Saturday, November 21, 2026
Tarjei Kidd Olsen
- A new seven-country initiative to salvage the United Nations anti-nuclear weapons efforts is gathering support, with a reluctant United States as the latest backer.
The proposals crafted by Norway with support from Britain, Australia and five other countries include a range of measures intended to safeguard disarmament and non- proliferation work.
The effort comes at a crucial time, four months after the collapse of a review conference on the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), and right before the UN world summit this week.
Norwegian foreign minister Jan Petersen submitted the proposals to the UN at the end of July. UN secretary-general Kofi Annan issued a statement supporting the initiative, adding that it should provide the basis “for a wide-ranging consensus.”
So far more than 80 countries have backed the initiative. On Sep. 3 the United States finally came into the fold, effectively opening the way for the text to be used as a basis for nuclear negotiations leading up to the UN summit.
This followed initial U.S. opposition to the plan, with reports that John Bolton, the new U.S. ambassador to the UN, was working actively to prevent the proposals becoming a basis for negotiations.
The United States is decidedly lukewarm towards disarmament efforts, focusing instead on non-proliferation.
Some commentators have held the United States responsible for the collapse of the NPT review conference in May. Delegates from countries who have signed up to the NPT met at the United Nations in New York from May 2 to 27 this year to review the treaty.
They accused the United States of backing out of a commitment to negotiate the elimination of nuclear weapons. The United States has also been criticised for refusing to ratify the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty, and for planning to develop bunker-buster miniature nuclear weapons.
“The United States agrees with a lot of aspects of the initiative, especially as regards non- proliferation,” Norwegian foreign minister Jan Petersen told IPS after a meeting with John Bolton. “However, we are also aware that they have some concerns relating to issues such as the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty, among others.”
It is the collapse of the NPT review conference that prompted Norway to create the new proposals together with Britain, Australia, South Africa, Indonesia, Chile and Romania.
“We particularly want to strengthen language relating to non-proliferation at the UN- summit, especially considering the new terrorist threat and dangers of nuclear weapons spreading even further,” Petersen told IPS.
Besides underlining the need to strengthen non-proliferation, the initiative urges safeguard measures to protect nuclear materials and to control access to them, the strengthening of disarmament measures (including entry into force of the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty), and “firm action to discourage any potential defection from the NPT”, according to the proposed text.
This last appeal can be seen as a reaction to the actions of North Korea, which left the treaty and promptly announced it had built a bomb. Currently there is no mechanism within the treaty for punishing such behaviour.
“Leaving the Treaty must not be considered a viable or consequence-free option,” the initiative proposes.
Another proposal reaffirms the “inalienable right of all (signatory countries to the NPT) to develop research, production and use of nuclear energy for peaceful purposes”, but pointedly adds that they also “may choose to fully enjoy the benefits of nuclear energy” without developing it themselves.
This will be seen as referring to Iran, which the United States and the European Union fear is trying to secretly develop nuclear weapons. They are trying to coax Iran into forsaking its nuclear energy programme.
Whether all of the proposals, especially relating to disarmament, make it into the outcome document of the UN summit is uncertain. Hard bargaining is expected, both from the United States and other countries such as France.
“As at the review conference of the NPT, there are disagreements over whether to focus on disarmament or non-proliferation,” a source at the Norwegian foreign ministry told IPS. “Some countries, particularly in developing countries, want the main focus to be on disarmament. Others think the priority should be non-proliferation. It’s not that the U.S. is saying no to disarmament, but more that it wants an emphasis on non-proliferation.”
All references to disarmament are nevertheless removed from John Bolton’s controversial 40-page text demanding more than 700 changes to the outcome document of the UN summit.
References to non-proliferation mentions were left alone or strengthened. A section affirming the right to the peaceful use of nuclear energy was removed altogether.
The United States, Russia, China, France and Britain have nuclear weapons, but are signatories to the NPT. This obliges them to work towards eliminating the weapons.
Israel, Pakistan and India are nuclear powers, but have not signed the NPT. There has been no independent verification of North Korea’s own claim that it has several nuclear bombs.