Development & Aid, Headlines, Poverty & SDGs

TRADE-EU: Rich Urged to Drop Anti-Development Policies

Stefania Bianchi

BRUSSELS, Jul 26 2004 (IPS) - Development groups are urging EU foreign ministers meeting to revive the Doha Development Round to abandon “anti-development policies” that caused the collapse of the WTO meeting in Cancun last September.

With less than a week to go before the World Trade Organisation (WTO) meets in Geneva to negotiate reform proposals, 17 development and environmental groups including Oxfam and Friends of the Earth are accusing rich countries of neglecting developing country needs and “imperiling” the Doha Development Round (DDR).

The non-governmental organisations (NGOs) say a proposed deal released Friday (Jul. 16) to rescue global trade talks risks “threatening to undermine world trade talks and perpetuate inequality and poverty.”

European Union (EU) foreign affairs and trade ministers will discuss the proposal with EU trade commissioner Pascal Lamy and EU commissioner for agriculture Franz Fischler in Brussels Monday (Jul. 26) before a four-day general council session begins Tuesday (Jul. 27) with the aim of producing a framework for the talks.

The draft document will serve as a framework for the final stretch of the talks scheduled to begin late July. The talks have been called to keep negotiations on track for the Dec. 31 deadline for a new international trade agreement.

The draft guidelines envisage the elimination of agricultural export subsidies and big cuts in domestic farm supports and border protection. Other issues covered include industrial tariffs, services, cotton subsidies and the launch of negotiations on customs procedures.


Last week the European Commission, the EU executive, cautiously welcomed the proposed deal as a “step in the right direction”, saying it would serve “as a basis for further work.”

The document is being debated in Geneva this week.

According to an Oxfam report ‘One Minute to Midnight’ released Thursday (Jul. 22), the WTO’s draft negotiating text “shows evidence of considerable rich-country influence and does not adequately address key areas of interest for developing countries, like export dumping and market access.”

It says that because of this imbalance, the talks this week may fail, and that this would have “dire consequences” for the future of multilateralism and global poverty reduction.

“Time is running out. Despite pledges of reform, rich countries have pursued a strategy based on self-interest and consistently blamed everyone else for potential deadlock. In fact, they are the ones who have been blocking progress, they have the power to unlock the round and they would enjoy the majority of benefits from its successful completion,” Jo Leadbeater, head of Oxfam International’s Brussels office said in a statement.

The NGOs are now calling for a series of measures in the proposal to be modified at the WTO’s general council meeting later this week.

On agriculture, the groups say there is still no indication of the time frame for the elimination of export subsidies, and are urging the EU to agree to eliminate the subsidies “with a clear end date without making it conditional on obtaining new concessions from developing countries.”

The groups add that the EU should give developing countries the right to protect their farmers from imports that threaten food security and to review and eliminate domestic support.

On non-agricultural goods, the civil society groups say the EU’s move to open developing country markets could lead to “de-industrialisation and the erosion of trade policy as instrument to preserve the environment and protecting the poor.”

For the controversial Singapore issues, which include investment, competition, transparency in government procurement and trade facilitation, the NGOs welcome the EU’s position to drop investment, competition and government procurement from the Doha Round “as a step in the right direction”, but urge that all Singapore issues should be dropped from the WTO altogether.

Oxfam says such changes are “key” to the success of the trade negotiations.

“Developing countries are being put in the untenable position of having to choose either to agree to a watered down framework or to accept the blame for the collapse of the talks,” said Leadbeater.

“Instead, the text should be redrafted in order to better reflect the promises made at the beginning of the round in Doha in 2001. Without major improvements, the proposals will fail to unlock negotiations, let alone deliver reforms that help poor countries,” she added.

 
Republish | | Print |