Headlines

RIGHTS-UAE: Labour Reforms to Reach Domestic Workers

Meena Janardhan

DUBAI, Nov 11 2007 (IPS) - After years of criticism and pressure by local and international human rights organisations, the United Arab Emirates (UAE) has set up a taskforce to draft a law that will define and regulate the relationship between domestic workers and their sponsors.

The proposed law will reconsider the rights and duties of both parties and will be drafted by a team of representatives from the ministries of interior, labour and justice. It will be guided by local and international legislations and systems.

The existing labour law excludes from its purview the rights of domestic workers, numbering at least 600,000, leaving them vulnerable to exploitation and abuse.

‘‘The decision to draft a new law pertaining to domestic workers is another important step in a series of measures that have been taken recently to streamline the labour market climate in the country, and demonstrates the government’s commitment to improve the plight of unskilled workers,’’ Anwar Gargash, minister of state for federal national council affairs, said.

Domestic workers include housemaids, nannies, nurses, drivers, gardeners and others who work in private homes – and in the public sector as janitors and helpers.

The issue, specifically in the Gulf countries, has attracted attention because many domestic workers are hostage to labour agents and employers. There are also reports of a number of them becoming victims of physical, sexual and psychological abuse, confinement, and even human trafficking. In extreme cases, it is estimated that they may work an average of 100 hours weekly, with no overtime and few holidays.


‘‘The new initiative is significant because it will particularly benefit the women&#39s segment of the expatriate workforce,’’ Gargash, who is also chairman of the permanent committee for monitoring the UAE’s image abroad, told IPS.

The majority of domestic workers in the region are women, mostly from Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, Indonesia, and the Philippines.

While reported cases of exploitation and abuse of domestic workers have increased across the Gulf in recent years, most go unreported for lack of an established mechanism or for fear of losing jobs. Another trend is the increasing instances of maids running away, contributing to the problems of human trafficking and illegal residence. The number of runaway Indonesian maids in the UAE, for example, totalled about 300 in 2005.

There have also been cases of maids concocting abuse charges to wriggle out of exploitative situations or getting their dues settled. To discourage this, the UAE ministry of interior has prescribed non-payment of dues and punishment for absconders.

The new proposal will build on a November 2006 decision to introduce contracts to protect the rights of domestic workers with details pertaining to salary, accommodation, healthcare and working hours.

Some of the other recent reforms with a ‘human face’ in the UAE include: the May 2006 decision not to ban domestic workers who wish to change their jobs, if they get a no-objection certificate from the original sponsor; a government-monitored electronic wage payment scheme for workers, that will become effective in 2008; and mechanisms to improve the working and living conditions of unskilled workers.

‘‘Any attempt to address the rights of domestic workers and provide a context to it is better than maintaining status quo,’’ Dubai-based sociologist Rima Sabban said. ‘‘The continuous struggle to get domestic workers to be treated on par with other workers finally appears to be bearing fruit.’’

Sabban told IPS: ‘‘Since our society depends heavily on domestic workers, their interests need to be recognised. Though late, compared to the rest of the world, the government decision is noteworthy.’’

However, suggesting that effective implementation of the law is more important than the intention, the sociologist said, ‘‘In a traditional family system, like the one followed in the UAE and the Gulf, it is very difficult to regulate the relationship between the sponsor and the domestic worker. This issue has several interwoven layers which need to be well-regulated if the new law is to be effective.’’

The UAE Human Rights Organisation has been demanding that domestic workers be covered by the labour law because the contract regulating the relationship between domestic helpers and their employers falls short of minimum human rights and international labour standards – especially in not providing a specific number of daily working hours and a weekly day off.

The recommendations specified by the national organisation include minimum wages, minimum working hours, work-profile, timely transfer of wages to banks, proper accommodation, annual leave and hotline service to receive complaints against abuse.

Earlier this year, a report by the Washington-based Human Rights Watch (HRW) also suggested that the country’s draft labour law, which had been displayed on the website of the ministry of labour to elicit public response, falls far short of international standards.

The report urged the government to revise the law to encompass domestic workers, protect workers’ rights to organise themselves, bargain collectively and protest.

During the last three years, the government has been deeply concerned with construction workers staging demonstrations both at work sites and on main roads during peak hours.

Last month, about 4,000 construction workers, mostly Indians, vandalised police vehicles and public property after a demand for a pay hike of 30 to 50 percent and better living conditions turned violent. Some of them are still in custody and face the possibility of deportation.

One of the HRW objections to the draft labour law was that it discriminates against women workers and treats them as dependents rather than as competent adults with full and independent legal capacity.

Some labour-exporting countries have also taken proactive measures to improve the plight of the domestic workers in the Gulf countries.

During 2007, the governments of the Philippines, Indonesia and Sri Lanka laid out new conditions for recruitment of maids, including a doubling of salaries. The minimum salary of a Filipina maid, for example, was set at 1,500 dirhams (400 US dollars) with effect from Mar. 1. Even though there are question marks about its effectiveness, Nepal and India are also set to follow suit.

Sabban has raised some questions and recommendations for the government to consider while drafting the law:

– who will implement the regulation, especially inside homes. – how will a dispute be handled. – will the new law be under the purview of the labour ministry. – establishing panels comprising experts who have studied this issue and seeking their assistance to settle disputes. – conducting training programmes for both sponsors and workers so as to make them aware of each other’s concerns.

LABOUR-UAE: Worker Friendly Laws Make a Difference (https://www.ipsnews.net/news.asp?idnews=36133) Building Towers Cheating Workers – HRW report (http://hrw.org/reports/2006/uae1106/uae1106web.pdf) INT&#39L LABOUR DAY: Trade Unions to Transform UAE Labour Climate (https://www.ipsnews.net/news.asp?idnews=33077)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags