Sunday, November 22, 2026
Antoaneta Bezlova
- China’s explosive economic growth and world superpower ambitions are prompting many developed countries to rethink their aid to the country as lending agencies begin to cut back on loans and focus instead on funding economic advisors to the government.
”Many cooperation offices here are asking themselves whether there is any point in giving them money when they (the Chinese) are preparing to send two people to space next year and spending a fortune on rebuilding Beijing and Shanghai,” said a Beijing-based Western diplomat.
China’s second manned space flight will carry two astronauts into space next year and will orbit the Earth for five days. The country’s space authorities made the announcement about the mission, early this month at an air show in China’s Guangzhou Province.
Signs that the international community was beginning to feel uneasy about lending to China emerged in August when a group of Japanese lawmakers recommended a cut in development aid pledged by Tokyo to Beijing. ”We could not find any need to continue promoting China-bound official development assistance,” the lawmakers said in a report outlining their findings.
Indeed, China is no longer the needy communist pariah state as espoused by the late leader Deng Xiaoping when he pleaded with the World Bank in 1980 to re-introduce his country into its lending system following Beijing’s years of self-imposed isolation..
Even in the eyes of the World Bank’s current president James D. Wolfensohn – a long-time supporter of huge loans to China – things have changed.
Based on its extreme poverty benchmark of living on less than one U.S. dollar a day, the World Bank estimates that China’s impoverished population has fallen sharply from more than 600 million in 1981 (64 percent of the population at the time) to 132 million or 11 percent of the population in 2004.
In May 2004, the World Bank and China co-hosted a global conference on poverty reduction in Shanghai, an event that offered stunning testimony to the ways in which China has, both, developed its economy and re-introduced itself to the world over the past 24 years.
On the eve of the conference, Wolfensohn told his Chinese hosts that the World Bank has recently reduced its lending to the country because China has ”so much money”.
”Frankly you don’t need to borrow money for a lot of the projects that you can finance yourselves,” Wolfensohn was reported as saying about China.
For years, China has been experiencing an economic growth of more than nine percent per annum. And there are fears that the country’s economy may overheat.
At the end of September, China’s foreign-exchange reserves reached 514 billion U.S. dollars, the second highest in the world after Japan’s.
The country is now becoming a lender to the developing world. China recently pledged to add a combined 100 million dollars to the coffers of the Asian Development Fund and the African Development Fund.
Figures released by the Ministry of Commerce show that in the first 10 months this year, China attracted 53.8 billion dollars in foreign direct investment (FDI), up 23.47 percent from last year. The inflow of FDI has been instrumental in modernising the country and setting the benchmark for local enterprises to expand their businesses.
Yet the vast flow of direct foreign investment into China, which has dwarfed that of multilateral lending agencies, is now prompting many donors to reduce or redirect their aid.
Compared with the exceptional levels of the 1990s, World Bank lending to China has fallen off in recent years. The World Bank lent 1.14 billion dollars to China in the year ending June 2003, down from 2.8 billion dollars in fiscal year 1997, according to the agency’s website.
Because of increases in China’s per capita income in recent years, the country no longer qualifies for soft loans from the International Development Association (IDA), the World Bank’s concessionary lending arm.
Though China continues to receive traditional development loans, the World Bank is tailoring its efforts to the country’s changing needs. In recent years, the Bank has focused on its role as an economic policy adviser to the Chinese government, providing analyses and suggestions on issues ranging from fiscal reform to environmental protection.
Development financing is no longer a priority for other donors either. While the European Commission continues to pledge 72 million euros (94 million dollars) in development aid to China every year, the focus of its co-operation programme is on training civil servants and judges..
”The Chinese say they need more aid for poverty alleviation but there are certainly moral issues here for many, because of Beijing’s military budget and their ambitious space programme,” notes another Western diplomat.
China’s officially announced defence budget for 2004 is 25 billion dollars. However, the U.S. Department of Defence estimates that actual military-related spending in 2003 has been in the range of 50 to 70 billion dollars, making China the third largest defence spender in the world, after the United States and Russia.
Japan – one of China’s largest country donors, is clearly uncomfortable with Beijing’s defence buildup. Citing the country’s rampant military spending and its rise as an economic powerhouse, earlier this month a group of Japanese lawmakers recommended a cut in aid to China.
The lawmakers’ report concluded that new development aid to China was not necessary and loans to China should be reduced to a level at which outstanding capital would not increase.
”Among the criticism of (Japan’s) China-bound official development assistance are its remarkable economic development, growing defence expenditure and anti-Japanese education,” the report said.
Japan has so far pledged 3.33 trillion yen (32.3 billion dollars) in official development assistance for China. In fiscal year 2002, China ranked second after Indonesia as the main recipient of yen loans.
But Tokyo is vexed that Beijing shows little appreciation for this cash flow while fanning anti-Japanese sentiment among China’s youth.
The rowdy affair that ensued during the Asian Cup final between Japan and China on Aug. 7 when Chinese fans threw bottles, shouted obscenities and burned Japanese flags, after Japan won, is a stark reminder that all’s not well between the two East Asian countries.