated and the international community is keen to see that genocide and what happened in Rwanda will never be repeated elsewhere," says tribunal spokesperson, Roland Ammoussouga.

Amnesty International, a human rights watchdog based in London, has highlighted cases of rights abuses in war-torn Somalia, Sudan, Cote d’Ivoire, Burundi, Liberia, the Central African Republic (CAR) and the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC).

The Rwanda genocide suspects, who are in the U.N. custody in Arusha, include former ministers, mayors, army officers, journalists, priests, nuns and businessmen. Thirteen of them have already been convicted; 20 others are being tried. Judge Pillay says the tribunal, with an annual budget of about 178 million U.S. dollars, will hire 18 part-time judges to assist the 11 judges to try all the suspects before the tribunal folds in 2008.

The presence of the tribunal in Arusha is also a blessing to the locals. Harrisson Temu, who owns six houses in Arusha, says: "If it was not for the tribunal I would be earning only 50,000Tsh (50 U.S. dollars) in rent per month. Now the tenants pay me about 300 to 400 U.S. dollars per unit per month."

Tanzania, with a population of around 38 million, remains one of the poorest countries in the world, heavily reliant on foreign aid, with many of its people living below the World Bank poverty line of one U.S. dollar a day.

The disparity is glaring, thanks to the U.N. tribunal’s purchasing power. Posh cars bearing blue number plates, starting with letter "T" – for the tribunal – dot the streets of Arusha. Even so, some officials prefer ridding in taxis, thus boosting the local economy.

"In the past we used to wait for passengers at the bus terminals, but now taxis are all over Arusha," says cab driver Dick Mpenda. "I earn up to 100 U.S. dollars on a good day and not less than 50 U.S. dollars on ordinary day. To me, this is business."

Sex workers also benefit from the windfall. "Most of my clients are from the tribunal. They claim their wives are far away and need to spend good time with me. They pay between 15 to 50 U.S. dollars a session," says Rose, who refused to provide her surname.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags