Development & Aid, Europe, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

DEVELOPMENT-EU: NGOs Favour Wider Role For New Aid Chief

Stefania Bianchi

BRUSSELS, Aug 30 2004 (IPS) - Leading development groups are pleading for enlarging the responsibilities of Louis Michel, commissioner designate in-charge of development and humanitarian aid in the new European Commission.

Michel should be given responsibility for European Union’s relations with all the developing countries and not only with the African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) countries, says Eurostep, a network of development non-governmental organisations (NGOs).

Otherwise the development policy of the 25-nation EU (European Union) will continue to focus on the ACP countries, says the Brussels-based group.

Under the current EU executive, development commissioner Poul Nielson is only responsible for relations with the 77 ACP countries. Other developing countries fall under the responsibility of Chris Patten, the bloc’s commissioner for external relations.

In his new role Michel (a former government minister in Belgium) will be responsible for development cooperation and humanitarian aid. He will oversee the directorate-general (DG) for development and the Commission’s humanitarian aid office, ECHO.

The debate over the roles of the commissioners for development and external relations has been growing in recent years, with development NGOs saying it was difficult to see how Nielson (a former Danish government minister) could effectively implement his development agenda outside the ACP regions.


Eurostep is concerned that the situation will not improve under José Manuel Barroso, president of the European Commission, which will come into effect on November 1, after undergoing the hearings at the European Parliament.

”An initial look at Barroso’s proposed appointments and responsibilities for the next Commission give the impression that not so much has changed from the current Commission and its institutional structure,” says Simon Stocker, director of Eurostep.

Stocker says that Nielson’s international influence was limited as ”his stated responsibilities were not matched by the departmental responsibilities”.

As DG Development was only responsible for relations with the ACP countries – other developing countries being located in the directorate for external relations under Chris Patten – it was difficult to see how Nielson could effectively implement his development role outside the ACP regions, says Stocker in a position paper.

In fact the EU had only a limited influence in other non-ACP developing countries.

”Increasingly the EU’s development policies are equated with the EU’s relations with the ACP, with the EU’s relations with other developing countries being primarily defined by policies other than development,” Stocker says.

He is of the view that this ambiguity not only remains for Michel, but may well be ”compounded” by the reforms that have taken place during the last five years.

The formal establishment of the bloc’s EuropeAid cooperation office in 2001 has resulted in the transfer of a number of functions that originally came under the realm of DG Development to the new office.

EuropeAid, which implements the external aid instruments of the European Commission, the EU executive body, is currently supervised by a board of commissioners with Patten as chairman and Nielson as chief executive.

While Patten oversees the appropriate implementation of the policy guidelines, Nielson supervises the strategic management of the board.

Günther Verheugen, the enlargement commissioner, Pascal Lamy, trade commissioner, and Pedro Solbes Mira, commissioner for economic and monetary affairs also sit on the board.

However, Eurostep says that although the commissioner for development officially ”oversees” the activities of EuropeAid, it is known within certain civil society circles that his influence over the office’s activities is limited.

Eurostep says that Nielson even acknowledged at the CONCORD NGO’s general assembly in February that his position on the board was a ”bad joke”.

Now, says Stocker says, the ”joke” will continue under Barroso’s EU executive with the responsibility of EuropeAid being transferred to Benita Ferrero-Waldner from Austria, who will assume the role of commissioner for external relations and European neighbourhood policy in November.

Ferrero-Waldner will not only be responsible for external relations, the Common Foreign and Security Policy (CFSP), and delegations in non-member countries; but DG external relations and the EuropeAid cooperation office will also have to report to her.

Stocker says that there are ”strong arguments” that primary responsibility for EuropeAid should lie with the commissioner for development, ”not least because most of the resources managed by EuropeAid are intended for development purposes whether this is within the ACP or in other developing countries”, he says.

Despite, such potential restrictions, Michel has already set himself a series of ambitious goals for his term in office.

Soon after his nomination on August 12, Michel said that one of his first tasks as the new development commissioner would be to persuade member states to contribute 0.7 percent of their gross national income (GNI) as official development assistance (ODA).

He said he will also focus on developing coherent cooperation projects with the greatest of efficiency and will pay particular attention to the environmental aspects of such projects

Michel said that improving relations with the ”large international actors for cooperation” will be central to his role.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags