Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Raúl Pierri
- "She was just six months old when she died last May. Her mother fed her only the water in which she boiled the pumpkin that she gave the rest of her children. The baby died of malnutrition," reads a new human rights report from Uruguay.
This case is an illustration of how times have changed in a country once known as "the Switzerland of South America", which prides itself on its strong social welfare programmes and relatively egalitarian social structure.
The severe economic crisis that peaked in 2002 has done enormous damage to the social fabric, while the country’s social indicators – although still among the highest in Latin America – have declined.
And although the distribution of income in Uruguay remains among the most equal in the region, the gap between the middle class and the poor is steadily growing.
The annual report by the Peace and Justice Service (SERPAJ), presented last week in Montevideo, especially highlights the critical social situation in the northern department (province) of Artigas, where infant mortality has shot up in the last few years.
"I am often asked: what do you think is the worst problem in human rights in our world today? I reply ‘extreme poverty’. Extreme poverty means a denial of the exercise of all human rights and undermines the dignity and worth of the individual," Mary Robinson, a former United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, once said.
Those who live in poverty have limited opportunities, freedoms and choices, and fewer chances of becoming the "protagonists of their own destiny. In short, their dignity is diminished," said Mandeville.
Uruguay fell into recession in 1999, and in 2002 the financial system collapsed, unemployment soared to a record high of nearly 20 percent, exports plunged to levels last seen during the 1973-1985 military dictatorship, wages plummeted and the country’s foreign reserves virtually dried up.
Unemployment has now dropped to just over 13 percent, thanks to the steady economic recovery seen since 2003, which has been largely due to an improvement in the international prices of the leading commodities exported by Uruguay, such as beef and soybeans.
At a press conference last Friday, on the occasion of International Human Rights Day, Mandeville said that "what is needed are public and private efforts, social mechanisms, institutions, and of course legal frameworks that guarantee human freedoms, including the right to have access to greater options and opportunities."
"The notion of integral citizenship, in full exercise of all rights, means poverty must be tackled not as a problem of dearth or scarcity in material terms, but as a multi-dimensional phenomenon, where it is not possible to merely address one aspect separate from the whole," he added.
The annual report by SERPAJ – a human rights group founded in 1974 in Argentina by Nobel Peace laureate Adolfo Perez Esquivel – on human rights in Uruguay puts a special emphasis on the need to esnure respect for economic, social and cultural rights.
"We are looking at a country that is breaking down. If we do not understand this on time, we will not be able to do so later," warned political analyst Gerardo Caetano, director of the Political Science Institute at the public University of the Republic.
"The notion of the state as the protector of the weak has broken down. We must once again demand that the state be the guarantor of human rights," he added.
In its 2004 report, SERPAJ notes that there are nearly 42,000 less jobs and around 25,500 more unemployed Uruguayans than when President Jorge Batlle of the centre-right Colorado Party took office in March 2000.
In March 2005, Batlle will hand over the reins to socialist president-elect Tabaré Vázquez, who will govern at the head of the leftist Broad Front coalition, which will also hold an absolute majority in parliament.
The report further states that "Uruguay is far from generating decent jobs, in the formal economy, with good pay and the due guarantees."
Jobs and social conditions are becoming more and more precarious, especially in certain sectors of society, said Fernando Willat, a member of SERPAJ’s economic rights team.
Willat pointed out that an unprecedented 32 percent of Uruguay’s 3.4 million people have fallen below the poverty line, including 75,000 who live in extreme poverty. Meanwhile, the infant mortality rate rose from 13.6 per 1,000 live births in 2002 to 15 per 1,000 in 2003.
The SERPAJ report states that "the crisis of 2002 led to a rise in malnutrition, especially among young children in poor or extremely poor homes."
In the northern department of Artigas, where the six-month-old malnourished baby who was mentioned by the report died, infant mortality climbed from 13 per 1,000 in 2002 to 28.9 per 1,000 in 2003.
Caetano stressed the need "not to lose the ability to feel shocked and indignant" about the worsening social situation, and said the argument that Uruguay is the "least unequal" country in the region is "unacceptable."
"You can take a bus from the (upscale Montevideo) neighbourhood of Pocitos, where infant mortality stands at four per 1,000, similar to European rates, and get off in the (poor suburban district) of Nuevo París, where infant mortality has risen to 40 per 1,000, closer to rates found in Africa," he said.
SERPAJ also called once again for full compliance with article 4 of Uruguay’s amnesty law.
That law, approved by voters in a 1989 referendum, put an end to prosecutions of members of the security forces accused of committing human rights abuses during the dictatorship, when according to Amnesty International, Uruguay had the highest proportion of political prisoners (many of whom were tortured) of any country in the world.
Article 4 states that the government must investigate the fate of Uruguayans who became the victims of forced disappearance during the de facto regime.
The investigation by a Peace Commission set up by the Batlle administration concluded that 26 Uruguayans died as a result of torture during the dictatorship, and that their remains were buried or cremated and thrown into the sea.
Another 128 Uruguayans were detained and disappeared in Argentina, seven in Chile, two in Paraguay and one in Bolivia as part of Operation Condor, a coordinated plan among the military governments that ruled the countries of the Southern Cone of Latin America in the 1970s and 1980s that was used to track down, capture and often eliminate left-wing opponents.
"It isn’t that we are trapped in the past, as some people accuse us of being. We just do not want this country to be an island of impunity. The Peace Commission made some progress in its time, but it was not entirely satisfactory," said Willat.