Sunday, November 22, 2026
Sonny Inbaraj
- The enlarged European Union instead of being a formidable ally to conservationists involved in saving the African elephant, has ironically become a stumbling block to the survival of the endangered species.
On Thursday the EU abstained in a crucial vote at the closing session of the Conference of Parties at the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES), here, paving the way for Namibia to succeed in re-opening the ivory trade.
The withdrawal of the 25 EU votes gave Namibia the numbers they needed to approve trade in worked ivory for ‘non-commercial’ purposes.
”Ivory trade is always a difficult issue at CITES. The African states were not united and it was a negative factor in our deliberations,” said Julio Garcia Burgues, unit head of the European Commission’s Environment Directorate.
”For the European Union, it is very important that all African range states (for the elephant), define a common line,” Burgues told reporters at the closing of the 12-day CITES conference attended by over 1,500 delegates from 166 member nations.
”The EU abstained on this proposal but we are confident that the ivory trade will be effectively controlled. There will be no negative impact on the conservation of the African elephant in Namibia or other African states,” he emphasised.
But the U.S.-based International Fund for Animal Welfare (IFAW) expressed its disappointment over the EU’s abstention, which many say was due to it being unable to reach a consensus – the basis of the European Union’s decision-making process.
”The European Union has turned out to be a problem at CITES because it has now 25 members and there has to be a consensus for everything. The EU goes as a bloc and if they abstain, any (CITES) proposal could get adopted or rejected because of the lack of opposition or support from 25 member countries,” Peter Pueschel, IFAW’s program manager, told IPS.
”If they can’t make up their minds and have to abstain, that could upset things,” he added.
Pueschel also accused the EU of taking the easy way out by blaming African nations.
”Nobody can expect that countries in the largest continent are going to find a consensus and then make an easy offer to the rest of the world to adopt this,” he said. ”There are very different views in terms of conservation inside Africa and that needs to be respected.”
On Monday a bid by Kenya for a 20-year moratorium on the commercial ivory trade was defeated, despite reducing the proposal to six years.
CITES is a U.N. backed treaty that has been in effect for nearly 30 years and the conference of parties deliberated on 50 proposals about various species of plants and animals, relating to elephants, snakes, orchids, turtles, dolphins and other threatened and endangered species.
This May, 10 countries (Cyprus, Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Malta, Poland, Slovakia and Slovenia) joined the 15-nation European Union.
With its high standard of living and a total population of more than 370 million people, the current EU represents one of the largest and most diverse markets for wildlife and wildlife products in the world.
Between 1996 and 2002, the 15 EU member states imported, for example, six million live birds, 1.5 million live reptiles, around 10 million reptile skins, 21 million orchids and 572 tonnes of sturgeon caviar. All such imports are subject to the EU Wildlife Trade Regulations, that implement the provisions of CITES in the region.
Because of the large size of the European market, wildlife smugglers will identify routes where the risk of detection is minimal and specifically target countries with weak border controls. This is of particular significance with regard to controlling wildlife trade in the EU, where systematic controls take only place at the EU external borders.
For illegal ivory, this poses a particularly difficult problem.
”All it needs is just one weak border in one of these 25 member countries. Once ivory is smuggled into the EU it can end up in Britain, Germany or anywhere else because you don’t have controls inside anymore,” said Pueschel.
In March this year, IFAW released a report indicating that large amounts of ivory are being sold illegally in Britain.
Investigators found that Portobello Road, west London, the world’s biggest antiques market and a top tourist attraction, was awash with dubious ivory products. None of the items offered for sale was accompanied by proper papers.
”The European Union or any other country outside of Africa that also has ivory markets needs to be responsible to crack down on the illegal trade because they are part of the whole problem,” said Pueschel.
”The EU needs to decide where it stands on the ivory trade because Africa is calling out for support,” he added.
The European Union has been approached by West and Central African nations for help in their efforts to conserve elephants.
After years of debate, CITES banned the ivory trade in 1989. At first the ban worked well and the massacres of the 1980s, which halved Africa’s elephant population became less frequent, keeping the population stable at around 500,000.
But a spate of large African ivory shipments intercepted in Asia recently prompted warnings that demand was rising.
”With this signal coming from this conference that the ivory trade is re-opened and that some ivory can be sold legally sends a message to poachers and traders that there is an illegal ivory market that can be also utilised,” said Pueschel.
”After today, the European Union must accept responsibility that they are currently driving and encouraging poachers to go into these national parks in many of the African countries to poach elephants.”
But Rebecca Parzer, acting EU president, defended the grouping’s performance at CITES.
”This is the first CITES conference where the EU has 25 member states and this has affected the way the meeting has been going,” she told IPS.
”We have tried to be as constructive as possible, and we’re trying to build bridges within the regions to help facilitate matters. It’s always in our best motives to use the number of votes we have to support the aims of this (U.N.) convention,” added Parzer.