Headlines, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean

VENEZUELA: Gearing Up for Decisive Battle in Recall Referendum Drive

Humberto Márquez

CARACAS, May 26 2004 (IPS) - Venezuela is gearing up for the decisive phase in the opposition’s drive to trigger a recall referendum for President Hugo Chávez.

Friday will mark the start of the signature verification process, in which 1.2 million Venezuelans will have three days to confirm or withdraw signatures that were questioned by the electoral authorities, at 2,600 tables to be set up around this South American nation.

The opposition needs 2.4 million signatures – 20 percent of registered voters – to activate a recall vote to remove the controversial populist president before the end of his six-year term, which began in 2000.

Of the nearly 3.5 million signatures that the Democratic Coordinator opposition coalition claims to have handed in, 1.9 million were declared valid by the National Electoral Council, 375,000 were disqualified, and 1.2 million were disputed and must be verified.

The opposition ”is prepared for an overwhelming victory, above and beyond (the government’s) excesses, tricks and threats,” Henry Ramos, the secretary-general of the social democratic Democratic Action, the main opposition party, said Tuesday.

But Willian Lara, the head of the governing Fifth Republic Movement, said ”it is numerically impossible to convoke a recall referendum, because the opposition has no chance of achieving the number of signatures required” by the constitution.

The constitution that was rewritten at Chávez’s request and approved by voters before it went into effect in 1999 stipulates that any elected official can be recalled if at least 20 percent of registered voters call for a referendum.

But if a referendum is held, more votes are needed to recall public officials than the number that originally put them in office.

Chávez, who was elected with 3.7 million votes in 2000, said in a meeting with small business owners Tuesday that ”a great victory for the Bolivarian revolution lies ahead” – a reference to his ”peaceful social revolution”, which takes its name from South American independence hero Simón Bolívar.

”I am calling on the opposition to accept the defeat that they will suffer, and later to agree to a dialogue,” he added.

The opposition needs at least 540,000 signatures to reach the required total of 2.4 million, which basically means that one out of every two signatures that were called into question by the electoral authorities will have to be ratified.

Súmate, the organisation that helped the opposition organise the recall referendum petition drive, estimates that at least 70 percent of the 1.2 million disputed signatures will be confirmed. Democratic Coordinator leader Enrique Mendoza said the necessary number of signatures would be obtained ”by mobilising 260,000 activists.”

A social democratic parliamentarian who asked not to be identified told IPS, however, that ”it is unlikely that the necessary number of signatures will be achieved, and the Coordinator knows that and realises that it may be heading for its third defeat.”

The previous ”defeats” he was referring to were a short-lived April 2002 coup d’etat that removed Chávez from power for two days and a two-month business and labour shutdown in December 2002 and January 2003 that failed in the attempt to pressure the president to step down or call early elections.

But Ramos said that ”no more than 50,000” of the disputed signatures will go unconfirmed, and that this minority will be ”mainly due to the government’s pressure on public employees,” who represent more than one million people in this country of 25 million.

Around 900,000 of the signatures were questioned because the petitions were filled out in the same handwriting, raising doubts as to whether opposition activists gathered citizens’ personal data to falsely present them as petitioners.

Jorge Rodríguez, one of the five members of the National Electoral Council, has insisted that Venezuelans should not be required to explain why they are ratifying or withdrawing their signatures.

Meanwhile, some 100 observers sent by the Organisation of American States (OAS) and the Carter Centre, led by former U.S. president Jimmy Carter (1977-1981), have been closely following the entire process, making continuous remarks and comments both on and off the record.

The government considers the public criticism of the verification process by the OAS and Carter Centre as going beyond the bounds of their role as observers.

The government is increasingly suspicious of the OAS mission. Ruling party lawmaker Ismael García formally asked the National Electoral Commission to cancel the election observer status of the head of the OAS mission, Fernando Jaramillo.

According to García, Jaramillo ”does not deserve to be in Venezuela, and in our view is just another member of the Democratic Coordinator.”

”Any report signed by Jaramillo would totally lack validity for us,” said another governing party legislator, Diosdado Cabello, who also criticised the Carter Centre ”for statements like the announcement that it would carry out its own parallel count, when the only body with the authority to oversee the process and offer results is the National Electoral Council.”

The OAS and Carter Centre missions did not respond to Wednesday’s criticism.

The signature verification period opens on Friday, and on Saturday OAS Secretary-General César Gaviria and Carter – a 2002 Nobel Peace Prize-winner – will arrive in Venezuela.

Chávez repeated this week that ”if the opposition collects its signatures in a transparent and valid manner, there will be a referendum.” He recently told foreign correspondents that if the recall vote is held and he is defeated, ”I’ll simply step down.”

In a column published by the Washington Post Wednesday, the president wrote that ”To be frank, I hope that my opponents have gathered enough signatures to trigger a referendum, because I relish the opportunity to once again win the people’s mandate.”

Venezuela’s leading polling firms, like Datanálisis and Keller, which are aligned with the opposition, predict that Chávez will be defeated in a referendum.

But the government and its supporters say a majority of the population back Chávez, especially since his administration began to implement massive social programmes including markets that sell subsidised food products, soup kitchens, an adult literacy drive, and efforts to bring health care to slums and other poor neighbourhoods.

In his Washington Post column, Chávez stated that ”What has enraged my opponents, most of whom are from the upper classes, is not Venezuela’s persistent misery and inequality but rather my efforts to dedicate a portion of our oil wealth to improving the lives of the poor.

”In the past six years we have doubled spending on health care and tripled the education budget. Infant mortality has fallen; life expectancy and literacy have increased,” he added.

Polling firms like Hinterlaces have found that between the two polarised extremes, around one-third of the population are ”ni-ni” or ”neither/nor” – in other words, they are affiliated with neither of the two sides, which means they could tip a recall vote either way.

Another key element is the date, because under the current electoral schedule, if enough signatures are ratified this weekend, the referendum could be held on Aug. 8.

That would be crucial for the opposition because if the vote is held before Aug. 19, when the fourth year of Chávez’s term is completed, and he is defeated, early elections would be held to replace him.

But if the referendum takes place after that deadline and Chávez loses, the vice-president, who was designated by the president himself, will serve out the remaining two years of his term.

The Democratic Coordinator’s ads urging voters to come out and ratify their signatures warn that it is ”Now or Never”.

Last weekend, a three-day verification process was held to confirm signatures demanding recall votes for one ruling party legislator and 13 opposition parliamentarians.

The preliminary results indicate that not enough signatures were validated to activate a referendum for the governing party lawmaker or two of the members of the opposition, but that enough were apparently confirmed to hold a recall vote for as many as nine opposition legislators.

If they lose their seats, the government would have a chance to expand the narrow majority it enjoys in parliament, where the correlation of forces is 85 to 80.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags