Saturday, November 21, 2026
María Cecilia Espinosa
- Tensions are rising between Chile and the European Union (EU) in the dispute that has erupted over new barriers to imports of Chilean salmon.
This South American country has announced that it will appeal to the World Trade Organisation (WTO), while the EU insists that its measures are legally grounded.
The Chilean government and fishing industry representatives have agreed to call for consultations in the WTO within a month’s time. If satisfactory results are not achieved, a three-member WTO panel will be designated to rule on the legality of the EU safeguard measures.
The EU, which absorbs eight percent of Chile’s salmon exports, established quotas, tariffs and minimum prices for salmon imported from Chile, Norway and the Faeroe Islands.
The quota set for Chilean salmon is 16,033 tons until August of this year and 36,146 tons from then until August 2006. A tariff of almost 35 percent will be charged on any imports above that ceiling.
The EU also established minimum prices of 2.7 euros (3.5 dollars) per gram of fresh fish and 2.59 euros (3.3 dollars) per kilo of frozen fish.
The safeguards, scheduled to remain in effect until 2008, could lead to an 18 percent drop in Chilean salmon exports.
The EU’s executive arm, the European Commission, justified the measures as a means of protecting Scottish and Irish fish farmers, whose complaints over rising imports led to the decision.
The president of the Chilean Salmon Industry Association (SalmonChile), Carlos Vial, called the EU decision "arbitrary and unjust", because it "totally contradicts the free trade agreement signed between Chile and the European Union, violating the guarantees of free trade contained therein."
Salmon and trout exports to EU countries during the first 11 months of 2004 brought Chile 107.5 million dollars in revenues, said Vial.
The safeguards will "directly limit the development of salmon farming in Chile and close the doors to further growth in the EU market despite the existence of an economic cooperation agreement," he added.
SalmonChile general manager Rodrigo Infante maintained that the new limits will not only affect Chilean exports, but also the world salmon market in general.
Market adjustments to the price floors established will lead to an overall drop in the volume of trade, since "local producers do not need to comply with the minimum import price and the quotas set for Chile are lower than the amount we are currently exporting to this market," he said.
The Chilean salmon industry is also concerned by the fact that investments in the sector will be more difficult to recover, which will undoubtedly curb further expansion and job creation.
Chile signed a free trade agreement with the EU two years ago, and since then, "our greatest problems in reaching this market were related to its distance, which is why the whole line of frozen products was created," said Infante.
At the same time, he added, redirecting exports to buyers like the United States and Asia will distort the market and could lead to a troubling decline in world market prices for salmon.
In his opinion, the EU "has not convincingly demonstrated the harm supposedly suffered by salmon producers in Ireland and Scotland, which is a necessary prerequisite for applying the safeguards."
According to Infante, the smoked salmon processing industry, which relies on imported raw materials, accounts for a much larger number of jobs in Europe than the fisheries sector, "so free trade benefits many more people."
Jocelyn Holt, head of international affairs for the co-governing Chilean Social Democratic Party, told IPS that the European salmon market "has been a source of conflict for 15 years, with producers in Scotland and Ireland, and now Latvia, pushing for regulation, because of the influence exerted by Norway and the market share captured by Chile."
"Now they have concluded that they need safeguards to regulate the market, and safeguards are not designed to regulate the market, but rather to respond to unfair trade practices," she said.
Ricardo Lagos Weber, director of multilateral affairs at the Chilean Foreign Ministry, believes that an appeal to the WTO will carry greater weight than any bilateral mechanisms.
The Chilean government has not ruled out a second option, which would be to convince the government of an EU member state to request a review of the measure in the European Commission.
In any event, Lagos Weber recognises that the adoption of safeguards was a foreseeable possibility, given the growth of the Chilean fish farming industry and its increased presence on the international market, factors which contributed to the potential for a trade dispute.
Carlos Vilches, a lawmaker from the opposition National Renovation Party, told IPS that "Chilean salmon is a product that seriously competes on the European market, making it the country’s second largest export industry and representing volumes that could frighten European producers."
In an attempt to prevent the adoption of safeguards, the Chilean government, lawmakers and industry representatives undertook major lobbying efforts, which included the submission of three documents to the European Commission, foreign ministry contacts with numerous European ministries, and joint meetings with officials and private sector representatives in Brussels.
Nevertheless, the right-wing opposition accuses the Chilean government – led by the centre-left Concertación por la Democracia coalition – of lacking sufficient foresight and reacting too late to the "salmon crisis".
Vilches called the government’s conduct "naïve", adding that "they had the information and should have recognised that this was a problem we were bound to be facing. They need to involve experts who have detailed knowledge of this issue in order to find a solution."
In his opinion, the Chilean government should immediately appeal to the WTO dispute settlement committee.
Holt, for her part, remained optimistic in the face of the new measures. "It is highly unlikely that the safeguards will hold up in the WTO. The majority of appeals taken to the organisation have been successful," she said.
The European Commission "knows perfectly well that there is solid opposition to the adoption of these measures on the part of a considerable number of European countries. At a meeting held on Jan. 21, 11 countries voiced their rejection of these restrictions, which is a sufficient number to block the measure in the Council of Ministers," Holt noted.
If only one country appeals to the Council of Ministers before Mar. 7 and demands that the safeguards be approved by the qualified majority required by the EU in these cases, the initiative will fail, she added.
In the meantime, the European Commission responded on Tuesday to Chile’s request for consultations in the WTO.
Claude Veron-Reville, spokeswoman for European Trade Commissioner Peter Mandelson, said that while the EU is willing to listen to Chile’s arguments, it has the factual and legal grounds needed to enforce the new safeguard measures.