Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Human Rights, Labour, Population

MALAYSIA: Outrage over Indonesian’s Abuse Sparks Calls for Change

Anil Netto

PENANG, Malaysia, May 28 2004 (IPS) - The widespread outrage over the torture and disfigurement of an Indonesian domestic worker has prompted new calls for reforms to protect migrant workers in Malaysia, but sceptics say the real test will be if changes happen after the media frenzy over the case subsides.

Since the horrific ordeal of 19-year-old Nirmala Bonat came to light earlier this month, the plight of abused domestic workers has hogged the headlines in Malaysia and Indonesia.

Web logs and discussion sites have been talking about the issue. Angry Malaysians have been conveying their disgust in letters to newspapers after pictures were published of a scarred Bonat, her hands bandaged and her face and parts of her body dotted with scars and burns.

These were the result of what she says is five months of abuse by her employer, the wife of a company director now in custody. Bonat, from East Nusa Tenggara in Indonesia, says her employer used a hot iron to scald her, and threw boiling water on her.

Human Resources Minister Fong Chan Onn has said that employers and employment agents would be held accountable for the welfare of foreign domestic workers in Malaysia, who are mainly from Indonesia and the Philippines.

But activists worry that without meaningful reforms and new policies, all this tough talk will remain just that.

The Bonat case underscores how comprehensive legal reforms to protect migrant workers and their rights are sorely needed in a country that is home to some two million migrant workers, but often gives them less rights.

Malaysian society, they add, also needs to change its attitudes and prejudices toward migrant workers often seed as the cause of crime and social ills. ”Laws and policies are enforced with great speed and efficiency when migrant workers violate laws but the situation is different when employers do the same,” said Joachim Xavier, migrant workers’ desk officer with the Penang Office for Human Development.

Activists want action to be taken against unscrupulous employers, recruitment agents and enforcement personnel.

Some employers here fail to adhere to employment contracts that their workers signed with recruitment agents in their home countries. Many workers find out too late that their wages fall short of what they agreed on earlier in their home countries. Unscrupulous employers who underpay their migrant workers are rarely penalised. Worse, workers often have no one to turn for help.

Indonesian domestic workers, for instance, are often barred from socialising with outsiders. Their employers or agents hold on to their passports, and many are not allowed to use the telephone. Often, they are denied a day off and are forbidden from leaving their employers’ homes on their own.

For instance, a Penang-based employment agent’s guidelines, a copy of which was seen by IPS, insist that all incoming and outgoing mail from domestic helpers have to be vetted by employers.

Given these conditions, it is easy for employers to subject migrant workers to sustained abuse and exploitation over a prolonged period.

”Domestic helpers are at a bigger disadvantage as they are not even considered ‘workers’ and as such do not fall under the provisions of the Employment Act,” pointed out Xavier.

Migrant workers in other sectors fare no better. ”We have faced many difficulties with our employer,” said La Khine, a Burmese migrant worker who arrived two years ago to work in an iron foundry. ”We don’t know who to approach to complain about our difficulties.”

Speaking through a translator, La Khine claimed his employer calculated the migrant workers’ overtime pay incorrectly and underpaid them. When he and his colleague, acting on behalf of fellow workers, brought this to their employer’s attention on May 12, the manager abruptly suspended the duo.

A week later, four men claiming to be police personnel turned up unexpectedly to escort them to the airport for deportation. It was only through the last-minute intervention of sympathetic employment agents that they were saved from deportation.

Activists have complained that employers sometimes resort to deporting workers who complain about working conditions – in some cases seeking the assistance of police, who for their part say they are there to ”calm” the situation.

It is easy for unscrupulous employers to cancel their employees’ work permits and obtain an immigration ”check-out memo” to deport the workers swiftly. ”The check-out memo cancels out all the workers’ rights and grievances,” said Chia Yong Tai, a migrant workers’ employment agent sympathetic to their plight.

At it stands, ”the check-out memo allows employers to kick out workers for even trivial reasons,” he added. In some cases, he points out, employers have been known to repatriate whole groups of workers without paying them their full wages.

”The immigration department should countercheck the reason for the deportation,” says Chia. ”They have to interview the workers and agents to find out for themselves.”

Once work permits are withdrawn, the workers lose their right to remain in Malaysia. The only way they can stay back to seek redress is to obtain a ‘special pass’ from the immigration department, but the terms of the pass do not allow them to work in the meantime.

Another Burmese worker, Aung Zaw Ling, working for a construction firm here, complained of deplorable living conditions. ”We were housed in containers containing 12 workers each,” he said. ”We have no proper toilet facilities – and 30 workers are supposed to share the ‘toilet’ we have.”

He said their employers withheld wage deductions meant to settle outstanding loans in Burma or to be paid to their family members. The total amount withheld for 25 workers amounted to 70,000 ringgit (18,400 dollars).

The situation of migrant workers has sparked calls for the Malaysian government to ratify the International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of their Families, which came into force in July.

”The Nirmala Bonat case should not be looked at in isolation but should be viewed in the broader context of what can be done to protect migrant workers,” Toh Kin Woon, a senior Penang state government leader who heads the economic planning and human resources portfolios, told IPS.

Said Toh: ”The Convention imposes certain obligations on governments in terms of their responsibility to protect the rights of migrant workers.” (END/IPS/AP/LB/PR/HD/AN/JS/04)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags