Sunday, November 22, 2026
Bob Burton
- Non-profit groups in Australia have dismissed suggestions by a conservative think tank that a major shake-up is required of how the Australian government deals with non-government organisations (NGOs).
A 39,000 U.S. dollar consultancy report presented to the government last week proposes that NGOs – including human rights, environmental, Aboriginal and aid groups – should be subjected to much greater scrutiny, says Gary Johns, senior research fellow with the conservative Institute of Public Affairs (IPA).
”When they are using or have some privileged access to a public resources, then it is then incumbent on the Commonwealth government to state ‘Well what are the resources? What is the relationship? Did you ask who these people were before you dealt with them?’,” Johns said.
The report – due to be publicly released in the next few weeks – is the culmination of a campaign by Johns and other IPA staff, who are vocal critics of human rights, environmental and development organisations.
The chair of the National Roundtable of Nonprofit Organisations, Robert Fitzgerald, argues that the IPA is determined to reduce the role of non-profit advocacy groups in society. ”This has been a three-year campaign which had its genesis in America where there is a strong anti-NGO sentiment because they believe NGO activity has undermined the Bush administration’s foreign policy,” he said.
”That is an ideological position. What the IPA has done is take the U.S. views and apply it in Australia, not only about domestic activities but about international activities as well,” he said.
Johns, who was a member of Parliament between 1987 and 1996 and now heads the IPA’s Non-Government Organisation Project, insists that NGOs that gain tax benefits or funding from government need to be subjected to more scrutiny. ”It is the relationship with government that generates the government’s need to disclose information to the public,” he said.
However, Johns does not see the disclosure requirement applying to the IPA, his organisation, arguing that the consultancy is the first time it has accepted direct government funding. ”It doesn’t necessarily put us in that category at all as being an NGO with a significant relationship with the Commonwealth,” he said.
Three weeks ago in the Senate, the minister for family and community services, Sen Kay Patterson, defended the IPA’s lack of transparency in the organisation’s sponsors. ”In line with privacy laws, it does not disclose the people who donate to the Institute,” she said.
Sen Andrew Murray, who is spokesman on taxation, finance and corporate affairs for the centre-left political party, the Australian Democrats, believes that the IPA’s failure to disclose who funds them casts doubt over the value of the report. ”Anyone taking a tender such as this must disclose any matters that might constitute a conflict of interest à you have to live by the principles that you espouse,” he said.
Funders of the IPA are known to include major mining, oil, tobacco and energy companies including Western Mining Corp, Esso Australia (a subsidiary of ExxonMobil), BHP, Shell, Philip Morris and British American Tobacco.
In the September 2000 edition of its newsletter, the IPA announced that it had established a ”regular ‘Corporate Affairs Forum’ to discuss ‘coal face’ issues of concern to corporate affairs executives à One of the spin-offs of the Forum is to provide ideas, information and direction for the IPA’s newly established NGO Project.”
The IPA newsletter stated that speakers included a public relations consultant who ”reviewed the generic problems the business community faces in dealing with ‘community- based’ organisations”.
The corporate affairs manager with Aventis CropScience Australia, Naomi Stevens, ”gave an account of the recent focus protests around the introduction of field trials of GM canola by Aventis,” the newsletter stated.
But Johns insists that the Corporate Affairs Forum, at which he gave a presentation, had little influence in shaping the IPA’s proposals on non-government organisations. ”It was the first paper that I wrote on NGOs so we said ‘Ok here’s what our thinking is, where it goes we are not quite sure’,” he said.
In April 2001, the IPA launched a special newsletter, ‘NGO Watch’, to target human rights, development and environmental organisations. However, faced with diminishing corporate support, the October 2002 edition was the last. ”It just wasn’t financially sustaining, there weren’t enough buying the product,” Johns said.
While financial support for the NGO Watch reports was meagre, the IPA found the conservative government of Prime Minister John Howard more forthcoming.
In late 2002, the IPA proposed a consultancy to advance its proposals that a protocol be developed between government and NGOs as well as a ”framework for assessing the role and standing of NGOs” in relation to eight government departments and ministers.
The Department of Family and Community Services claims that the IPA contract was given on the grounds that the expertise was not available within the department and that the projected required ”independent or impartial research/assessment by an independent organisation”.
The national director of Philanthropy Australia, Elizabeth Cham, argues that there is little to be gained by shooting the messenger in discussing issues such as social equity or human rights. ”Global companies just can’t go about doing whatever they want to do à global capital is just not behaving in a way that society expects, so there is an important role for non-profit groups in voicing the concerns of society,” she said.