Economy & Trade, Headlines, Human Rights, Labour, Latin America & the Caribbean

LABOUR: Workers in Latin America Heavily Affected by Economic Insecurity

María Cecilia Espinosa

SANTIAGO, Nov 23 2004 (IPS) - -Economic insecurity affects the vast majority of the world’s workers, but is especially marked in Latin America, according to officials from the International Labour Organisation (ILO), a UN specialised agency.

"Systems for the protection of workers have not kept up with the changes that have taken place in countries and labour markets as a result of technology, globalisation or economic development models," José Figueiredo, the senior economist and research coordinator for the ILO Socio-Economic Security Programme, told IPS.

According to a recent ILO report, "Economic Security for a Better World", roughly 73 percent – almost three-quarters – of the world’s workers live in circumstances of economic insecurity, while only eight percent live in countries that offer a high degree of security.

The report, prepared by the Geneva-based programme headed by Figueiredo and based on four years of research, reveals that economic security leads to personal happiness, and is beneficial in terms of growth, development and social stability.

As part of the research for the report, over 48,000 workers were surveyed in 15 countries: Argentina, Bangladesh, Brazil, Chile, China, Ethiopia, Ghana, Hungary, India, Indonesia, Pakistan, Russia, South Africa, Tanzania and Ukraine.

A second survey, on job flexibility and security, was carried out in over 10,000 workplaces in 11 of these countries.


The report addressed seven forms of work-related security: income, labour markets, employment, skills, work, jobs and representation.

The ILO grouped the countries studied into four categories: "pacesetters" (with good policies, good institutions and good outcomes), "pragmatists" (good outcomes in spite of less impressive policies or institutions), "conventionals" (seemingly good policies and institutions but with less impressive outcomes) and "much-to-be-done countries" (weak or non-existent policies and institutions and poor outcomes).

The study found that political democracy, respect for civil liberties and government spending on social security significantly increase economic security, while economic growth has only a limited effect on security in the medium and long term.

For Figueiredo, the most striking conclusion of the report is the gap between the needs of workers and the protections offered to them.

"The world is facing new systemic risks. Someone living in Brazil will suffer the effects of a financial shock in Asia, because the crisis will inevitably spread there, and there is no system to protect people against this," he said.

Interestingly, the study found that higher levels of skills and training are actually inversely related to well-being, because a growing number of people feel that the skills and qualifications they possess do not correspond to the jobs that they are obliged to perform, leading to what the report calls "status frustration".

The researchers also determined that the global distribution of economic security does not correspond to the global distribution of income.

Whereas countries in South and Southeast Asia have a greater share of global economic security than their share of the world’s income, the Latin American countries, by contrast, offer their citizens less economic security than would be expected from their relative income levels.

As a consequence of globalisation, the world economy has become increasingly prone to crises and abrupt periods of recession that spread around the planet, and Latin America is the region most severely affected as a result. Between 1980 and 1998, more than 40 economic crises hit Latin America, leading to a drop in gross regional product of over four percent.

The region, represented in the report by Argentina, Brazil and Chile, was found to fare worse than the global average in terms of a decline in economic growth rates in per capita terms and an increase in the variability of annual economic growth rates, implying greater economic insecurity.

The ILO report stated that Latin America has the most unequal distribution of wealth in the world, and that in terms of economic security, 42 percent of the region’s nations fall into the category of "much-to-be-done countries", while a third rated as "conventionals" and another 25 percent as "pragmatists". None of the region’s countries could be considered a "pacesetter" in economic security.

In the Latin American nations studied, over two-thirds of workers in urban areas had jobs with at least some degree of informality, and women were found to be particularly affected.

The status of the workplaces studied did not necessarily determine that of their employees. In Chile, 38 percent of workers in informal enterprises had formal employment conditions, while 42 percent of employees of formal companies had informal labour relations (as a result of outsourcing, for example).

According to Figueiredo, the researchers also found a great deal of statistical evidence that women are suffering more, especially within workplaces. "We found that in almost all of the countries studied, women did not have the same opportunities for training or promotion within the company," he explained.

For the head of the research office of the Chilean Department of Labour, Malva Espinosa, globalisation is not in itself a negative factor with regard to economic security, given the opportunities and benefits offered by the opening up of trade.

The risks derive largely from "the instability of employment and businesses and the dependence on internationally set prices for our exports," Espinosa told IPS.

But in this world of uncertainties and risks, she added, it should not be up to the most vulnerable sectors to take the brunt of the consequences. "The poorest, least qualified people should not have to pay for the risks that should be absorbed by society as a whole," she said.

To deal with this high degree of risk, the ILO calls for the development of protection mechanisms, including adequate coverage in the event of unemployment, noted Espinosa, who added that "state or mixed mechanisms, and creative ideas from governments to protect the population" are essential to revert economic insecurity.

The ILO report, she noted, establishes that economic security should be viewed as a human right, as well a necessary step towards real freedom.

Figueiredo advocates state protection policies based on rights, such as the right to a minimum income for all citizens. Moreover, he added, state policies should have a universal scope, and not be limited to the poor, "because that would only solve the problem of that particular sector, and in a crisis, more people are left vulnerable."

According to the ILO report, people in countries that provide their citizens with a high level of economic security have a higher level of happiness on average. The key factor for happiness and satisfaction, however, is not income level, but rather the extent of income security, measured in terms of income protection and a low degree of income inequality.

For ILO representative Fabián Bertranou, "many of the insecurities affecting workers are not only related to income or employment, but also to other aspects of their working lives, such as professional development, social protection, or pensions for the future."

All of these concerns undoubtedly affect levels of productivity, he added.

Figueiredo concurred. "We have evidence that when workers are provided with more security, both society and businesses work better. The Scandinavian countries are among the world’s wealthiest, and they have both the highest levels of social protection and the highest levels of production," he concluded.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags