Europe, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

LATAM-EU: Disputes, EU Enlargement Preclude Advances at Summit

Diego Cevallos*

MEXICO CITY, May 27 2004 (IPS) - Observers say the third summit of European Union (EU), Latin American and Caribbean leaders will bring neither surprises nor far-reaching results, but merely the usual high-sounding declarations.

”Major breakthroughs cannot be expected at the summit in Guadalajara (Mexico) because it is taking place at a time when Latin America is experiencing discord on a number of fronts within the region, and the EU seems to have other priorities,” Patricio Cárdenas, a professor of international affairs at the National Autonomous University of Mexico, told IPS.

Stephan Sberro, a researcher at the Autonomous Technological Institute of Mexico, said the factors that weigh against the possibility of improving relations with the EU at the present time include the bloc’s recent enlargement and the lack of a unified voice on the part of Latin America and the Caribbean.

The EU expanded from 15 to 25 members on May 1 when it incorporated 10 eastern and central European countries. ”Although (the EU) may deny it, Latin America has become less of a priority for the bloc since enlargement,” said Cárdenas.

The Third EU-LAC Summit, to take place Friday and Saturday in Guadalajara, will draw around 1,500 delegates of the governments of 58 countries of Latin America, the Caribbean and the EU and some 130 international bodies and organisations.

At the summit, the third of its kind since 1999, when the first was hosted by Brazil, the leaders will sign agreements on human rights and democracy. The main themes of the gathering are social cohesion and multilateralism.


Many nations of Latin America are coming to the summit with hopes of advancing towards trade agreements with the EU and in search of greater European support. But relations between a number of countries in this region are currently tense, while the European bloc’s priorities do not seem to jibe with those of Latin America.

In addition, a number of leaders will be conspicuously absent, including presidents Néstor Kirchner of Argentina, Fidel Castro of Cuba, and Alejandro Toledo of Peru, was well as British and Italian prime ministers Tony Blair and Silvio Berlusconi.

Anti-globalisation activists complain that the meeting, which will last just 10 hours, is designed to bolster a globalisation model that privileges the interests of transnational corporations and rich nations.

”The summit has given rise to mainly scepticism, scant hopes and even less enthusiasm,” Sberro commented to IPS.

But Lourdes Dieck, the Mexican Foreign Ministry’s under-secretary of economic relations and international cooperation, sees things in a different light.

”The summit has generated great interest because it is focused on strengthening relations between Latin America and Europe, which share common visions and a strategic association that is maturing year by year,” she told IPS.

According to Cuba’s socialist government, however, the meeting will not produce positive results, because – it argues – the interests of Latin America and the Caribbean are ”diametrically opposed” to those of the EU.

Referring to the summit, Cuban President Fidel Castro said ”the whole thing has been organised in such a way that there can be no real free, open and public debate on vital issues that concern the destinies of our hemisphere and of the world.”

Castro announced late Wednesday that he will not be attending the summit.

Relations between Cuba and Mexico are at an all-time low. This month the government of Vicente Fox recalled its ambassador from Havana and expelled the Cuban ambassador.

The summit agenda indicates that Latin American and EU leaders will be meeting basically to discuss the question of social cohesion and strategies to harmonise positions within multilateral bodies – issues that have not given rise to major differences.

But the substantive questions will not be dealt with in the summit itself, but in parallel meetings, said Cárdenas.

Observers are waiting to see what results will emerge, for instance, between the countries of South America’s Southern Common Market (Mercosur) trade bloc and the EU, which have been negotiating a free trade agreement for four years.

Meanwhile, the nations of the Andean Community trade bloc, and Central America, hope the EU will set a date for the start of free trade talks, while seeking an increase in development aid.

The EU, which has already signed free trade deals with Mexico and Chile, has not yet agreed on one with the Mercosur, made up of Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay.

The two blocs acknowledge that there are continuing differences on several issues, especially Europe’s farm subsidies, and the agreement is not expected to be signed until October, rather than at this weekend’s summit in Mexico as both sides had hoped.

With respect to the Andean Community (Bolivia, Colombia, Ecuador, Peru and Venezuela) and the nations of Central America (Costa Rica, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Nicaragua and Panama), the EU warned that it is not in a position to make commitments regarding the start of trade talks or to provide extra aid.

”It is difficult to know whether the EU has a real interest in establishing a strategic relationship with Latin America, as it claims,” given the fact that the European bloc’s trade relations with this region are in decline and it has not assumed any far-reaching political commitments, said Sberro.

EU development aid to Latin America has diminished. And while in 1980, 26 percent of Latin America’s exports went to Europe, that proportion has shrunk to less than 13 percent today, and imports from Europe have dropped from 20 to 14 percent.

”We are concerned that behind the lovely European rhetoric there is no real intention to address the real problems plaguing Latin America,” said Alejandro Villamar with the Mexican Network of Action Against Free Trade.

Besides the recent enlargement of the EU, another obstacle to a strengthening of ties between the two regions is the lack of cohesion in Latin America, which has translated into a chorus of separate and sometimes conflicting voices regarding relations with Europe.

In addition, a number of countries, including Argentina, Bolivia, Colombia, Cuba, Chile, Peru, Mexico, Uruguay and Venezuela, are experiencing a resurgence of tension, involving border disputes as well as economic and political conflicts.

While Cuba’s relations with the EU are currently tense due to the bloc’s tendency to vote in favour of the annual United Nations Commission on Human Rights resolution condemning the Caribbean island nation’s human rights record, Havana’s ties with several Latin American countries, such as Peru, Honduras, Mexico and Uruguay, have cooled off for the same reason.

Bolivia and Chile, which broke off diplomatic relations in 1978, have also raised the volume on their long-standing dispute over landlocked Bolivia’s demand for an outlet to the Pacific Ocean, which it lost to Chile in the War of the Pacific (1879-1884).

On another front, Chile is annoyed with Argentina for cutting exports of natural gas, which the Chilean power industry depends on.

And the normally close ties between Argentina and Uruguay are strained because of discrepancies over pending human rights issues dating back to the two countries’ dictatorships of the 1970s and 1980s, and with respect to Mercosur integration strategies.

There have also been recent rows between two other neighbours, Colombia and Venezuela, triggered by the continuous movements of Colombian guerrillas and paramilitaries over the border between the two countries.

* Dalia Acosta in Cuba provided additional reporting.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags