Sunday, November 22, 2026
Ann De Ron
- A joint assembly of members of the European Parliament and representatives from some of the poorest countries has been invited to consider six "myths" about new trade agreements.
African and European civil society groups are urging the Joint Parliamentary Assembly of the European Union (EU) and the African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) group at The Hague this week to take another look at the new Economic Partnership Agreements (EPAs) between the two.
The EPAs are agreements being negotiated between the EU and regional groups within the 77 ACP member countries. Negotiations are due to be concluded by December 2007, and the EPAs implemented between 2008 and 2020.
These would replace the existing agreement that gives ACP products non-reciprocal, preferential and in most cases free access to the EU market, while also providing financial assistance to ACP countries through traditional aid and policies intended to stabilise export earnings.
Seventy-seven ACP representatives are conferring with just as many EU parliamentarians this week to promote interdependence of North and South. They will pass resolutions on the situation in Darfur, on the damage caused by cyclones in the Caribbean, the political dialogue between ACP and EU, and food aid and food security in ACP countries.
The Joint Parliamentary Assembly is also expected to pass a resolution whether money for development cooperation in the ACP countries should be made a part of the EU budget. So far individual member states have been providing the funds. The European Commission, the executive arm of the EU, has only a coordinating role. While the assembly pursues its agenda, Oxfam International, Action Aid International and civil society groups from Ghana, Guinea, Kenya, Mali, Senegal, Zambia, Zimbabwe and other African countries want the assembly to consider their "six reasons to oppose the Economic Partnership Agreements (EPAs) in their current form."
The World Trade Organisation (WTO) had considered the existing agreements between the EU and the ACP discriminatory against non-ACP developing countries and thus not compatible with WTO rules. The EU argues that the only solution is to have EPAs in the model of a reciprocal free trade agreement which requires elimination of barriers to trade on "substantially all trade" between the parties within a "reasonable time".
But the civil society groups challenge this method of attaining WTO compatability. Their joint paper mentions several alternatives by changing WTO or EU rules.
The civil society groups also challenge the EU argument that EPAs will integrate ACP states into the world economy, promote sustainable development, and contribute to poverty eradication.
They say rapid trade liberalisation will not automatically lead to this, because ACP countries are being asked to open up to EU goods before they are in a position to compete.
The EU sees this differently. "The EPAs are actually not about opening the market, but about creating regional markets," Claude Veron-Reville, spokesperson for new trade commissioner Peter Mandelson told IPS. The EU wants to help ACP countries ease trade barriers with neighbouring countries to give them experience and prepare them better for world markets, Veron-Reville said.
The NGOs argue that ACP states must be allowed first to consolidate their own regional integration processes that are in most regions still in an early stage.
Veron-Reville argues that the EU is liberalising faster to the ACP than the other way round. But the civil society groups still feel that opening ACP markets to EU imports could undermine rather than support the process.
The report of the civil society groups points out that several ACP leaders have expressed reservations about negotiating EPAs in the manner proposed by the EU. Mauritian trade minister Jayakrishna Cuttaree said recently that "ACP states could not agree that subjects that have been rejected at the WTO should be brought back to the EPA negotiations."
The groups say EPAs would bring a major decline in government income through lost tariff revenue. "This is based on the false assertion that there will be a complete and immediate removal of tariff barriers," says Veron-Reville. She says there is a transition period during which ACP governments have time to find income from other sources. Unlike the civil society groups, she does think these can be found.
"We expect the joint parliamentary assembly to take a strong stand in favour of equity and ACP countries’ right to development," Bibiane Mbaye from the Senegal based international non-governmental organisation ENDA told IPS. "We want them to monitor the process of new trade arrangements between the ACP and the EU for the interest of both parties, so that it is a win-win process."
Whether the joint parliamentary assembly considers the civil society suggestions or not, there are doubts what exactly such an assembly can do. "Negotiations on EPAs are conducted by governments, not by the Joint Parliamentary Assembly," said Ramdien Sardjoe, the Suriname co-president of the ACP-EU assembly. "We only come on stage when it comes to ratifying the results of the negotiations."