Saturday, November 21, 2026
Tran Dinh Thanh Lam
- The mushrooming of industrial zones in Vietnam, as the country rushes to join the market economy, is taking a heavy toll on farmers who have been forced off their land to make way for new factories.
Many are now jobless and find it very difficult to get employed in industries demanding highly-skilled labour.
Le Van Kich, a ninety-four year-old farmer at An Tinh village in Chu Chi Commune had to unwillingly move twice from his land to make way for the Trang Bang Industrial Zone.
The first time he was offered a mere 15 million dong (951 U.S. dollars) by the industrial zone to move from his half-hectare plot of land, valued at 150 million dong (9,510 U.S. dollars), to make way for the project’s initial phase.
There was little Kich could do as under the 1993 Land Law, land rights could be transferred to other parties in the name of economic reforms or ‘doi moi’, which literally means ‘change for the new.’
As Vietnam embraces open markets and goes down the path of rapid industrialisation, any attempts by Kich to oppose his ‘relocation’ would have been deemed as unpatriotic to the government.
Faced with little choice, he then sought permission from local authorities to buy a small plot of land far from the industrial zone to build his new home for himself and his 85 year-old wife.
But the cruel hand of fate soon struck again.
Trang Bang Industrial Zone had expanded and soon it was at the fringes of Kich’s new home.
”I had just built the house and local authorities together with the industrial zone developers came and asked me to move again,” lamented Kich.
This time, he received even less compensation – just half the sum he had invested into building his new home.
Like Kich, more than 500 families in An Tinh village have lost their arable land and become jobless since the Trang Bang Industrial Zone was first built in 1999.
To date, the industrial zone has bought 232 hectares of land from An Tinh villagers at 50,000 dong (3.16 U.S. dollars) for one square metre of dwelling land – well below the market rate.
”This is ridiculous. These prices are only one tenth of those offered on the free market,” said 46 year-old Nguyen Van Chien.
” With the compensation money, I could hardly buy a small land for a house, six kilometers away from the village,” he said.
At least 80 percent of the An Tinh population could not relocate with the money received from the industrial zone developers.
In a 1998 amendment of the 1993 Land Law, every year around 100,000 hectares of agriculture land – most of them rice fields – can be converted, by the authorities, into non-agricultural usage.
James Riedel, a professor of international economics at the U.S.-based Johns Hopkins University, argues in a recent report that agricultural employment had reached its capacity in Vietnam.
Riedel said the only way to raise the country’s productivity is to transfer a large portion of the agricultural labour force to the industrial sector.
He added: “Even with substantial investment in agriculture, the sector will not be able to provide productive employment for the millions of people who live in the countryside.”
But Bui Ngoc Thanh, a National Assembly delegate from Thanh Hoa province disagrees with Riedel.
”In the past, no farmers were totally jobless. But now, more and more farmers experience absolute unemployment, and the number increases proportionally with the disappearance of agricultural land,” Thanh told IPS.
The on-going National Assembly annual session is debating the impact of the disappearance of agricultural land to industries and has asked the government to come up with polices to address the issue of displaced farmers.
”Farmers loosing their land and becoming jobless are critical issues that we should consider seriously,” said Nguyen Thi Hong Xinh, the assembly delegate from Ba Ria-Vung Tau province.
International bodies like the World Bank have been promoting an export-oriented industrialisation strategy for Vietnam and the liberalisation of its economy in order for the country to take advantage of global markets.
Heeding the World Bank’s advice, Vietnam in 2000 announced a multiyear reform programme that is expected to facilitate entry of private enterprise into export trade and production and help reduce export costs.
But this industrialisation strategy has taken its toll on farmers, like the ones in An Tinh village.
”After depriving us of our land, the Trang Bang Industrial Zone developers continue to deny us the right to work,” said an angry Pham Van Nhoc.
The government has stipulated that farmers who renounce their land rights to industrial zone developers, like the one in Trang Bang, will receive 3.6 million dong (228 U.S. dollars) each as an allowance to seek a new job.
The industrial zones are also required to set up training and vocational programmes in order to make the out-of-job farmers employable by the factories.
However, in most of cases nothing has been done, leaving many relocated families jobless and having no means to make a living.
”It’s hard for an old farmer to shift to new work. Finally, the 3.6 million dong has been spent and the old farmer finds himself becoming a new proletariat,” said Nhoc sarcastically.
But the government admitted that existing policies for farmers’ training are unrealistic.
“The National Assembly requires the government to provide job training for one million people annually. However, the budget is only enough for 160,000 people a year,” Minister of Labour, Invalids and Social Affairs, Nguyen Thi Hang told IPS.
”Therefore the 100 percent training of relocated peasants is impossible,” added the minister.
Ho Chi Minh City Deputy Mayor Mai Quoc Binh, however, was more forthcoming.
”The reality is that investors usually demand workers to be high-school graduates, know a foreign language or be able to handle a computer – the skills young peasants hardly have,” he said.