Monday, November 16, 2026
Raúl Pierri
- With its plans to build two paper mills on the banks of the river it shares with Argentina currently pending a decision at The Hague, the government of Uruguay has been forced to defend its position on the home front since the release of a locally-produced scientific study warning of the project’s harmful effects.
The report charges that the effluents from the two plants under construction on Uruguay’s side of the river – the largest industrial investment in the country’s history – will negatively affect fish reproduction and cause chronic damage to aquatic life in the Uruguay River. Furthermore, the factory operations would require an expansion of the non-native pine and eucalyptus plantations in the area, which could reduce river flow and cause permanent soil damage, the study concluded.
The document, “A summary of environmental effects of pulp mills and the forestry model in Uruguay”, was prepared by an expert commission of the Faculty of Science at Uruguay’s public University of the Republic.
“The two mills are expected to produce 1.5 million tonnes of pulp per year, requiring an annual supply of 4.5 million tonnes of wood. They will need 300,000 hectares of forest to make this work,” explained geographer Marcel Achkar at the study’s official presentation this week.
However, Uruguay’s potentially forestable and available land accounts for only 40 percent of the required 300,000 hectares; the rest of the demand would have to be met with land now used for agriculture and grazing, he said.
Following a drawn-out controversy that strained relations between Buenos Aires and Montevideo almost to the breaking point, Argentina’s Foreign Ministry filed a complaint with the International Court of Justice in The Hague against the construction of the two mills, owned by the Finnish Botnia company and Spain’s ENCE, as well as a port in the south-western Uruguayan city of Fray Bentos on the river’s east bank.
The scientists told IPS that put together the report to “weigh in on an issue that is clouded in confusion and yet is of the utmost importance to the country,” also taking into account that “the founding charter of the university establishes an obligation to engage in major national issues.”
The report was based on data from studies conducted in other countries published in specialised international journals, but also drew from some of the university’s own studies.
Alice Altesor, of the university’s ecology department, said the forestry model put forward in the pulp mill plans would have a negative impact on Uruguay’s air, water and land.
Eucalyptus and pine plantations contribute less carbon to the natural prairie ecosystem than pastureland; they also consume up to 50 percent more water, affecting river flow and streams, increase soil acidity and leech out other nutrients, she explained.
“The negative effects of replacing natural grassland with tree farms have been clearly documented,” said Altesor.
The report warns that “many of the chemical changes (acidification, salinisation, loss of nutrients), are irreversible, seriously compromising soil fertility and, therefore, productive potential.”
Additionally, “natural prairies are home to 80 percent of Uruguay’s plant biodiversity and the rich wildlife associated with it. Replacing diverse vegetation with a monoculture triggers a serious loss of ecosystem and genetic information,” as well as “the emergence of invasive exotic species,” says the text.
Néstor Mazzeo, a professor in the university’s environmental science master’s degree programme, described the concrete effects that the pulp mills’ effluents would have on the Uruguay River, using as a reference studies of organisms exposed to emissions from similar plants at 18 sites in Sweden, Canada and the United States.
In addition to vast quantities of water, the pulp-extraction process involves the use of several chemicals, such as chlorine or chlorine dioxide, caustic soda, oxygen or oxygen peroxide and sodium hypochloride, which generate highly toxic and persistent organochlorines (dioxins and furans) that can accumulate in the fatty tissue of animals.
“Effluents have an extremely heterogeneous composition, and its important to note that many compounds have not yet been identified. We know very little about the way in which many of the compounds react,” said Mazzeo.
“A clear illustration of the issue is the fact that, in general, 80 percent of the aquatic organisms studied suffered delays in sexual maturity,” despite an overall increase in size, he said.
This means that “there is enough food, but something in the environment is blocking part of the energy that these organisms require for reproductive functions,” Mazzeo explained, adding that several species could face oxygenation problems.
He emphasised that the dangerous compounds, which are minimally soluble and take decades to degrade into a less harmful substance, have been found in the effluents of several pulp mills – including those that use the Elemental Chlorine Free (ECF) system, which releases fewer organochlorines, and those that use the Totally Chlorine Free (TCF) system.
The ENCE and Botnia companies note in their respective environmental impact studies that they will employ a kraft cellulose production system (a chemical process that uses sulphates to break down wood) with an ECF bleaching system.
The university study recommends that the Uruguayan government, led by President Tabaré Vázquez, be vigilant in monitoring the plant impacts and outlines treatments to reduce effluent toxicity that should be added to the companies’ plans.
The left-leaning government played down the report’s conclusions, dismissing it as a “little more than an extended bibliography.”
The data included in the study “refer to experiences in other places. It is a bibliographical review of information that is not relevant to Uruguay. The conditions of the Uruguay River are different than those in the rivers studied, as are the species,” Alicia Torres, National Environment Director, told IPS.
The official also said that the study’s recommendations are “identical” to the measures adopted by the Ministry of Housing, Zoning and Environment for these projects, published on their web site.
Torres met with the scientists on Monday, and said she was surprised by the timing of the report’s release.
The court at The Hague is expected to rule this month on Argentina’s original request that work be halted on the Botnia and ENCE construction projects along the river it shares with Uruguay. á