Development & Aid, Headlines, Health, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean

CHILE: Renewed Debate on Dying with Dignity, ‘Therapeutic Cruelty’ and Euthanasia

Gustavo González

SANTIAGO, Apr 5 2005 (IPS) - The Terri Schiavo case revived the debate in Chile on euthanasia, medical ethics and the right to die with dignity at a time when technological advances in medicine make it possible to delay death or prolong life in a “cruel” manner, according to bioethics expert Sergio Zorrilla.

The heavy international media coverage of the Mar. 31 death of Schiavo, whose feeding tube was disconnected after she spent 15 years in a “persistent vegetative state”, prompted Chilean parliamentary Deputy Guido Girardi, a medical doctor, to call for passage of a bill on “death with dignity”, while Senator Nelson Avila urged his fellow lawmakers to set aside “preconceptions” and enact a new law on passive euthanasia.

Girardi, of the co-governing Party for Democracy, has proposed “living will” legislation in this heavily Roman Catholic South American country of 16 million.

The living will, which has been legal in some European countries since the 1970s, is a written document containing detailed advance instructions regarding the use or removal of life-sustaining or death-delaying procedures in the event of terminal illness or incapacity.

Avila, who belongs to the Radical Social Democratic Party, which also forms part of the ruling centre-left Coalition for Democracy, urged Congress to begin to debate a bill that he introduced in January.

The bill would make it possible for doctors to cut off or withhold extraordinary life-prolonging procedures or life-support for patients with no hope of recovery.

Passive euthanasia contrasts with active euthanasia, which is the intentional termination of life by a doctor, “for humanitarian reasons,” at the express wish of a patient with a fatal disease who is experiencing unbearable suffering with no prospect of improvement, the senator pointed out.

Passive or negative euthanasia, on the other hand, “is common in all of the country’s hospitals, but is not publicly discussed except in a few specific cases that have drawn media attention,” said Avila.

“The same thing occurs with therapeutic abortion, while 150,000 (clandestine) abortions a year are practised in Chile (where abortion is illegal), and everyone prefers to look the other way,” he added.

Professor Domingo Lovera, a lawyer with the Public Interest Clinic at the private Diego Portales University, told IPS that Girardi’s bill on living wills recognises an individual’s right to self-determination.

“People have a right to live their own lives with dignity, and to die with dignity as well,” said Lovera.

“When the state assumes that life is a higher value that goes beyond the individual’s right to decide, it is adopting a moral conception of life, which may or may not be shared by the citizens. That kind of response from the state disregards our moral autonomy,” said the lawyer.

He added, however, that it is difficult to guarantee “death with dignity” in Chile, because the courts consider life “the most precious gift,” which refers to “the natural right that no one can take our lives, but in no way recognises our control over our own lives.”

But Jesuit priest Tony Mifsud, director of the Ethics Centre at the private Alberto Hurtado University, said Deputy Girardi’s bill is in need of clearer definitions.

“Dying with dignity is a phrase that is used today with different meanings. Some see euthanasia as dying with dignity. Others, like myself, do not agree with that. Dying with dignity is refraining from meddling with people when there is no hope, so that the natural process can take its course,” he commented to IPS.

The legal and moral battle that surrounded Schiavo’s death, as well as the films “The Sea Inside” by Spanish filmmaker Alejandro Amenábar and “Million Dollar Baby” directed by Hollywood’s Clint Eastwood, sparked renewed media interest in cases in Chile involving patients with severe brain damage or who have been left quadriplegic.

Erika Sotelo has been in a persistent vegetative state since March 1995 as a result of medical negligence during surgery. Her husband, Carlos Abarca, continues to take care of her even though he has had a new partner for the past six years. He refuses to even consider disconnecting Erika’s feeding or breathing (tracheostomy) tubes.

Another case that has received recent coverage by the local media is that of María Acuña, 24, who was left paralysed from the neck down when she was shot in the head by her husband. “The only thing I want is to die,” says the quadriplegic.

According to the Chilean Medical Association, disconnecting Schiavo’s feeding tube amounted to “condemning her to die of hunger,” while Eliana Reyes, vice-president of the Association of Clinical Nutrition, said the case was “an example of barbarity in a wealthy country.”

But in an on-line letter, a reader of the Santiago newspaper El Mercurio who identified himself as Giacometti refuted that view. Schiavo, he said, did not die of hunger or thirst, but of starvation, because in her vegetative state she was unable to experience hunger, thirst, smells or sounds, or to dream or even think. “Her body simply stopped functioning,” he said.

According to the Medical Association, the brain damage that put Schiavo in a persistent vegetative state for 15 years was “a chronic, not terminal, condition.” But even in cases of imminent death, “it is not considered ethical to eliminate the basic life supports of food and liquid,” it added.

The president of the Medical Association, Dr. Juan Luis Castro, said that in cases like Schiavo’s, “there is a debate on quality of life, not on whether they are terminally ill, because these patients aren’t.”

The possibility of withdrawing or withholding “extraordinary means” of prolonging life (e.g., intravenous feeding, respirators, and artificial kidney machines) can be debated, but not the removal of water and food, he said.

“In Chile that would not be possible even with a kind of living will, because that is basic life support, and withholding it runs counter to the principle of defence of life and contravenes our national laws,” said Castro.

Zorrilla, a philosopher who specialises in bioethics on the Faculty of Medical Sciences at the public University of Santiago of Chile, told IPS that in the case of patients in a vegetative state, the words “persistent” and “permanent” are “worth their weight in gold.”

“Those who want to be ambiguous talk about ‘persistent’, which means it’s not ‘permanent’, because some day the person will wake up and be just like they were before. But that’s a lie: the medical literature shows that of 20,000 people who have been in this state, maybe two will wake up, and they do not return to normal at all.

“And if they are normal, it’s probably because the diagnosis was incorrect,” he added.

Zorrilla noted that studies have found that 80 percent of the relatives of people in a persistent vegetative state visit them regularly only in the first five months on average.

In the first seven years after Schiavo suffered severe brain damage, for example, it was mainly her husband, Michael, who cared for her, he added.

The bioethics expert spoke out against “therapeutic cruelty” that provides for endless and futile treatments for terminal patients, and said that in his view, “the big problem that doctors have with euthanasia is that they don’t want to assume the responsibility of killing someone.

“It makes no sense to prolong the suffering and the act of dying,” he argued, “because it not only hurts the person who is dying, but all of the patient’s loved ones as well. It makes no sense to prolong the agony when medicine can cure and heal other patients.

“Values issues are fundamentally political issues. A society that acknowledges euthanasia is completely different from a society that does not confront the problem of death and allows patients, and the elderly, to die with incredible suffering,” said Zorrilla.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags