Africa, Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Europe, Headlines

DEVELOPMENT: EU Sweetener Not Enough

Stefania Bianchi

BRUSSELS, Jan 25 2005 (IPS) - An EU "action plan" to soften the blow from proposed sugar reforms is not good enough, some of the poorest developing countries say.

The proposals presented Monday are "inadequate" and "lacking in detail", a group of African, Caribbean and least developed countries said in their response to the proposals.

The reform proposals by the European Commission, the EU executive, announced last July envisage cutting the guaranteed price of sugar imported by the European Union (EU) from these countries by one-third between 2005 and 2007, and reducing sugar quotas.

As part of its development policy, which has been criticised for unfairly discriminating against sugar producers from other developing countries, the EU currently pays above market rates for sugar from a number of African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) countries, many of them former colonies of European countries.

The preferential access of ACP countries to the EU market currently represents some 70 percent of the revenue of their sugar sectors.

The loss of those privileges when the EU starts paying prices closer to market rates is expected to have a huge economic impact in many ACP countries that are dependent on sugar exports to the EU. The current regime is due to come to an end in 2006.


The EU was forced to change its policies after complaints from major sugar producing countries such as Brazil and Australia which argued that EU subsidies were unfair. The World Trade Organisation (WTO) upheld those complaints in part in October last year..

The "action plan" presented to ACP and least developed countries (LDC) ministers Monday (Jan. 24) sets out EU plans for countries that will suffer as a result of the sugar price cuts.

The Commission says it proposes to enhance the competitiveness of the sugar sector where this is sustainable, promote diversification in sugar-dependent areas, and address broader adaptation needs.

But the plan so far lacks details and figures.

Officials from the affected countries said the proposed reforms were disastrous and would put vulnerable economies and hundreds of thousands of jobs at risk. LDC ministers said the reforms would mean losses to their countries of an estimated 333 million dollars a year.

Mauritian agriculture minister Nandcoomar Bodha who represented the ACP at the Monday meeting said the price cuts and three-year transition period proposed by Brussels were "unbearable" and would "cripple" ACP sugar industries.

Bodha said a core sugar industry was essential for ACP countries "to sustain their economies and democracies."

He urged the EU to grant ACP and other sugar nations a transition period to revamp their industry, notably by focusing more on derivative products such as ethanol.

"Sugar is not a commodity only, it is the cohesive factor of our social fabric," he said. "We believe there should be a lesser (price) cut and we should be given time to adjust to this reform."

The development group Oxfam said the action plan was disappointing.

"There is not enough detail in this plan about where the money is going to come from or how to ensure that the support will be delivered in a timely and effective manner," said Phil Bloomer, head of Oxfam International’s Make Trade Fair campaign.

Bloomer said that in Jamaica alone 32,000 people could lose their jobs, and in Trinidad about 20,000.

"The EU must now enter a dialogue with the ACP and act urgently to address these implications with detailed proposals for immediate financial assistance," he said.

EU trade commissioner Peter Mandelson said Monday that some ACP countries may suffer disruption to their sugar industries, but insisted that the current system was no longer tenable. "Reform is necessary, cannot be put off and should not be watered down," he told ACP ministers.

"We are committed to act quickly to help producers prepare for change rather than just cushioning them against it," he added.

Development commissioner Louis Michel said the bloc would not offer compensation but a response to "specific requests" on the basis of "the actual needs of the countries concerned."

EU officials also turned down calls for a less dramatic cut than the one-third price reduction foreseen.

"If we do not decrease the price considerably, there is no sugar reform," said EU agriculture commissioner Mariann Fischer Boel.

Pointing out that the sugar regime had not been reformed in 40 years, Fischer Boel said she was aware that the proposals would not satisfy all ACP countries.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags