Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Population

HONG KONG: Territory Losing its Shine to Mainland China

Antoaneta Bezlova

HONG KONG, Sep 17 2003 (IPS) - Daniel Guo, a university professor with an enviable salary and a cosy flat, is feeling less and less confident about his prospects in this once exuberant city.

When he arrived in Hong Kong from mainland China 10 years ago, he felt he had struck a pot of gold – as an academic here, he was getting a salary and perks that his fellow countrymen could only dream about.

But these days, things are not looking so rosy. With the economy depressed for five consecutive years, the property market in the doldrums and unemployment running at a historic high of about 8.6 percent, his once dream-come-true existence is being eroded by salary cuts and trims in benefits.

‘‘These days the new El Dorado is mainland China,” Daniel says. ‘‘Everyone is looking at what possibilities are opening up there. The first one million yuan (121, 116 U.S. dollar) annual salary for an academic was announced in Guangdong (southern China) this year.”

‘’If ten years ago someone had told me that I would be contemplating going back to work in communist China, I would have thought him mad,” he points out.

Hong Kong, which used to feel it was a few steps ahead of the mainland, is now getting left behind. Before Britain handed the former colony back to China in 1997, its superior legal infrastructure and accountancy standards allowed Hong Kong to assume the role of China’s premier financial centre..

Today, its allure as a city of boundless opportunities and high-quality living is being overshadowed by Shanghai and Shenzhen – the new, burgeoning financial hubs of mainland China.

David Webb, an economic observer and long-time resident of Hong Kong, says the territory is seeing a ‘‘second brain-drain” wave. ‘‘In the run-up to the 1997 handover to China, there was a bunch of people who left for Canada, Australia, United States and Britain. Today, we have a second brain drain going to Shanghai, Beijing and Guangzhou.”

It is the ‘‘middle-management class”, the white-collar professionals that are leaving the city for better opportunities in mainland China.

But the exodus of jobs has spread also to manufacturing industries that have moved across the border to the mainland. Now, increasing numbers of people cross to shop or buy properties in neighbouring cities like Zhuhai and Shenzhen.

‘‘Even the red lantern districts in Wanchai are closing down because the bar girls in Shenzhen are so much cheaper,” grumbles Cheung Yip, a waiter at the Repulse Bay beach restaurant.

Before the economy’s collapse, Yip ran his own seafood import company but like so many other businesses in Hong Kong, it went bust.

The seafood restaurant where he now works as a waiter still flies in red lobsters from Tasmania and tiger garoupa from South Africa, but the days of high consumption are past. Consumer spending has been falling for 57 months in succession.

The crash came during the 1997 Asian financial crisis, which started just months after the British handover. Hong Kong refused to follow the other Asian tiger economies into devaluing its currency and did not cut the Hong Kong dollar’s peg with the U.S.. dollar.

Since then, the territory has suffered a string of recessions. Property prices and the stock market have tumbled, and unemployment has broken records. A poll of economists by Dow Jones Newswires, reported on Tuesday, put the unemployment rate at around 8.6 percent.

That was already a slightly better figure, reflecting some recovery from the impact of the Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) virus outbreak this year, which emptied shops and scared off tourists.

Hong Kong’s public blames the post-colonial administration of chief executive Tung Chee-hwa for mismanaging the economy by intervening too much, increasing public expenditures and creating a huge budget deficit.

Unemployment is now a threat to everybody, says Judy Lam, a kindergarten teacher. For a city where people’s savings are heavily invested in properties, the collapse in property prices has meant that many end up with mortgage debts that exceed the current value of their homes.

‘‘If you lose your job, but have to pay your mortgage and your house is worth 50 percent less, then you are in a big trouble,” says Lam.

The sense of crisis is pervasive, although the city is beginning to emerge from its post-SARS depression. Hotels and shopping malls are gradually filling up again but now it is those new rich Chinese across the border that are the big spenders.

‘‘Oh yes, they have a lot of money these days,” Yip sighs.

Beijing has tried to extend a helping hand to prop up Hong Kong economy. In recent months, Chinese trade mandarins have unveiled new cross-border infrastructure projects and allowed some mainland tourists to visit Hong Kong without having to join tour groups.

Soon mainland tourists would be allowed to take 5,000 U.S. dollars out of the country, or more than double the previous currency limit.

Yet somehow, the SARS crisis that spread from the neighbouring province of Guangdong and the Tung Chee-hwa administration’s inept initial response to it, have come to symbolise all the ills plaguing Hong Kong.

That same crisis has also dented hopes of relying on high-spending visitors to revive the economy.

There is a sense that if Hong Kong does not reform and reinvent itself, in five or 10 years time, this newly industrialised econonmy will be left behind as a ‘‘sleepy financial backwater”, warns Webb.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags