Africa, Headlines, Human Rights

RIGHTS-ZIMBABWE: The Daily News’ Premature Come-Back

Wilson Johwa

HARARE, Oct 28 2003 (IPS) - "If we journalists could have had our way, we wouldn’t have made the decision to publish," sighs a reporter on the staff of Zimbabwe’s troubled independent daily newspaper.

A very popular title with the highest circulation in the country, The Daily News suffered a second police clampdown last weekend when it brought out a surprise issue following a favourable court ruling.

"We’re back!" screamed the headline of the Saturday edition – announcing the paper’s return to the streets after a 42-day government-enforced closure. The publication is Zimbabwe’s only independent daily.

But, this announcement turned out to be somewhat optimistic. The newspaper, a strong critic of the government, has since been shut down again.

The latest closure has angered some of the paper’s 45-odd journalists. They feel that the impatience of its publishers, Associated Newspapers of Zimbabwe (ANZ), has played into the hands of the authorities.

Since The Daily News was first shut down on September 12, its staff members have stayed at home, albeit on a full salary.

Many have since started to involve themselves in other activities, not all related to their professions. When a court gave the newspaper a lifeline, there was general relief – which quickly melted into frustration.

"They bungled, they keep bungling," says another journalist in reference to management’s decision to publish immediately after last week’s judgment. "These guys are not good managers."

But ANZ’s corporate affairs director, Gugulethu Moyo, says the firm acted within the law. "We are not in violation of any court order," she says. "We expect the police to vacate our premises and then we’ll be back in business."

That, however, could be easier said than done. The publishing company’s offices have been sealed by the police who accompany any staff member who may need to retrieve personal belongings.

Daily News editor Nqobile Nyathi says she hasn’t met journalists since the offices were shut last week.

One of them is Abel Mutsakani, who is also the president of the Independent Journalists’ Association of Zimbabwe (IJAZ).

Mutsakani believes workers in the publishing group are well-prepared for the paper’s fight for survival, saying it was clear from the beginning that The Daily News would find itself at loggerheads with the government.

He says by publishing immediately after last week’s judgment, the company did what any reasonable person would have done. "If it was a matter of law alone, we would have an unassailable case," Mutsakani notes.

Saturday’s eight-page issue hit the streets a day after the country’s administrative court ruled that the newspaper must be granted a licence to operate. The court set November 30 as the deadline by which the government-appointed licencing body, the Media and Information Commission (MIC), should issue the licence.

In terms of the recently-enacted "Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act", all media organisations and journalists are required to register with the MIC before being allowed to operate.

As staffers worked on the Sunday edition of the newspaper, police pounced, arresting whomever they could, including at least 12 journalists.

In addition, they have since detained directors of the publishing group, saying they wanted to establish who made the decision to resume publication – something that officials insist is in breach of an earlier Supreme Court judgment.

The Daily News lost the Supreme Court challenge, in which the paper argued that the Information Act was unconstitutional.

At the time, the newspaper was not licenced under the act. The Supreme Court ruled that that the publishers of the paper would first have to register with the MIC before proceeding with their constitutional challenge.

In a further twist, the government then denied The Daily News the opportunity to register – all the while labeling the newspaper "illegal".

The administrative court judgment, which also stated that the MIC was improperly constituted, followed an appeal by the Daily News that the MIC was biased against it.

Harare lawyer Alec Muchadehama says that in terms of the latest judgment, the MIC has been invalidated. "Even those papers that think they are registered are not registered, because the MIC was not properly constituted."

He says there is no longer any distinction between accredited and unaccredited journalists since the whole process has in effect been declared null and void.

 
Republish | | Print |