Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights

CHINA: Safety Valve for Absorbing Discontent in Danger of Exploding

Antoaneta Bezlova

BEIJING, Nov 9 2004 (IPS) - As China considers doing away with one of its unique communist vestiges, the ‘shangfang’ – or the system of petitioning the government – there are fears that scrapping the only channel available to people to air their grievances might lead to a serious escalation of social unrest in the country.

For more than fifty years of communist rule, ‘shangfang’ has provided the disgruntled with an opportunity to gain redress from the highest levels of government.

Communist China’s founding fathers from the late chairman Mao Zedong to paramount leader Deng Xiaoping have used the petitioning system to present a benevolent face to people who had been wronged by local officials and deprived of the chance to a fair trial.

Now, however, social researchers and legal experts argue this rather imperial way of meting out justice is undermining China’s efforts to establish a modern society based on the rule of law.

Disillusioned with leaders and law enforcers at the local level, plaintiffs often choose to spend months in Beijing petition offices rather than go through the slow motions in Chinese courts.

But the rapidly escalating number of grievances has rendered the system totally inefficient and there seems to be mass discontent, according to researchers.

The success rate of China’s petitioners is infinitesimal. Last year, the government’s Petition Office received more than 10 million petitions but just two out of every thousand cases were resolved, according to a new survey published in the Guangzhou-based ‘Southern Weekend.’

The question, now, is if the petitioning system is maddeningly ineffective, what alternatives are there for the poor to seek redress against corrupt local officials.

”Many people are running afoul of our proposals to abolish the system,” said Yu Jianrong, a researcher of rural issues with the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. ”In fact, we don’t propose to seal off this outlet for redress – people can still use it to voice their opinions, but we suggested to the government to separate people’s right to social relief from the old system of petitioning top leaders.”

”If the system is not reformed, the political outcome for the government could be disastrous,” Yu who is leading the team in charge of the ‘shangfang’ survey told the ‘Southern Weekend.’

The proposal submitted to the high echelons of Chinese government comes at an explosive time. In recent months China has experienced a series of violent ethnic clashes and riots that have forced open the floodgates of pent-up social anger.

Despite restrictions on reporting, news about various protests reflecting seething resentments across this country of 1.3 billion have filtered through the state-run media and prompted alarm among Chinese leaders.

The state ‘Xinhua’ news agency even reported the five days of pitched battles, this month, between thousands of Hui Muslims and Han Chinese villagers in the central Henan province. The agency said seven people were killed and 42 injured, but other local sources told foreign media that as many as 148 people died, including 18 police officers.

The rioting was triggered by a simple traffic accident, which pitted the mostly Han residents of one village against Hui Muslims from a neighbouring hamlet.

A number of other riots, protests and clashes have been reported over the past weeks, showing grievances were widespread and the underprivileged driven to desperation.

In another case of widespread civic unrest in Hanyuan County in Sichuan province, villagers rioted over the loss of their land to a dam project and the meager compensation and relocation package offered by the government.

Up to 100,000 farmers clashed with the police last week, forcing Chinese leaders to impose martial law and dispatch droves of paramilitary police to stabilise the area.

Despite China’s economic expansion, many citizens are simmering with discontent and independent observers say resentment among the country’s disenfranchised is running high in the country.

More than three million people took part in protests and demonstrations in the month of September alone, according to the New York-based Human Rights in China. In more than 100 cases nationwide, protests escalated into large, violent clashes between demonstrators and local police, resulting in the torching of several government buildings.

Those caught up in the disputes – mostly farmers, industrial workers and members of ethnic minorities – represent a wide spectrum of disadvantaged groups. Unable to voice their discontent, they are often ready to resort to drastic action when their rights are trampled upon.

In one of the most recent examples, seven migrant workers in the northern city of Shenyang tried to commit pact suicide by swallowing large doses of sleeping pills together. In their case, replayed in many places throughout the country, all their yearly wages had been stolen by the building contractor who had recruited them to work and later fled the site once the construction was finished.

The increasing social strife is an indication of the widening wealth gap between China’s rich and poor, pervasive corruption and officials’ aloofness towards people’s grievances. According to World Bank statistics, income disparity in China is now wider than in India, and nearing the levels of Latin America.

Most of the rural protests occur when peasants are cheated by local officials of their land, says Li Ping, the Beijing representative of the Rural Development Institute – a U.S.- based non-governmental organisation. ”The problem of illegal land seizures is widespread and can lead to even more rural protests in the future,” Li said in an interview.

In China’s rush towards modernisation, more than 40 million farmers have been displaced and the number is increasing by more than two million a year. Farmers without land are now among the poorest people in the country, says Zhao Dianguo, an official with the Labour and Social Security Ministry.

Beijing fears that if the entrenched system of petitioning is revoked, pent-up social anger could find more dangerous outlets.

Yet top leaders have no choice but to reform the obsolete mechanism of ‘shangfang’, according to Yu Jianrong, the rural researcher. ”What we ultimately want is a rule by the law and not the cult of honest officials and resolutions scribbled on our petitions by superiors.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags