DEVELOPMENT: African Ministers Oppose New Issues in Cancun

By IPS Correspondents Reprint | | Print |

Tetteh Hormeku

GRANDE BAIE, MAURITIUS, Jun 24 2003 (IPS) - -African Union ministers of trade have called on the Cancun Ministerial Conference of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) in September to focus on developmental concerns in the existing agreements and not to start negotiations for new agreements.

In a declaration adopted in Grand Baie, Mauritius, recently the trade ministers noted that "WTO members do not have a common understanding on how the so called Singapore issues – such as investment, competition, government procurement and trade facilitation – should be dealt with procedurally and substantively."

And, "taking into account the potential serious implications of these issues on our economies", they called "for further clarification on these issues to continue."

At the same time, the Ministers focused attention on the missed deadlines in the current negotiations on issues such as agriculture, TRIPS and public health, special and differential treatment and implementation-related issues. Expressing concern at this evidence of general lack of progress on the issues of critical concern to their countries, they challenged the members of the WTO to "inject momentum into the negotiations on these issues in order to ensure that the Cancun WTO Ministerial yields positive results for African countries and makes the Doha Work Programme a truly ‘Development Agenda’

The Ministers stated that agriculture was of critical importance to Africa’s development, with the potential to "lift millions of our people" out of poverty. They added that progress in the agricultural negotiations was essential for the successful conclusion of the Doha work-programme, and strongly urged members to fulfill their Doha commitments. Ministers also noted the need for African countries to continue to enjoy agricultural trade preferences, calling for action to address the erosion of these preferences.

In relation to services, the Declaration charged the Services Council (of the WTO) with failure to satisfy the requirement in the General Agreement in Trade in Services (GATS) to carry out an assessment of trade in services. Furthermore, in a clear reference to the pressures from developed countries to liberalise their service sector against their will, the Ministers called for due respect for their rights to regulate trade in services and liberalise according to their national policy objectives. At the same time they emphasised the respect to the principle of progressive liberalisation subject to the principle of flexibility, as well as the need to promote and facilitate the participation of African countries in international trade in services. Developed countries only should therefore liberalise their sectors and modes that are of export interest to African countries.

On the Doha mandate regarding measures to enable countries which lack manufacturing capacity to access medicine for public health, the Ministers re-stated their support for their compromise deal reached in December last year, and wrecked by the United States. This deal, they added, still remains a means for members to fulfill their obligations as required by the Doha declaration.

For industrial tariffs, the Ministers stated the objectives of the negotiations as being to facilitate the development and industrialisation of African countries. These must be reflected in the modalities and actual negotiations by addressing tariff peaks and escalations, and take fully into account the special needs and interests of developing and least-developed countries. This required, among others, fulfillment of the principles of special and differential treatment, as well as the principle that developing and least developed countries must not make full reciprocal commitments to reduce their tariffs.

The declaration was adopted following focused deliberations on the measures needed by Africa to ensure that its interests prevailed in the face of stark balance sheet of the disappointed hopes of Doha. In his welcome address to the Ministers, J Cuttaree, Minister of Industry and International Trade of the Republic of Mauritius asked Ministers to draw their strength and decision of purpose from their unity in order for Africa’s pressing concerns over the core issues of the Doha agenda to be recognised in Geneva and Cancun.

He reminded ministers that 19 months after the hope and optimism evoked with the launch at Doha of trade negotiations under the title of "Development Round", the development agenda is stranded in missed deadlines. The negotiations have failed to yield "balanced outcomes in which the interests of all, particularly those who are in most need are truly attended".

Cuttaree stated that "had the WTO been effective in finding expeditious solutions to the problems of TRIPS and Public Health, we should have seen an improvement for millions of people in Africa who are suffering from deadly diseases".

Nor have African countries had any comfort "on their basic concerns in the areas of special and differential treatment, agriculture, and textiles."

He pointed to the double standards at play in the area of industrial tariffs. Here, proposals to drastically cut and eliminate tariffs, which African countries have already declared a recipe for disaster, are being pursued by countries that had themselves used this instrument in the early stage of their industrialisation process. "Having used the ladder for so long, it is not fair that they should kick the ladder off to the detriment of our countries".

In a similar vein, Ambassador Vijay Markham, Interim African Union Commissioner, cautioned that while trade is important Ministers need to beware of those who sing the praise and play the tune of unbridled trade liberalisation.

He reminded them of the case of the former United Kingdom trade minister, Stephen Byers who, while in government promoted trade liberalisation as panacea to problems of development, only to confess once outside government, that his optimism had not been borne out in practice. Markham argued that a "conducive international trading environment is as important, if not more important, than efforts at national level to make trade an effective instrument for development".

This requires action on the imbalances and inequities of the international trading system, such as the persistent deterioration in the terms of trade for primary commodities, tariff peaks and escalation, the asymmetry in the treatment of capital and labour in the area of services, as well agricultural subsidies in developed countries which are daily destroying the livelihood of African farmers.

Referring to the failures in the Doha agenda to address these problems, Markham said that this created a situation where "once again pressure will be brought to bear on us to compromise on our stand so that Cancun can be a success. This cannot and should not be allowed to happen."

Adelaide Mkhonza, Assistant Secretary-General of the African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) countries stated that the glimmer of hope contained in the Doha development agenda for ACP and other developing countries to rebalance the rules of the WTO has been undermined by a stalled process. The missed deadlines are set to over-load and stretch the agenda to the detriment of countries with limited resources.The African Union provided a foundation of collective action of African countries, together with other countries of the ACP group, for the necessary action to redress these imbalances.

African civil society organisations who, for the first time, were allowed to meet under the auspices of the conference and to address the Ministers, underscored their support for the collective effort of the Ministers for international trade rules which reflected the needs and interests of the people of Africa.

In their statement, presented on their behalf by Jane Ocaya-Irama of Uganda, the civil society organisations called on the Ministers to focus on addressing the inequities of the existing agreements of the WTO, and reject any attempt to launch negotiations on the Singapore issues in Cancun.

The group drew attention to the undemocratic, and non transparent processes of the WTO, and called for the elimination of such abusive practices such as exclusive informal meeting, mini-ministerials, and such other none transparent devices as "friends of the chair". Aware of the pressures by developed countries to derail African countries from their concerns in the trade negotiations, they pledged to work with ministers as they strive for rules and agreements which will serve the interest of African women and men.

The very presence of civil society organisations formally at the gathering of Ministers and the fact that they addressed their concerns directly to the Ministers was a welcome precedence for the AU. But while the civil society organisations lend support to the Ministers, it was clear that their demands were stronger, and went far beyond what the Ministers were able to adopt in their Declarations.

According to Thomas Deve of MWENGO from Zimbabwe, this gap between civil society demands and the Ministers’ positions sets a mark for judging how far the Ministers will go in the coming months to hold up to their collective positions in the face of pressure. It also outlines the tasks ahead of civil society groups in Africa and beyond to ensure that Ministers live up to their commitments to Africa.(ENDS/IPS/AF/DV/TH/SM/03)

= 06240609 ORP011 NNNN