Sunday, November 22, 2026
Linus Atarah
- In Brazil rubber tappers living in the Amazon forest are locked in deadly conflicts with timber loggers and big agribusiness companies, with up to ten activists killed every year, NGOs working in the country say.
In Kenya large-scale production of cut flowers for export is increasingly wresting farmland from peasants and leaving in its wake polluted water sources and people afflicted with skin rashes.
While both instances involve ecological damage, the problem cannot be addressed without tackling the issue of democracy, participants said at a conference on the environment here Thursday.
Instead a link should be made between preserving the environment and the struggle for democratic participation within society, participants said. In short, ecological democracy.
The seminar was organised by the Siemenpuu Foundation, a Finnish organisation that supports environmental work in developing countries. It brought together activists, researchers and policy makers from South America, Africa and India.
"Environmental issues cannot be de-linked from social issues," said Juan Carlos Carrasco Rueda of the Brazil Rubber Tappers Union (CNS). The central task in environmental protection is to develop just public policies for all, he said.
Risto Isomaki of Friends of the Earth said globalisation is rapidly generating a crisis of democracy that is diminishing people participation in social and political life. The idea behind ecological democracy is to draw the attention of environmental groups to this crisis in democracy.
"Driving people out of a forest in order to preserve it eventually makes them enemies and not friends of the reservation," Isomaki said. Tackling conservation within the frame of ecological democracy would help environmental organisations consider the need of local communities to control their resources, he said.
Thomas Wallgren, activist and lecturer of philosophy at the University of Helsinki said northern analysis of the environmental problems of the south has often glossed over the concerns of people affected by the problem.
Northern organisations and governments should avoid "green paternalism", Wallgren said. They should also avoid a sectoral approach to environmental protection issues in the south. Instead the approach should include an analysis of international power structures and a demand for more democratisation of global relations.
"Why for instance, is President Lula Da Silva of Brazil not able to implement a radical environmental programme?" Wallgren asked. Because he has to address his country’s international debts and the fact that he is held hostage by powerful domestic, international agribusiness and financial institutions, he said.
"We can bring in the best World Bank experts to give advice on how best to tackle the problem but that is not sufficient unless we involve the people affected by the problem," he said.
Rueda said that after 20 years of working with rubber tappers in the Amazon forest, CNS has realised that ecological and social issues must go hand in hand in any attempts to preserve the Amazon forest.
"The environmental and social problems are two sides of the same coin which must be resolved simultaneously in order to conserve the forests or advance the living conditions of the people," he said.
Rueda said overseas development agencies and NGOs from industrialised countries have never made this socio-ecological link in their intervention to preserve the Amazon forest. The result is projects and programmes that focus only on the physical nature of the forest such as animals and plants without concern for the people, he said.
Development has come to mean expansion of agro-business, large-scale cattle breeding and soya farming, he said. Over the last 15 years 243,393 square kilometers of the Amazon forest, about five percent, has been lost to large-scale commercial activities, he said.
The CNS is working to create extractive reserves for people living in the forest. These are designated government land but controlled by the local communities.
Not every delegate at the conference was a convert to ecological democracy. Chachage Seithy, professor of sociology at the University of Dar es Salaam in Tanzania said ‘ecological democracy’ is only another fashion after the likes of ‘self-reliant development’, ‘endogenous development’ and ‘participatory development’.
He acknowledged that an ever changing conceptual shift can be an expression of actual change. But he was doubtful about the ability of southern NGOs to bring it about. "Southern NGOs in many cases are not legitimate representatives of the people and therefore do not understand their problems," he said.