Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines

HONG KONG: Activists Sell Social Responsibility As Profit Builder

Peter Zirnite

HONG KONG, Sep 3 2004 (IPS) - Working out of a cramped, one-room office located on the edge of Central District – the financial and commercial heart of Hong Kong – a small group of activists has undertaken the formidable task of getting companies to understand their social responsibilities and to do a better job of addressing them.

Their mission may seem to be quixotic, as evidenced by a major real estate developer’s current marketing campaign for its holdings in Central – ”the soul of the city” – which employs a series of banners touting ”gluttony”, ”sloth”, ”greed” and other so-called deadly sins.

However, those working for Community Business are undaunted, firmly believing that the challenges they face can be overcome by getting companies to realise that corporate social responsibility (CSR) boosts profits.

”We need to show value,” stresses CEO Shalini Mahtani, a former accountant and banker who founded the non-profit organisation 18 months ago.

The Hong Kong native has a full-time staff of three and a ”regular flow” of volunteers to assist her in convincing companies that accepting social responsibility is ”fundamental to their success”.

In an interview with IPS, she points out that her experience in the financial industry is advantageous because it allows her to ”speak to people in a language that they understand”.

The first step, Mahtani says, is getting firms to understand what corporate responsibility involves. ”Many people think CSR is community investment or philanthropy,” she notes, quickly adding, ”Philanthropy is not CSR; it is part of CSR.”

Mahtani explains that, in addition to community investment – such as making charitable donations and encouraging employees to volunteer, especially on company time – corporate social responsibility also includes addressing various workplace issues.

Most companies, she says, find it ”much easier” to deal with community investment issues than those related to workplace diversity, equality and discrimination.

To get companies to understand the importance of addressing workplace issues, Community Business focuses on the business benefits it provides, according to Mahtani, who notes that these are ”all the things that build high productivity”.

Unresolved workplace issues, she adds, can result in bad publicity that adversely affects public perception, investor relations, and a company’s price share.

”It takes years, even decades, to build a reputation,” Mahtani says, ”but it can be ruined literally in seconds.”

For a corporate social responsibility programme to succeed, according to Mahtani, it must be actively embraced by top executives and not merely be used as a public relations tool.

”It shouldn’t end up in the PR department,” she asserts. ”It should be part of the corporate DNA.”

To date, Community Business has enlisted 18 member companies, which it assists in developing the skills necessary to address issues related to community investment and workplace diversity, in part by drawing on international best practices.

All, but one, of its ”corporate citizens” are local branches of multinational firms headquartered elsewhere.

The apparent lack of interest in social responsibility among Hong Kong- based firms is not surprising to Richard Welford, deputy director of the Corporate Environmental Governance Programme at the University of Hong Kong.

”They haven’t wakened up to the need,” Welford tells IPS.

Welford is the author of two recent studies on corporate social responsibility, one of which is a comparative survey of how the issue is being addressed in Europe, North America and Asia.

”Hong Kong is really lagging behind what is happening elsewhere,” he says. ”Western multinationals certainly are the ones doing the most while Japanese firms are rapidly catching up.”

He offers several reasons why Hong Kong companies are "relative laggards".

The first, Welford says, is linked to the fact that many local companies are ”essentially family-owned businesses” with few shareholders. As a result, he explains, ”there is not a great deal of pressure from shareholders in Hong Kong, as there is in other parts of the world.”

Welford also cites the lack of government pressure on companies to act in a more socially responsible manner.

While officials Singapore, Malaysia and elsewhere in Asia have been successful in pressuring companies, he says, ”That’s not happening in Hong Kong. Here, the government has a very laissez-affaire attitude toward what businesses are doing.”

His study of business sustainability, released in early August, indicates there is a direct link between the level of corporate social responsibility in a country and its economic competitiveness.

Welford says this is because demonstrating social responsible has become a critical factor in gaining access to international markets.

Interestingly, the only local company Community Business has engaged so far is the MTR Corporation, which operates Hong Kong’s mass transit rail system and does not have to worry about international market access. Even so, MTR officials believe improving the company’s record on social responsibility is vital to its future success.

While it is ”too early” to assess MTR’s work with Community Business, external relations manager Maggie So is confident it will benefit company efforts to ”build a cohesive relationship” with customers.

”We need to serve our customers well,” she says. ”If we do, they will come back and bring us more business, and that is good for the shareholders.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags