Europe, Headlines, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean

RIGHTS: EU Truce with Cuba Questioned

Stefania Bianchi

BRUSSELS, Feb 1 2005 (IPS) - The European Union’s decision to restore diplomatic ties with Cuba Monday has angered human rights and press groups.

European Union (EU) foreign ministers agreed Monday (Jan. 31) to end the two-year freeze in relations with the communist regime, which was triggered by a clampdown on dissidents by Havana in 2003.

Ministers signalled that EU embassies in Havana would re-open diplomatic contacts with Fidel Castro’s government, but vowed to maintain pressure on the communist leader.

However, opponents to restoring high-level ties with the Caribbean island state say the EU had bowed to demands from the Cuban leader and promoted the wrong message for those who remain imprisoned.

The decision came after Castro’s regime released 14 dissidents last year.

The sanctions were imposed on Cuba after 75 dissidents were given long prison sentences of between six and 28 years, and three Cubans found guilty of hijacking a ferry were executed.


The EU banned high-level official visits to Cuba, and participation in cultural events. EU member states started inviting dissidents to embassy parties. Castro responded by freezing out the EU embassies.

In recent months Spain’s socialist government led by Prime Minister Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero played a crucial role in promoting a review of EU policy towards Cuba.

Monday’s decision will allow the resumption of high-level visits, although such trips must be used to push for improvements in human rights and the rights of dissidents in Cuba, the EU says.

A statement approved by EU foreign ministers said the union was willing to resume "a constructive dialogue with the Cuban authorities aiming at tangible results in the political, economic, human rights and cooperation sphere."

But the ministers stressed they would develop "more intense relations with the peaceful political opposition and broader layers of civil society in Cuba."

Jean Asselborn, Luxembourg’s foreign minister, whose country currently holds the rotating presidency of the EU, said the bloc was calling for the "urgent" and "unconditional" release of the remaining dissidents detained in Cuba.

"We highlighted the need to support a process leading to democratic pluralism, respect for human rights and basic freedoms," he said Monday.

But in spite of such conditions, critics say the warming in relations will send the wrong message to Cuba.

Four of the bloc’s 25 member states – the Czech Republic, the Netherlands, Poland and Slovakia – were amongst those who are particularly opposed to lifting the sanctions.

Czech foreign minister Cyril Svoboda said: "We are on our territory and we can invite whomever we want." Poland’s state secretary Jan Tuszczynski said that if dissidents arrive at the Polish national day reception, "we will not throw them out."

Joel Simon, deputy director of the New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) which promote press freedom worldwide, said dialogue and negotiations between the EU and Cuba could be positive as long as the EU avoids "creating the perception that Cuba is being rewarded" for releasing a handful of prisoners while many more remain in jail.

"The EU should recognise that the while the release of independent journalists and dissidents is good news, conditions have not really changed in Cuba," he told IPS.

"What troubles me is that Cuba seems to view the liberty of the journalists and other dissidents as something that can be used to manipulate international public opinion," he added. "The EU should not play along with this game."

Human Rights Watch (HRW) says the EU should make normalising relations with Cuba dependent on Cuba’s meaningful progress on human rights. It says meaningful progress would include the release of all wrongfully imprisoned dissidents.

"Cuba’s recent release of some of the dissidents is a welcome step, but it does not signal a meaningful change in the government’s repressive policies," Jose Miguel Vivanco, HRW Americas director said Monday.

"President Fidel Castro is using human beings as pawns in a political game aimed at improving relations with Europe," he added.

HRW is urging Cuba to establish legal reforms designed to protect the rights to freedom of expression and association. "The Cuban government continues to restrict freedom of expression, association, assembly, movement and the press," the group said Monday..

The decision will be reviewed in July to see if Cuba’s human rights record has improved.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags