Sunday, November 22, 2026
Stefania Bianchi
- A top official and a leading human rights group are calling on China to improve its human rights record as the EU considers lifting its 15-year-old arms embargo.
The human rights organisation Amnesty International has backed a call to China by European Commission president Romano Prodi to improve its human rights record before the bloc can lift its embargo. The commission is the executive arm of the European Union (EU).
The EU and the United States imposed an embargo on arms sales to China after a violent crackdown on pro-democracy demonstrators in Tiananmen Square in Beijing in 1989. Hundreds were killed in the massacre.
China is keen to put that episode behind. Access to European weapons technology, nearly as advanced as U.S. capabilities in some areas, would enable China’s defence industry to accelerate modernisation.
Speaking at the start of a four-day visit to China, Prodi said Tuesday (Apr. 13) that improvements in the field of human and political rights in China would be "very helpful" in the context of ending the ban.
"We have registered certain progress by China in the area of human rights but it is not yet satisfactory," he said. "Further progress in this field would be very helpful in the context of discussions that are ongoing on the possibility of lifting the arms embargo."
Amnesty is asking the EU to consider what message it would send to the Chinese government, the relatives of victims of the Tiananmen Square massacre, and to the world if it lifts the ban.
Relations between China and the EU have warmed considerably in recent months, with many European leaders indicating that the bloc is ready to lift the ban. They say China’s human rights situation has improved significantly since 1989, and that the embargo is no longer justified. French President Jacques Chirac has led the calls for resumption of arms sales to China.
But the prospect of an end to Europe’s arms embargo has infuriated the United States, which believes the Chinese regime does not merit a softer approach.
Human rights groups are also concerned that lifting the embargo would send out mixed messages about China’s human rights record, and are urging the EU to consider the human rights situation before it makes its final decision.
"The human rights situation in China has to be central to the EU’s decision," director of Amnesty’s EU office Dick Oosting told journalists Wednesday (Apr. 14). "The situation there is very poor. The EU would be sending out all the wrong messages unless it gets something concrete in return, such as a commitment of an investigation into the events in Tiananmen Square."
Amnesty says dozens of people are still in prison in China following the brutal crackdown on protesters calling for political reform in 1989. It says the country continues to support the death penalty, torture and unfair trials.
"Pro-democracy advocates are still suffering in the China of today and the EU should think twice before letting them down," Oosting said.
Amnesty also stressed that the EU’s Code of Conduct on Arms Exports cannot be considered a credible alternative to the embargo.
The code was adopted in June 1998 and outlines criteria which EU member states should take into account when granting arms export licences. Some EU governments have proposed the code as a safeguard if and when the embargo is lifted.
Amnesty says the EU code has had a "substantial impact" on arms export but it has a number of shortcomings. Arms trade campaigner for Amnesty Robert Parker says the code is not legally binding, and its scope and transparency need to be improved.
"Even now we see it being flouted in some parts of the EU and in countries about to join as EU members," he said. "The code is currently under review. The EU must take this opportunity to tighten up its controls and ensure that EU- supplied arms and security equipment are not used to abuse human rights."
Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao indicated Tuesday that he will visit the EU headquarters in Brussels in May. Ireland, which currently holds the EU’s rotating presidency, is preparing for talks with the Chinese foreign minister Monday (Apr. 19).
EU foreign ministers are due to discuss the lifting of the EU arms embargo against China in the coming weeks.