Sunday, November 22, 2026
Dionne Jackson Miller
- Jamaica’s Parliament has now passed legislation to enable the country to join the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ), but the issue remains in legal limbo and embroiled in controversy.
The government’s decision to replace the right of appeal to the London-based Judicial Committee of the Privy Council with the right of appeal to the CCJ, scheduled to be inaugurated in November, has met with strong and continuing opposition. The debate has focused on the court’s appellate jurisdiction, although it will also have original jurisdiction over regional trade disputes.
Local opposition culminated in the opposition Jamaica Labour Party joining forces with local rights groups, including Jamaicans for Justice and the Independent Jamaican Council for Human Rights, in an unprecedented court challenge designed to stop Parliament from debating the CCJ legislation before it had been passed.
The local courts ruled in the government’s favour but granted leave to appeal to the Privy Council, Jamaica’s court of last resort. But the groups decided not to proceed with the case, and to let the parliamentary debate continue.
The government meanwhile agreed that while it would pass the legislation, it will not join the court until the Privy Council rules on the new law’s constitutionality, a decision expected to be handed down in the next few months.
Carolyn Gomes, executive director of Jamaicans for Justice, is deeply disturbed at the turn of events.
"We’re upset that we should be trying to establish a court that is as fragile as a single vote in the House of Representatives and a single vote in the Senate – that’s why we’re pressing ahead with the legal issues," Gomes says.
By "fragile" she is referring to the fact that the laws for the new court’s establishment have been passed by a simple majority in Parliament, and that although the government has promised that the legislation creating the court will be entrenched in the constitution at a future date, this will not be the case at the outset.
Opponents of Jamaica joining the CCJ argue that abolishing the right of appeal to the Privy Council and participation in the new court should be by way of a national referendum rather than a simple majority in Parliament. Laws establishing the country’s Supreme Court and Appeal Court are both entrenched in the constitution, so there would be an anomaly if the CCJ existed on a less secure constitutional basis, they add.
"Entrenched" clauses in the constitution require two-thirds majorities in Parliament before they can be changed – which must be done with the support of the opposition – while "deeply entrenched" clauses require two-thirds majorities plus a referendum.
But government officials respond that the CCJ would have the same status that the Privy Council now enjoys, and they insist the government has fulfilled its legal obligations towards the new court.
A staunch advocate of the CCJ says it is important to wait for the Privy Council’s ruling on the constitutionality of the law.
"It is a dilemma in the sense that having passed the legislation, the government still has to await the ruling of the Privy Council," says Keith Sobion, the principal of the Norman Manley Law School at the University of the West Indies.
"But there is a challenge to the court and I think it is important that we hear what the Privy Council says about this case," he told IPS.
"I think that once the Privy Council ruling comes out, and I expect it to be in favour of the Government of Jamaica’s position, I think that things will start to happen very quickly," adds Sobion, a former attorney general of Trinidad and Tobago.
Prime Minister PJ Patterson is also confident of the government’s legal position and maintains that no member of the Commonwealth – a group of former British colonies – that has abolished the right of appeal to the Privy Council has gone the route of a referendum.
"I have undertaken legal, historical and political research … and there is not a single one that has done so by the way of a referendum, not one," said Patterson.
The prime minister maintains that judicial matters are best dealt with absent the type of political fistfights that would accompany a referendum.
In addition, tying a country’s legal affairs to those of another nation holds implicit dangers, Patterson says, noting that eastern Caribbean countries that legally depended on Britain’s lord chancellor to appoint their chief justice found themselves having to make constitutional changes when Britain recently abolished the post of lord chancellor.
"There may be some who are prepared to leave their fate to some legislature other than their own, 42 years after (independence) … this prime minister and this administration are insistent that we must have the final right of decision in our own affairs," says Patterson.
The CCJ will come into being as soon as three countries sign on, and the initial participants are expected to be Guyana, which withdrew from the Privy Council years ago, Barbados and Jamaica – if the Privy Council rules in the government’s favour. There have been other concerns in the region, however.
Speaking at the opening ceremony at the Caribbean Community (CARICOM) heads of government meeting in Grenada on Jul. 4, newly installed Prime Minister of Antigua and Barbuda Baldwin Spencer raised his own doubts about the CCJ.
"Three landmark Privy Council decisions, all arising from constitutional motions, leave lingering doubts in large numbers of the Antigua and Barbuda population about the wisdom of abandoning what many see as ‘the protection of the Privy Council’. Each of those three Privy Council judgments found that unanimous decisions of our Court of Appeal were fatally flawed," said Spencer.
The leader of Jamaica’s opposition, Edward Seaga, has been one of the strongest opponents of the new court.
"The CCJ has no legacy of performance since it is proposed to start from the beginning. It therefore would have no record of performance on which to judge its capability as the most important court in the judicial system of Jamaica; it would be untried and unproven," Seaga told Parliament.
The cost to operate the CCJ and its judicial expertise are also issues, he argues.
"The proposed CCJ cannot hope to assemble the collective judicial experience of the panel which now comprises the Privy Council, notwithstanding that recruitment could provide qualified judges for the CCJ over time," he says.
But Patterson’s administration and other supporters take issue with arguments about the quality of justice the CCJ will dispense.
"That is one of the arguments that irks me most, because howsoever couched or skilfully disguised, because it is nothing less than an admission that we don’t have the intellect … the probity … the expertise to be able to dispense justice for ourselves to ourselves," Patterson told Parliament.
Such comments have prompted Jamaicans for Justice to complain that the Caribbean Court of Justice is being imposed on citizens "wrapped up in the flag of sovereignty and national pride."
But Gomes acknowledges that apart from the intense lobbies mounted by civil society, the campaign has not gained the wider, public interest the group had hoped for.
"I’m disappointed in the public unconcern about this, because it’s fundamental," she says.