Sunday, November 22, 2026
Stefania Bianchi
- The European Union must raise the issue of human rights abuse in China when its leaders meet their Chinese counterparts at a summit this week, say leading human rights groups.
Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch (HRW) are highlighting what they call "widespread and sometimes brutal abuses" within China of people working to promote human rights.
The non-governmental organisations (NGOs) are concerned that the European Union (EU) appetite for economic benefits from closer cooperation with China may outweigh concerns over democracy and human rights.
Chinese premier Wen Jiabao is holding talks with Dutch prime minister Jan Peter Balkenende at The Hague in the Netherlands Dec. 7 and 8. The Netherlands currently holds the rotating EU presidency.
Jiabao will be accompanied by Chinese foreign minister Li Zhaoxing, commerce minister Bo Xilai and agriculture minister Du Qinglin.
He will also meet European Commission president Jose Manuel Barroso and EU foreign policy chief Javier Solana.
But relations between China and the EU have warmed considerably over the past year with many European leaders arguing that the embargo is outdated, and indicating that the bloc is ready to lift the ban.
They say China’s human rights situation has improved significantly since 1989, and that the embargo is no longer justified. French President Jacques Chirac has led the call for resumption of arms sales to China.
Last month Dutch foreign minister Bernard Bot also said that the EU was ready to give a "positive signal" about lifting the ban. He stressed however, that conditions for lifting the ban would include progress by China on human rights.
China argues that human rights issues are unrelated to the arms embargo and should not be considered by the EU.
But Amnesty International and HRW insist that human rights abuses and the arms embargo are linked.
In a 42-page report released Monday (Dec. 6) to coincide with the summit, Amnesty highlights cases of activists who have being arrested on vague charges and put into prisons which it says are known for ill-treatment and torture.
"Those who become openly involved in human rights advocacy in China may face serious human rights violations, including in some cases torture, arbitrary detention and imprisonment," the report says.
Amnesty adds that even though many of those campaigning for better rights are members of groups set up by the government in China, they are vulnerable because their rights are limited and poorly defined.
"Even those working in officially registered civil society organisations may be at risk," it says.
The report details stories of individuals working to protect rights in the spheres of health, housing, labour, and religious and ethnic freedom.
Among the cases highlighted is a man detained for trying to protest against the forced relocation of Beijing families to make way for a new building for the 2008 Olympics, and that of a Chinese woman "beaten to death" in custody for handing out copies of the Bible.
Amnesty is urging EU delegates at Wednesday’s summit to press China to release people in prison for rights activism.
"In talks with the Chinese leadership this week, EU leaders should take into account that while the number of human rights activists is growing, in the China of today they still may be at risk at any time of arrest or imprisonment," said Dick Oosting, director of Amnesty International’s EU office.
"The EU has announced its intention to use this week’s summit to raise its relationship with China to a higher level," he said. "Amnesty International hopes this also means the EU will employ a higher level of scrutiny of China’s harsh treatment of those who dare to speak out, whether it is about HIV/AIDS, housing rights, workers rights, freedom of religion, minority rights or the right to justice."
HRW is backing Amnesty’s calls and is asking that the EU does not let business interests hamper its "longstanding proclaimed commitment" to human rights in China.
"France and some other EU members have made it clear that their interest is commerce and they no longer want to let human rights stand in the way of making money," Brad Adams, Asia director of HRW, said in a statement Monday. "This is profoundly misguided.."
The rights group says the EU should not make concessions in exchange for the release of a few prisoners who did not belong in prison in the first place.
Instead, it says the EU should insist on a general amnesty for all those jailed for all forms of peaceful protest in China and insist on new trials, attended by international observers, for all those convicted of crimes related to the 1989 demonstrations.
In addition, HRW is urging the EU to call for an independent investigation into the events surrounding the massacre.
The group says 15 years later no one has been held publicly accountable for the decision to turn the army against the demonstrators in Tiananmen Square. It adds that there has been no independent investigation of the massacre, no one knows how many were killed or injured, how many were imprisoned, or how many remain in prison.
Adams is urging the EU to realise the serious consequences that its action may have.
"What needs to be remembered is the reason the embargo was created in the first place," he said. "China’s army turned its guns on its own people after receiving orders from the political leadership. There is no sign of the reforms necessary to make the EU comfortable that this won’t happen again. If the ban is lifted, the next attack could be with weapons supplied by EU states."