Friday, November 20, 2026
Bob Burton
- The refusal by the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) in Australia to exert pressure on the conservative Australian government to ratify the Kyoto Protocol on climate change is evidence that the organisation has gone soft, according to a report from a think-tank.
The report titled ‘Taming the Panda’ by the Canberra-based Australia Institute, argues that over the last five years WWF Australia has consistently adopted softer policy views than the overwhelming majority of other major environmental groups.
”WWF Australia’s comments are almost uniformly favourable, and often highly complimentary, to the Howard government,” report authors Clive Hamilton and Andrew Macintosh argue.
Early this month, WWF Australia published a report ‘Climate Change Solutions for Australia’ that omitted advocating that the Australian government should ratify the Kyoto Protocol. Nor does ratification of the Kyoto climate change convention rate a mention in the organisation’s election year document for assessing the performance of political parties.
General elections, in Australia, are expected to be called by October.
This omission, Hamilton and Macintosh point out, is at odds with the position adopted by WWF International, which views implementing the convention as ”an essential first step against climate change”.
Following the release of the report on Wednesday, WWF Australia did not respond to a request for an interview.
However, WWF Australia’s director of conservation, Ray Nias, told the ‘Sydney Morning Herald’ that the ratification of Kyoto was omitted from their election assessment because ”everyone else makes the point about Kyoto”.
The Kyoto Protocol obliges industrialised countries to cut emissions by 6 percent from the level in 1990.
But Prime Minister John Howard simultaneously argues that ratifying Kyoto would be too damaging to the Australian economy and bad for business.
In a bid to defuse critics, Howard is on record saying that larger cuts of greenhouse gases than mandated under the convention are necessary.
And this is a view that WWF echoes.
”In the short term Kyoto allows (Australia) to increase our emissions. We want to see deep cuts being made,” Nias was quoted as telling the ‘Sydney Morning Herald.’
Senior Lecturer in the Department of Humanities and Social Sciences at the University of Technology of Sydney, Dr James Goodman, a researcher and author on social movements argues that it is routine for companies and governments to seek out conservative groups such as WWF.
”They do this so they can present themselves as addressing the environmental issues and spin some rhetoric around it and thereby directly negate the messages that other activists are trying to get across,” Goodman told IPS.
While stating that he is not particularly familiar with WWF, Goodman is critical of large, often international non-government organisations (NGOs) that see their role as deal-makers without participating in the on-the ground campaigns and being accountable to other activists or their constituency.
”What tends to happen is that they are not only parasitic upon the movements that do the hard grassroots work and set the agenda in terms of politicising particular issues but they actively undermine the movements that are setting the agenda,” he said.
While traditionally WWF in Australia has had little grassroots presence, it has grown dramatically in recent years, largely as a result of the financial support showered on it by the Howard government.
Since 1996, when the Howard government was elected, the Australia Institute estimates that WWF Australia has received 10.65 million U.S. dollars in government funding – of which the organisation received over 9.5 million U.S. dollars in the past four years.
But WWF’s preference to develop close co-operative approaches with major corporations and governments has often seen it embroiled in controversy.
Human rights activists, for instance, remember 1997.
In that year environmental activist Ken Saro-Wiwa and eight others were executed in Nigeria for opposing Shell’s damaging oil developments in Ogoniland.
Less than eighteen months later, WWF Canada astonished activists by nominating Shell for an environmental award because it relinquished some oil exploration licences. It was later revealed that WWF Canada had received funding from the oil company.
In 2001, WWF Australia was embarrassed when a leaked internal report revealed it had done nothing to end an oil company- funded forestry project it created in Papua New Guinea that was illegally logging mangroves.
While WWF Australia states its approach is to develop ‘solutions’, environmental author and associate professor in geographical and environmental studies at the University of Adelaide, Tim Doyle, thinks otherwise.
”It is not that they are too timid, they are aggressively conservative, pushing a conservative ideological agenda of environmental management,” said Doyle.
”They say they are ‘doers’, ‘not talkers’; but their version of ‘doing’ rarely questions the status quo practices of big business and conservative/neo-liberal governments,” he told IPS.
Goodman believes that the benefit to NGOs that embrace a conservative strategy can be short lived.
”When peak NGOs sign agreements with companies or get too close to governments that has the spin off effect of those who have been undermined having a clearer understanding on their situation,” he said. ”Over time the co-opted NGOs become sidelined because, once exposed, they lose credibility and the agenda moves well beyond them.”